This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/dec/04/labor-senator-katy-gallagher-faces-referral-to-high-court-over-british-citizenship
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 7 | Version 8 |
|---|---|
| Labor senator Katy Gallagher faces referral to high court over British citizenship | Labor senator Katy Gallagher faces referral to high court over British citizenship |
| (3 months later) | |
| The Labor senator Katy Gallagher faces referral to the high court because she was a British citizen on the nomination date for the 2016 election and may therefore be ineligible to sit in parliament. | The Labor senator Katy Gallagher faces referral to the high court because she was a British citizen on the nomination date for the 2016 election and may therefore be ineligible to sit in parliament. |
| Documents made public in the Senate on Monday show that while Gallagher submitted forms to renounce her British citizenship on 20 April 2016, the renunciation was not confirmed until 16 August 2016, well after the 9 June nomination date. | Documents made public in the Senate on Monday show that while Gallagher submitted forms to renounce her British citizenship on 20 April 2016, the renunciation was not confirmed until 16 August 2016, well after the 9 June nomination date. |
| Gallagher, a former chief minister of the ACT, and Labor senator for the territory, claims she is still eligible to sit in parliament because, like Labor MPs Justine Keay and Susan Lamb and Nick Xenophon Team’s Rebekha Sharkie, she took “all steps reasonably required” by foreign law to renounce her dual citizenship. | Gallagher, a former chief minister of the ACT, and Labor senator for the territory, claims she is still eligible to sit in parliament because, like Labor MPs Justine Keay and Susan Lamb and Nick Xenophon Team’s Rebekha Sharkie, she took “all steps reasonably required” by foreign law to renounce her dual citizenship. |
| However, several constitutional law experts have warned it is arguable that reasonable steps are not enough to escape the constitutional disqualification on a strict reading of the high court’s most recent decision in the citizenship seven case. | However, several constitutional law experts have warned it is arguable that reasonable steps are not enough to escape the constitutional disqualification on a strict reading of the high court’s most recent decision in the citizenship seven case. |
| The new eligibility declarations from all senators – a requirement imposed as a consequence of the dual citizenship debacle that has consumed the parliament for months – were released publicly on Monday. | The new eligibility declarations from all senators – a requirement imposed as a consequence of the dual citizenship debacle that has consumed the parliament for months – were released publicly on Monday. |
| The Liberal senator Arthur Sinodinos, who has Greek heritage, said in his eligibility declaration his lawyers had received formal advice from the Greek government confirming he had never been a Greek citizen, or entitled to the rights and privileges of one – but he failed to provide a copy of the legal advice. | The Liberal senator Arthur Sinodinos, who has Greek heritage, said in his eligibility declaration his lawyers had received formal advice from the Greek government confirming he had never been a Greek citizen, or entitled to the rights and privileges of one – but he failed to provide a copy of the legal advice. |
| Section 44 (i) of Australia's constitution bars "citizens of a foreign power" from serving in parliament, including dual citizens, or those entitled to dual citizenship. But the provision was very rarely raised until July 2017, when the Greens senator Scott Ludlam suddenly announced he was quitting parliament after discovering he had New Zealand citizenship. | Section 44 (i) of Australia's constitution bars "citizens of a foreign power" from serving in parliament, including dual citizens, or those entitled to dual citizenship. But the provision was very rarely raised until July 2017, when the Greens senator Scott Ludlam suddenly announced he was quitting parliament after discovering he had New Zealand citizenship. |
| That sparked a succession of cases, beginning with Ludlam’s colleague Larissa Waters, as MPs and senators realised their birthplace or the sometimes obscure implications of their parents’ citizenship could put them in breach. | |
| By October, seven cases had been referred by parliament to the high court, which has the final say on eligibility. They were Ludlam and Waters; the National party leader Barnaby Joyce, deputy leader Fiona Nash and minister Matt Canavan; One Nation’s Malcolm Roberts; and independent Nick Xenophon. | By October, seven cases had been referred by parliament to the high court, which has the final say on eligibility. They were Ludlam and Waters; the National party leader Barnaby Joyce, deputy leader Fiona Nash and minister Matt Canavan; One Nation’s Malcolm Roberts; and independent Nick Xenophon. |
| The court found that five of the seven had been ineligible to stand for parliament, exonerating only Canavan and Xenophon. That meant the senators involved had to be replaced by the next candidate on the ballot at the 2016 federal election, while the sole lower house MP – Joyce – would face a byelection on 2 December in his New South Wales seat of New England. Joyce renounced his New Zealand citizenship and won the seat again. | The court found that five of the seven had been ineligible to stand for parliament, exonerating only Canavan and Xenophon. That meant the senators involved had to be replaced by the next candidate on the ballot at the 2016 federal election, while the sole lower house MP – Joyce – would face a byelection on 2 December in his New South Wales seat of New England. Joyce renounced his New Zealand citizenship and won the seat again. |
| After the court ruling the president of the Senate, the Liberal Stephen Parry, also resigned on dual citizenship grounds. Then MP John Alexander quit, triggering a byelection in his Sydney seat of Bennelong – which he won. Independent Tasmanian senator Jacqui Lambie became the next casualty and NXT senator Skye Kakoschke-Moore soon followed. Labor MP David Feeney also had to quit, but Ged Kearney won his seat of Batman back for the ALP. | |
| The case of senator Katy Gallagher tested the interpretation relied on by Labor that taking ‘reasonable steps’ to renounce citizenship was enough to preserve eligibility. In May 2018 the high court ruled against her, forcing a further three Labor MPs – Justine Keay, Susan Lamb and Josh Wilson – to quit, along with Rebekha Sharkie of the Centre Alliance (formerly NXT). The major parties have agreed that all MPs and senators must now make a formal declaration of their eligibility, disclose foreign citizenship and steps to renounce it. But the constitution cannot be changed without a referendum. | |
| - | |
| Sinodinos’s mother and father were born in Cephalonia in Greece but the Liberal senator said in his declaration that he had never been a citizen of any country other than Australia. | Sinodinos’s mother and father were born in Cephalonia in Greece but the Liberal senator said in his declaration that he had never been a citizen of any country other than Australia. |
| The Liberal senator, who is on leave from the parliament and being treated for cancer, later released a letter from the Greek embassy saying there was no record of his registration in Greece. | The Liberal senator, who is on leave from the parliament and being treated for cancer, later released a letter from the Greek embassy saying there was no record of his registration in Greece. |
| The Senate motion requires documentary evidence only of those who have held citizenship of a foreign country. For completeness, I attach a letter from the Greek Government so as to confirm my status. pic.twitter.com/vlDYZTXibo | The Senate motion requires documentary evidence only of those who have held citizenship of a foreign country. For completeness, I attach a letter from the Greek Government so as to confirm my status. pic.twitter.com/vlDYZTXibo |
| The One Nation senator Peter Georgiou, who was born in Perth, also says he is eligible to sit in parliament, despite his parents and grandparents being born in Greece, but he does not say what steps he took to confirm his eligibility before he nominated for for election. | The One Nation senator Peter Georgiou, who was born in Perth, also says he is eligible to sit in parliament, despite his parents and grandparents being born in Greece, but he does not say what steps he took to confirm his eligibility before he nominated for for election. |
| Georgiou provided a letter, dated 16 November 2017, from the Hellenic Republic Embassy of Greece in Canberra, that says the acquisition of Greek nationality and citizenship can be proven by registration within the municipal and male registries of the Greek state, and no registration exists for Georgiou, so he cannot be considered a Greek citizen or national. | Georgiou provided a letter, dated 16 November 2017, from the Hellenic Republic Embassy of Greece in Canberra, that says the acquisition of Greek nationality and citizenship can be proven by registration within the municipal and male registries of the Greek state, and no registration exists for Georgiou, so he cannot be considered a Greek citizen or national. |
| Georgiou entered parliament in March 2017, replacing Rod Culleton, who was disqualified by the high court under section 44 of the constitution. | Georgiou entered parliament in March 2017, replacing Rod Culleton, who was disqualified by the high court under section 44 of the constitution. |
| The Liberal senator Anne Ruston also declared her paternal grandfather was born in Burwell, England, in 1890, which may have made her father, born in South Australia, a citizen by descent. | The Liberal senator Anne Ruston also declared her paternal grandfather was born in Burwell, England, in 1890, which may have made her father, born in South Australia, a citizen by descent. |
| But Ruston claimed that because neither of her parents had ever “applied for, or registered interest in, obtaining citizenship from the United Kingdom” they were both “solely Australian citizens all of their lives”. She said she had previously sought advice on her eligibility to get a UK passport and was informed she had “no rights to UK citizenship”. | But Ruston claimed that because neither of her parents had ever “applied for, or registered interest in, obtaining citizenship from the United Kingdom” they were both “solely Australian citizens all of their lives”. She said she had previously sought advice on her eligibility to get a UK passport and was informed she had “no rights to UK citizenship”. |
| Liberal senator, Zed Seselja, disclosed that his mother and father were born in the “now defunct” Yugoslavia, in Manja Vas and Dugi Otok in modern-day Croatia. | Liberal senator, Zed Seselja, disclosed that his mother and father were born in the “now defunct” Yugoslavia, in Manja Vas and Dugi Otok in modern-day Croatia. |
| He said he was not a citizen of either country, adding in a further statement that the Croatian president, Kolinda Grabar-Kitarović, had confirmed this to Malcolm Turnbull on a state visit in August. | He said he was not a citizen of either country, adding in a further statement that the Croatian president, Kolinda Grabar-Kitarović, had confirmed this to Malcolm Turnbull on a state visit in August. |
| In a statement issued via Facebook on Monday, Gallagher said she did not believe she should refer herself to the high court but she recognised “ultimately that will be a matter for the Senate to determine”. | In a statement issued via Facebook on Monday, Gallagher said she did not believe she should refer herself to the high court but she recognised “ultimately that will be a matter for the Senate to determine”. |
| Gallagher released legal advice from English barrister Adrian Berry that she had taken “all steps to renounce British citizenship” on 20 April but the same advice states she remained a British citizen until 16 August. In separate constitutional advice, Gallagher’s lawyers claim that the test in Sykes v Cleary, reaffirmed in the “citizenship seven” decision, allowed that a person was eligible if they had taken “all steps reasonably required” to renounce foreign citizenship. | Gallagher released legal advice from English barrister Adrian Berry that she had taken “all steps to renounce British citizenship” on 20 April but the same advice states she remained a British citizen until 16 August. In separate constitutional advice, Gallagher’s lawyers claim that the test in Sykes v Cleary, reaffirmed in the “citizenship seven” decision, allowed that a person was eligible if they had taken “all steps reasonably required” to renounce foreign citizenship. |
| Malcolm Turnbull has released separate legal advice arguing that people who had taken steps to renounce citizenship but were still foreign citizens on nomination date were not eligible. | Malcolm Turnbull has released separate legal advice arguing that people who had taken steps to renounce citizenship but were still foreign citizens on nomination date were not eligible. |
| The high court’s unanimous judgment explicitly warned that section 44 “does not disqualify only those who have not made reasonable efforts to conform to its requirements”. The judgment states that a person who “retains the status of subject or citizen of a foreign power” at the time of nomination will be disqualified “except where the operation of the foreign law is contrary to the constitutional imperative that an Australian citizen not be irremediably prevented by foreign law” from participation in representative government. | The high court’s unanimous judgment explicitly warned that section 44 “does not disqualify only those who have not made reasonable efforts to conform to its requirements”. The judgment states that a person who “retains the status of subject or citizen of a foreign power” at the time of nomination will be disqualified “except where the operation of the foreign law is contrary to the constitutional imperative that an Australian citizen not be irremediably prevented by foreign law” from participation in representative government. |
| University of Sydney constitutional expert Anne Twomey has said the law on reasonable steps is still unclear. “It is possible to argue that a strict reading of the judgment is that a person is disqualified if he or she is a dual citizen at time of nomination regardless of what steps were taken beforehand,” Twomey said. | University of Sydney constitutional expert Anne Twomey has said the law on reasonable steps is still unclear. “It is possible to argue that a strict reading of the judgment is that a person is disqualified if he or she is a dual citizen at time of nomination regardless of what steps were taken beforehand,” Twomey said. |
| As well as the declarations in the Senate, a resolution covering members of the House of Representatives passed through the lower house on Monday, with declarations expected by mid-week. | As well as the declarations in the Senate, a resolution covering members of the House of Representatives passed through the lower house on Monday, with declarations expected by mid-week. |
| The new Senate declarations suggest that a handful of senators had historical problems with dual citizenships – the Liberal Dean Smith, the Green Nick McKim, and the Labor senators Louise Pratt and Lisa Singh. | The new Senate declarations suggest that a handful of senators had historical problems with dual citizenships – the Liberal Dean Smith, the Green Nick McKim, and the Labor senators Louise Pratt and Lisa Singh. |
| The Labor senator Sam Dastyari also outlined the exhaustive steps he took to renounce his Iranian citizenship over the months leading to his arrival in the Senate in August 2013. | The Labor senator Sam Dastyari also outlined the exhaustive steps he took to renounce his Iranian citizenship over the months leading to his arrival in the Senate in August 2013. |
| Australian citizenship | Australian citizenship |
| Australian politics | Australian politics |
| Labor party | Labor party |
| Arthur Sinodinos | Arthur Sinodinos |
| Liberal party | Liberal party |
| One Nation | One Nation |
| news | news |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |