This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/education/2017/oct/04/women-only-cambridge-college-to-allow-students-who-identify-as-female-murray-edwards
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Women-only Cambridge college to allow students who 'identify as female' | Women-only Cambridge college to allow students who 'identify as female' |
| (4 months later) | |
| Murray Edwards admissions policy change welcomed by gender diversity campaigners but decried by some feminists | |
| Matthew Weaver | |
| Wed 4 Oct 2017 10.22 BST | |
| Last modified on Wed 4 Oct 2017 21.09 BST | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| View more sharing options | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Close | |
| A women-only Cambridge college has changed its admissions policy to allow it to accept transgender students who identify as female. | A women-only Cambridge college has changed its admissions policy to allow it to accept transgender students who identify as female. |
| The decision by Murray Edwards College, formerly known as New Hall, has been attacked by some feminists as illogical but welcomed by campaigners for gender diversity. | The decision by Murray Edwards College, formerly known as New Hall, has been attacked by some feminists as illogical but welcomed by campaigners for gender diversity. |
| The college, whose alumni include the broadcaster Mishal Husain, the comedian Sue Perkins and the actor Tilda Swinton, said it sympathised with the idea that gender is not binary and will support those who do not wish to define themselves as either female or male. | The college, whose alumni include the broadcaster Mishal Husain, the comedian Sue Perkins and the actor Tilda Swinton, said it sympathised with the idea that gender is not binary and will support those who do not wish to define themselves as either female or male. |
| The college used to follow the admissions policy of Cambridge University’s two other women-only colleges, Newnham and Lucy Cavendish, which only accept applicants who are legally recognised as women. | The college used to follow the admissions policy of Cambridge University’s two other women-only colleges, Newnham and Lucy Cavendish, which only accept applicants who are legally recognised as women. |
| But after a decision by its council, Murray Edwards will now be open to students who identify as a woman and have “taken steps to live in the female gender”. | But after a decision by its council, Murray Edwards will now be open to students who identify as a woman and have “taken steps to live in the female gender”. |
| Lucy Cavendish is expected to adopt a similar change when its council meets on Wednesday. | Lucy Cavendish is expected to adopt a similar change when its council meets on Wednesday. |
| Announcing its change Dame Barbara Stocking, the president of Murray Edwards College, said: “We are a college that is open to all outstanding young women and so it is absolutely right, both legally and within our set of values, for anyone who identifies as female to be able to apply to study with us. | Announcing its change Dame Barbara Stocking, the president of Murray Edwards College, said: “We are a college that is open to all outstanding young women and so it is absolutely right, both legally and within our set of values, for anyone who identifies as female to be able to apply to study with us. |
| “There is now a greater understanding of the complexities of gender. In order that we remain true to our mission of being open to all outstanding young women we recognise that it is right for anyone who identifies as female, regardless of their born gender, to be able to apply to study with us.” | “There is now a greater understanding of the complexities of gender. In order that we remain true to our mission of being open to all outstanding young women we recognise that it is right for anyone who identifies as female, regardless of their born gender, to be able to apply to study with us.” |
| In a statement about the new policy, the college said: “Many of us within the college have sympathy with the idea that gender is not binary and have concerns that narrow gender identities and the expectations associated with them are damaging both to individuals and to wider society. | In a statement about the new policy, the college said: “Many of us within the college have sympathy with the idea that gender is not binary and have concerns that narrow gender identities and the expectations associated with them are damaging both to individuals and to wider society. |
| “At the admissions level, we will consider any student who, at the point of application, identifies as female and, where they have been identified as male at birth, has taken steps to live in the female gender.” | “At the admissions level, we will consider any student who, at the point of application, identifies as female and, where they have been identified as male at birth, has taken steps to live in the female gender.” |
| Germaine Greer, who has lectured at Newnham, described the decision as “ridiculous”. | Germaine Greer, who has lectured at Newnham, described the decision as “ridiculous”. |
| “If they [Murray Edwards] really don’t believe that gender is binary, then they really shouldn’t be a single sex college,” she told the Telegraph. | “If they [Murray Edwards] really don’t believe that gender is binary, then they really shouldn’t be a single sex college,” she told the Telegraph. |
| Victoria Smith, a publisher who writes on the blog Feminist Current, made a similar point: | Victoria Smith, a publisher who writes on the blog Feminist Current, made a similar point: |
| Why have single-sex colleges if admission is based only on ‘self-identity’? https://t.co/3iq2P3YQqI | Why have single-sex colleges if admission is based only on ‘self-identity’? https://t.co/3iq2P3YQqI |
| She said the decision would end women-only spaces at the college. She wrote: “Once a college’s admissions policy is based on an unverifiable inner sense of self – the kind of thing non-sophisticates call ‘personality’ – then it is no longer an exclusive space. Which is fine if you think any and all exclusion is bad, but ridiculous if you still want to cling on to an exclusive status.” | She said the decision would end women-only spaces at the college. She wrote: “Once a college’s admissions policy is based on an unverifiable inner sense of self – the kind of thing non-sophisticates call ‘personality’ – then it is no longer an exclusive space. Which is fine if you think any and all exclusion is bad, but ridiculous if you still want to cling on to an exclusive status.” |
| In response to the criticism, Stocking said: “We want women to get the best from Cambridge and a lot of that will involve working with men, but because there is so much gender inequality in the world we believe there is a need for a place such as ours that has a special and additional focus on women’s learning to meet the challenges of the workplace.” | In response to the criticism, Stocking said: “We want women to get the best from Cambridge and a lot of that will involve working with men, but because there is so much gender inequality in the world we believe there is a need for a place such as ours that has a special and additional focus on women’s learning to meet the challenges of the workplace.” |
| Mermaids, a charity which supports gender diverse and transgender children and teenagers, thanked the college for “accepting and embracing all young women”. | Mermaids, a charity which supports gender diverse and transgender children and teenagers, thanked the college for “accepting and embracing all young women”. |
| Thank you @Cambridge_Uni for accepting & embracing ALL young women.Education always wins over ignorance & fear.https://t.co/kf0j51rEqd | Thank you @Cambridge_Uni for accepting & embracing ALL young women.Education always wins over ignorance & fear.https://t.co/kf0j51rEqd |
| Celia Macleod, the chair of the Gender Identity Research and Education Society also welcomed the decision. | Celia Macleod, the chair of the Gender Identity Research and Education Society also welcomed the decision. |
| University of Cambridge | |
| Transgender | |
| Higher education | |
| Gender | |
| Sexuality | |
| LGBT rights | |
| news | |
| Share on Facebook | |
| Share on Twitter | |
| Share via Email | |
| Share on LinkedIn | |
| Share on Pinterest | |
| Share on Google+ | |
| Share on WhatsApp | |
| Share on Messenger | |
| Reuse this content |