This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/australia-news/2017/nov/25/real-jeopardy-independent-panel-lays-into-murray-darling-basin-management
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| 'Real jeopardy': independent panel lays into Murray-Darling basin management | 'Real jeopardy': independent panel lays into Murray-Darling basin management |
| (25 days later) | |
| An independent panel has delivered a scathing assessment of the Murray-Darling Basin Authority’s leadership in managing the plan for Australia’s inland river system, warning the plan is being placed in “real jeopardy”. | An independent panel has delivered a scathing assessment of the Murray-Darling Basin Authority’s leadership in managing the plan for Australia’s inland river system, warning the plan is being placed in “real jeopardy”. |
| It has concluded the Murray-Darling Basin Authority (MDBA) has been “unable to assert its authority during the development of water resource plans” and had not taken a strong enough role in ensuring compliance, which is largely the responsibility of the states. | It has concluded the Murray-Darling Basin Authority (MDBA) has been “unable to assert its authority during the development of water resource plans” and had not taken a strong enough role in ensuring compliance, which is largely the responsibility of the states. |
| The ABC Four Corners report in July revealed that despite recommendations from compliance teams on the ground for prosecutions in New South Wales for water theft and meter tampering, there had been little action from the NSW Office of Water. | The ABC Four Corners report in July revealed that despite recommendations from compliance teams on the ground for prosecutions in New South Wales for water theft and meter tampering, there had been little action from the NSW Office of Water. |
| The NSW Ombudsman last week delivered a report revealing its concerns that the lack of prosecutions had been ignored by successive NSW water ministers. | The NSW Ombudsman last week delivered a report revealing its concerns that the lack of prosecutions had been ignored by successive NSW water ministers. |
| Releasing this latest report – on the federal side of water management – the prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, said: “Water theft is a crime – pure and simple. All Australians need confidence the rules governing water use are applied fairly, without fear or favour.” | Releasing this latest report – on the federal side of water management – the prime minister, Malcolm Turnbull, said: “Water theft is a crime – pure and simple. All Australians need confidence the rules governing water use are applied fairly, without fear or favour.” |
| The independent report, which is contained within another by the authority, highlights dramatically different enforcement cultures among the states, with NSW and Queensland far more lax than South Australia and Victoria. | The independent report, which is contained within another by the authority, highlights dramatically different enforcement cultures among the states, with NSW and Queensland far more lax than South Australia and Victoria. |
| In its document, the authority concedes it has not given enough attention to compliance. In an extraordinary admission, it says it “has not dealt adequately with allegations of compliance breaches”. | In its document, the authority concedes it has not given enough attention to compliance. In an extraordinary admission, it says it “has not dealt adequately with allegations of compliance breaches”. |
| The Guardian has reported that the authority knew there was widespread water theft taking place in the Barwon-Darling basin a year before the Four Corners program, after staff trialling a program using satellite imagery reported that it was probably taking place. However, nothing was done. | The Guardian has reported that the authority knew there was widespread water theft taking place in the Barwon-Darling basin a year before the Four Corners program, after staff trialling a program using satellite imagery reported that it was probably taking place. However, nothing was done. |
| The authority has now come up with 11 recommendations for action and greater co-ordination among governments. | The authority has now come up with 11 recommendations for action and greater co-ordination among governments. |
| “This review was imperative. Without it we were likely to be faced at 30 June 2019 [the deadline for states to meet their water recovery] with the prospect of the Basin Plan being placed in real jeopardy caused in part by a lack of action on the part of the MDBA but to a not insignificant extent by the failure of states to deliver on their commitments.” | “This review was imperative. Without it we were likely to be faced at 30 June 2019 [the deadline for states to meet their water recovery] with the prospect of the Basin Plan being placed in real jeopardy caused in part by a lack of action on the part of the MDBA but to a not insignificant extent by the failure of states to deliver on their commitments.” |
| The independent report said there had been insufficient progress on two important compliance areas: accreditation of water resource plans and protection of environmental water. | The independent report said there had been insufficient progress on two important compliance areas: accreditation of water resource plans and protection of environmental water. |
| The report has recommended, and the authority seems to have accepted, that it should be the “last resort” for breaches. | The report has recommended, and the authority seems to have accepted, that it should be the “last resort” for breaches. |
| “The review clearly shows that all basin governments need to lift their game and better enforce their water laws, Turnbull said. | “The review clearly shows that all basin governments need to lift their game and better enforce their water laws, Turnbull said. |
| “Specifically, we need improved metering, protected environmental flows and proper resourcing of compliance and enforcement activities,” he said. | “Specifically, we need improved metering, protected environmental flows and proper resourcing of compliance and enforcement activities,” he said. |