This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/nov/09/the-guardian-view-on-trump-in-china-a-bromance-unlikely-to-run-smooth
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| The Guardian view on Trump in China: a bromance unlikely to run smooth | The Guardian view on Trump in China: a bromance unlikely to run smooth |
| (11 days later) | |
| Mao once observed that a revolution is not a dinner party. Neither are great power relations – even if they manifest temporarily as a lavish meal in the Forbidden City. Wednesday’s feast for Donald Trump was the first time the palace in central Beijing had hosted a banquet for a foreign leader since the Communist party took power in 1949. Beijing, adept at ladling on such flattery, pitched this leg of the US president’s Asia tour as a “state visit-plus” and arranged a greeting party of children to cry: “Welcome to China! I love you!” | Mao once observed that a revolution is not a dinner party. Neither are great power relations – even if they manifest temporarily as a lavish meal in the Forbidden City. Wednesday’s feast for Donald Trump was the first time the palace in central Beijing had hosted a banquet for a foreign leader since the Communist party took power in 1949. Beijing, adept at ladling on such flattery, pitched this leg of the US president’s Asia tour as a “state visit-plus” and arranged a greeting party of children to cry: “Welcome to China! I love you!” |
| It seems to have worked – for now. The visit’s arrangements were magnificent, incredible, beautiful, impressive, terrific and unforgettable, Mr Trump enthused. His description of his “great chemistry” with Xi Jinping – a “very special man” to whom he has “an incredibly warm” feeling – made it sound like a fully fledged bromance. (He too was presumably soft-soaping – but which leader seems more easily swayed?) The man who accused China of raping the US economy and promised to label it a currency manipulator on his first day in office (he still hasn’t) said the trade relationship was unfair: but he blamed his predecessors, not Beijing. He tweeted that he is looking forward to building “an even STRONGER relationship”. | It seems to have worked – for now. The visit’s arrangements were magnificent, incredible, beautiful, impressive, terrific and unforgettable, Mr Trump enthused. His description of his “great chemistry” with Xi Jinping – a “very special man” to whom he has “an incredibly warm” feeling – made it sound like a fully fledged bromance. (He too was presumably soft-soaping – but which leader seems more easily swayed?) The man who accused China of raping the US economy and promised to label it a currency manipulator on his first day in office (he still hasn’t) said the trade relationship was unfair: but he blamed his predecessors, not Beijing. He tweeted that he is looking forward to building “an even STRONGER relationship”. |
| That Mr Trump seems to enjoy visiting authoritarian countries more than traditional democratic allies has already been noted. He is uninterested in paying even lip service to human rights issues, such as the activists and dissidents harassed or placed under house arrest for his visit. America’s retreat from global leadership is a gift to Beijing; this week we learned that the US will be the only country outside the Paris accord if the president follows through on his pledge to leave, while Mr Xi has positioned China as the champion of action on climate change. | That Mr Trump seems to enjoy visiting authoritarian countries more than traditional democratic allies has already been noted. He is uninterested in paying even lip service to human rights issues, such as the activists and dissidents harassed or placed under house arrest for his visit. America’s retreat from global leadership is a gift to Beijing; this week we learned that the US will be the only country outside the Paris accord if the president follows through on his pledge to leave, while Mr Xi has positioned China as the champion of action on climate change. |
| But it is hard to believe this love is built to last. Mr Trump is predictable chiefly in his inconsistency (demonstrated already in his approach to China, as well as elsewhere). Mr Xi’s remark that the two nations’ interests were “closely converging” seems, to put it mildly, a stretch. Individual deals do nothing to address structural trade issues – and many of those signed in Beijing were non-binding statements of intent. Shared anger at North Korea cannot disguise very different interests and priorities. The administration’s talk of the “Indo-Pacific” (extending the region to include India as a counterweight) and Mr Trump’s golf-buddy rapport with Japan’s Shinzo Abe (another expert ego-stroker, who handed over a baseball cap reading “Donald and Shinzo: Make Alliance Even Greater”) underscore concerns about China’s rise. In the US, views on Beijing are hardening. | But it is hard to believe this love is built to last. Mr Trump is predictable chiefly in his inconsistency (demonstrated already in his approach to China, as well as elsewhere). Mr Xi’s remark that the two nations’ interests were “closely converging” seems, to put it mildly, a stretch. Individual deals do nothing to address structural trade issues – and many of those signed in Beijing were non-binding statements of intent. Shared anger at North Korea cannot disguise very different interests and priorities. The administration’s talk of the “Indo-Pacific” (extending the region to include India as a counterweight) and Mr Trump’s golf-buddy rapport with Japan’s Shinzo Abe (another expert ego-stroker, who handed over a baseball cap reading “Donald and Shinzo: Make Alliance Even Greater”) underscore concerns about China’s rise. In the US, views on Beijing are hardening. |
| China’s disdain for the US is increasingly clear, among the population as well as in the leadership. So is its increasing confidence in the world and open embrace of global ambitions. It has spent years pouring money into its military as it attempts to catch up with the US; this year it opened its first foreign military base. Its mammoth One Belt, One Road international infrastructure project is another indication of its regional ambitions. But the clearest one came at last month’s Communist party congress. It was notable not only for cementing Mr Xi’s immense power (the “great political victory” applauded by Mr Trump), but also for its trumpeting of a resurgent China, regaining its rightful place in the world – and reshaping the rules as it does so. As Mr Xi spelt out, “It will be an era that sees China moving closer to centre stage” and becoming a model for others. His vision of “great power diplomacy with Chinese characteristics” will no doubt include more cosy dinners, but overall the US and others will find it hard to stomach. | China’s disdain for the US is increasingly clear, among the population as well as in the leadership. So is its increasing confidence in the world and open embrace of global ambitions. It has spent years pouring money into its military as it attempts to catch up with the US; this year it opened its first foreign military base. Its mammoth One Belt, One Road international infrastructure project is another indication of its regional ambitions. But the clearest one came at last month’s Communist party congress. It was notable not only for cementing Mr Xi’s immense power (the “great political victory” applauded by Mr Trump), but also for its trumpeting of a resurgent China, regaining its rightful place in the world – and reshaping the rules as it does so. As Mr Xi spelt out, “It will be an era that sees China moving closer to centre stage” and becoming a model for others. His vision of “great power diplomacy with Chinese characteristics” will no doubt include more cosy dinners, but overall the US and others will find it hard to stomach. |
| China | China |
| Opinion | Opinion |
| Donald Trump | Donald Trump |
| Xi Jinping | Xi Jinping |
| Asia Pacific | Asia Pacific |
| Communism | Communism |
| US foreign policy | US foreign policy |
| editorials | editorials |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |