This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/commentisfree/2017/jun/16/house-grenfell-homeless-expropriate-empty-property
The article has changed 5 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Where to house the Grenfell homeless? Expropriate the rich’s empty investments | Where to house the Grenfell homeless? Expropriate the rich’s empty investments |
| (17 days later) | |
| As the horror of the Grenfell Tower fire is gradually revealed, we already know that people are homeless and traumatised, having lost everything, and sometimes everyone they care about. They are bereft, shattered, devastated and in need of help to soothe their sorrow, and of assistance for their practical needs. | As the horror of the Grenfell Tower fire is gradually revealed, we already know that people are homeless and traumatised, having lost everything, and sometimes everyone they care about. They are bereft, shattered, devastated and in need of help to soothe their sorrow, and of assistance for their practical needs. |
| But one particular aspect is easy to make better, isn’t it? Placing survivors of this horror in London’s vacant property, as David Lammy and Jeremy Corbyn have rightly suggested, is pleasingly and exquisitely simple in its justice (in fact, let’s house all homeless people in the capital’s empty flats). | But one particular aspect is easy to make better, isn’t it? Placing survivors of this horror in London’s vacant property, as David Lammy and Jeremy Corbyn have rightly suggested, is pleasingly and exquisitely simple in its justice (in fact, let’s house all homeless people in the capital’s empty flats). |
| Stay calm, oh poor benighted rentier class; we can already hear your shrill, entitled whining. Be silent, you wailing investor; we are not coming for your home, we will not evict your family from the country pile. But all those flats you snap up then keep empty to accumulate unearned, undeserved wealth? Let people live in them. | Stay calm, oh poor benighted rentier class; we can already hear your shrill, entitled whining. Be silent, you wailing investor; we are not coming for your home, we will not evict your family from the country pile. But all those flats you snap up then keep empty to accumulate unearned, undeserved wealth? Let people live in them. |
| Proudhon applies here. Property really is theft when it is grasped greedily and then hoarded, when every home suitable for first-time buyers is placed out of reach. Developments that should contain homes for people to live in are appropriated by the rentier class. This is a major problem in London, but also happens wherever the buy-to-let development industry is rampant – Manchester especially. | Proudhon applies here. Property really is theft when it is grasped greedily and then hoarded, when every home suitable for first-time buyers is placed out of reach. Developments that should contain homes for people to live in are appropriated by the rentier class. This is a major problem in London, but also happens wherever the buy-to-let development industry is rampant – Manchester especially. |
| How many empty homes are there in London? Tens of thousands. Not all are gorgeous mansions in the sky; some are quite ordinary flats but pass for luxurious under London’s febrile through-the-looking-glass housing market, where an ordinary Edwardian terrace in Fulham built to house the working class is now drooled over by millionaires. | How many empty homes are there in London? Tens of thousands. Not all are gorgeous mansions in the sky; some are quite ordinary flats but pass for luxurious under London’s febrile through-the-looking-glass housing market, where an ordinary Edwardian terrace in Fulham built to house the working class is now drooled over by millionaires. |
| When investors have outbid even those few locals who might afford to buy them, do they then live there? Sometimes. Rent them out for a massive profit? Occasionally. All too often new property is bought off-plan by overseas investors who treat robust housing like fragile porcelain ornamental houses, keeping them empty and clear of polluting tenants. | When investors have outbid even those few locals who might afford to buy them, do they then live there? Sometimes. Rent them out for a massive profit? Occasionally. All too often new property is bought off-plan by overseas investors who treat robust housing like fragile porcelain ornamental houses, keeping them empty and clear of polluting tenants. |
| Wander through neighbourhoods favoured by investors and the first thing you notice is silence. There are frequently no children, not even any teenagers hanging around. Some homes are bought by overseas clients who never see what they own, and who, given the amount of equity they have already acquired, have made a fortune by sitting still and doing nothing. | Wander through neighbourhoods favoured by investors and the first thing you notice is silence. There are frequently no children, not even any teenagers hanging around. Some homes are bought by overseas clients who never see what they own, and who, given the amount of equity they have already acquired, have made a fortune by sitting still and doing nothing. |
| So let’s nationalise them. Let’s place them in the hands of councils so desperate for affordable homes that they ship homeless people to Peterborough, away from all they know and everything they hold dear. | So let’s nationalise them. Let’s place them in the hands of councils so desperate for affordable homes that they ship homeless people to Peterborough, away from all they know and everything they hold dear. |
| Vast gated estates of empty investment shells with poor doors render neighbourhoods eerily bleak. Housing Grenfell Tower survivors together would revitalise arid property prairies where nobody lives but where rich people invest. Squatting is so restricted by new laws as to be impossible, so that option is closed. Kindly expropriation – owners could even be paid rents by government – will open up empty flats, even entire blocks, ideally containing top-of-the-range sprinkler systems and with all cladding the best that money can buy. These properties will be fireproof, shiny and classy, with all internal fittings extravagant. The grander, the better. | Vast gated estates of empty investment shells with poor doors render neighbourhoods eerily bleak. Housing Grenfell Tower survivors together would revitalise arid property prairies where nobody lives but where rich people invest. Squatting is so restricted by new laws as to be impossible, so that option is closed. Kindly expropriation – owners could even be paid rents by government – will open up empty flats, even entire blocks, ideally containing top-of-the-range sprinkler systems and with all cladding the best that money can buy. These properties will be fireproof, shiny and classy, with all internal fittings extravagant. The grander, the better. |
| I can envisage mass compulsory purchase orders affecting not the poorer people in the way of a new development, as is generally the case, but displacing those who collect a property portfolio as others hoard boxed Stars Wars figures. These property owners do nothing except splurge at an auction overseas (many councils even visit the property market in Cannes to encourage them). The money amassed by the privileged few is obscene. | I can envisage mass compulsory purchase orders affecting not the poorer people in the way of a new development, as is generally the case, but displacing those who collect a property portfolio as others hoard boxed Stars Wars figures. These property owners do nothing except splurge at an auction overseas (many councils even visit the property market in Cannes to encourage them). The money amassed by the privileged few is obscene. |
| In most of London, property has been earning more each year from rising prices than a firefighter does from saving lives. Empty property should be bought up, then placed under a brand new arm’s-length management organisation. After which, I suggest, leave it in perpetuity as social housing. Otherwise, who will teach, drive and serve coffee to London’s rich? | In most of London, property has been earning more each year from rising prices than a firefighter does from saving lives. Empty property should be bought up, then placed under a brand new arm’s-length management organisation. After which, I suggest, leave it in perpetuity as social housing. Otherwise, who will teach, drive and serve coffee to London’s rich? |
| And if these properties are top-end flats, with swimming pools and a concierge, marble fittings, en-suites throughout and balconies with a view? Even better. After what they have been through, this wonderful, strong community deserves the very best that investors could buy. | And if these properties are top-end flats, with swimming pools and a concierge, marble fittings, en-suites throughout and balconies with a view? Even better. After what they have been through, this wonderful, strong community deserves the very best that investors could buy. |