This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/world/2017/jul/09/good-news-from-mosul-does-not-signal-the-end-of-islamic-state
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Good news from Mosul does not signal the end of Islamic State | Good news from Mosul does not signal the end of Islamic State |
| (6 days later) | |
| It is almost exactly three years since Islamic State’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, proclaimed a caliphate from the pulpit of the medieval Great Mosque of al-Nuri in Mosul, following a stunning Isis sweep through large areas of Iraq and Syria. | It is almost exactly three years since Islamic State’s leader, Abu Bakr al-Baghdadi, proclaimed a caliphate from the pulpit of the medieval Great Mosque of al-Nuri in Mosul, following a stunning Isis sweep through large areas of Iraq and Syria. |
| Three years later, Iraq’s second city is mostly back under the control of government forces, Isis has been largely confined to the Syrian city of Raqqa and desert areas of western Iraq, and Baghdadi is missing, reported killed. | Three years later, Iraq’s second city is mostly back under the control of government forces, Isis has been largely confined to the Syrian city of Raqqa and desert areas of western Iraq, and Baghdadi is missing, reported killed. |
| The al-Nuri mosque, like much of Mosul, is in ruins. Mosul’s residents have paid a steep price. Thousands have been killed or wounded – murdered by the jihadists, blown up in air raids by the US-led anti-Isis coalition or killed after being caught in street fighting. | The al-Nuri mosque, like much of Mosul, is in ruins. Mosul’s residents have paid a steep price. Thousands have been killed or wounded – murdered by the jihadists, blown up in air raids by the US-led anti-Isis coalition or killed after being caught in street fighting. |
| The jihadists’ many atrocities in Mosul and elsewhere brought them global infamy. About 1 million city residents are now displaced, many among them ill or malnourished. Reconstruction will be a major challenge. It will take years, assuming the peace holds; some fighting was still continuing on Sunday. | The jihadists’ many atrocities in Mosul and elsewhere brought them global infamy. About 1 million city residents are now displaced, many among them ill or malnourished. Reconstruction will be a major challenge. It will take years, assuming the peace holds; some fighting was still continuing on Sunday. |
| Iraq’s prime minister, Haider al-Abadi, was quick to claim credit for the city’s liberation, making a visit in person on Sunday. But Abadi and his predecessor, Nouri al-Maliki, also bear some responsibility for losing control in the first place. | Iraq’s prime minister, Haider al-Abadi, was quick to claim credit for the city’s liberation, making a visit in person on Sunday. But Abadi and his predecessor, Nouri al-Maliki, also bear some responsibility for losing control in the first place. |
| Few people outside of Iraq and Syria predicted Isis’s rise or its victorious advance in 2014. With hindsight, it became clear the group fed on fierce resentment among Iraq’s Sunni Muslim minority at the failure of the Shia-led Baghdad government to provide equal treatment. Some in Mosul initially welcomed its arrival. | Few people outside of Iraq and Syria predicted Isis’s rise or its victorious advance in 2014. With hindsight, it became clear the group fed on fierce resentment among Iraq’s Sunni Muslim minority at the failure of the Shia-led Baghdad government to provide equal treatment. Some in Mosul initially welcomed its arrival. |
| This failure occurred despite repeated outside efforts, principally by the US, to induce Maliki and his backers to allow meaningful power-sharing with the Sunnis and Iraq’s other large minority, the Kurds. | This failure occurred despite repeated outside efforts, principally by the US, to induce Maliki and his backers to allow meaningful power-sharing with the Sunnis and Iraq’s other large minority, the Kurds. |
| Maliki’s allies in Iran’s Shia-led regime were also to blame. Having been inadvertently handed an un-dreamed-of degree of influence in post-invasion Iraq by the ineptitude of George W Bush, Tehran was not going to surrender it easily. | Maliki’s allies in Iran’s Shia-led regime were also to blame. Having been inadvertently handed an un-dreamed-of degree of influence in post-invasion Iraq by the ineptitude of George W Bush, Tehran was not going to surrender it easily. |
| Although Iranian-backed Shia militias have played a significant role in pushing Isis back from Ramadi, Tikrit and other cities, Iran’s highly visible role, and corrosive Sunni-Shia rivalry, may continue to have a negative impact. | Although Iranian-backed Shia militias have played a significant role in pushing Isis back from Ramadi, Tikrit and other cities, Iran’s highly visible role, and corrosive Sunni-Shia rivalry, may continue to have a negative impact. |
| To some degree, the imperative of defeating Isis united Iraq’s disparate forces. Now, the temporarily submerged fault lines between Arabs and Kurds, Sunnis and Shias, may re-emerge. | To some degree, the imperative of defeating Isis united Iraq’s disparate forces. Now, the temporarily submerged fault lines between Arabs and Kurds, Sunnis and Shias, may re-emerge. |
| Mosul has had a very rough time. But it remains a multi-ethnic city that will not necessarily welcome resumed direct rule by an unpopular government in Baghdad. | Mosul has had a very rough time. But it remains a multi-ethnic city that will not necessarily welcome resumed direct rule by an unpopular government in Baghdad. |
| The Kurds’ part in success against Isis, achieved in alliance with US special forces and the western coalition, will further boost the local and international profile of the quasi-autonomous Kurdish regional government in northern Iraq. The KRG plans to hold an independence referendum in September, which could prospectively lead to Iraq’s partition. There is also growing momentum behind greater cooperation with Syrian Kurdish groups opposed to rule from Damascus. | The Kurds’ part in success against Isis, achieved in alliance with US special forces and the western coalition, will further boost the local and international profile of the quasi-autonomous Kurdish regional government in northern Iraq. The KRG plans to hold an independence referendum in September, which could prospectively lead to Iraq’s partition. There is also growing momentum behind greater cooperation with Syrian Kurdish groups opposed to rule from Damascus. |
| The US now faces some complex issues. The vexed question of how long US forces remain in Iraq, and whether they will indefinitely prop up Abadi’s government, will return to the fore. The Pentagon does not appear to anticipate an early exit. It has requested a budget of $1.27bn in 2018 to continue to support Iraqi forces. But if there is a long-term US strategy it is a well-kept secret. | The US now faces some complex issues. The vexed question of how long US forces remain in Iraq, and whether they will indefinitely prop up Abadi’s government, will return to the fore. The Pentagon does not appear to anticipate an early exit. It has requested a budget of $1.27bn in 2018 to continue to support Iraqi forces. But if there is a long-term US strategy it is a well-kept secret. |
| Politically speaking, the Trump administration will doubtless crow about Mosul and see in it a harbinger of imminent success in Raqqa. Donald Trump may even claim he has fulfilled his campaign pledge to “eliminate” Isis. | Politically speaking, the Trump administration will doubtless crow about Mosul and see in it a harbinger of imminent success in Raqqa. Donald Trump may even claim he has fulfilled his campaign pledge to “eliminate” Isis. |
| That would be decidedly premature. The jihadists may be losing their territorial bases, but their warped ideology has not been vanquished. The group will continue to propagate its hateful ideas online. Its fighters will probably continue to wage an insurgent campaign. And they may now be additionally motivated to take the fight to the “enemy”, meaning a possible future rise in attacks on European soil. There is plenty of anecdotal evidence that battle-hardened fighters are returning to their European countries of origin. | That would be decidedly premature. The jihadists may be losing their territorial bases, but their warped ideology has not been vanquished. The group will continue to propagate its hateful ideas online. Its fighters will probably continue to wage an insurgent campaign. And they may now be additionally motivated to take the fight to the “enemy”, meaning a possible future rise in attacks on European soil. There is plenty of anecdotal evidence that battle-hardened fighters are returning to their European countries of origin. |
| The news from Mosul is good. But Isis is down, not out. | The news from Mosul is good. But Isis is down, not out. |
| Islamic State | Islamic State |
| Iraq | Iraq |
| Mosul | Mosul |
| Middle East and North Africa | Middle East and North Africa |
| Trump administration | Trump administration |
| analysis | analysis |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |