This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/healthcare-network/2017/jun/13/shunned-studying-medicine-become-nurse
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| I shunned studying medicine to become a nurse. Here's why | I shunned studying medicine to become a nurse. Here's why |
| (about 1 month later) | |
| “A nurse? | “A nurse? |
| “You want to be … a nurse?” | “You want to be … a nurse?” |
| There it is again. The surprise, the raise of the eyebrow, the uncomfortable pause. Followed by one of two responses: the overly-enthusiastic and evidently forced “good for you”, or the honest “but, why? Surely you’d rather be a doctor?” | There it is again. The surprise, the raise of the eyebrow, the uncomfortable pause. Followed by one of two responses: the overly-enthusiastic and evidently forced “good for you”, or the honest “but, why? Surely you’d rather be a doctor?” |
| The surprise is understandable; I don’t have the most conventional background for nursing. At school I pursued both science and humanities to A-level before landing a place at Cambridge to read history of art. Wooed by the hedonism of student media, I pursued a career in entertainment television, dismissing my long-standing passion for nursing as a romantic daydream, sparked by the literature of Vera Brittain and Florence Nightingale. | The surprise is understandable; I don’t have the most conventional background for nursing. At school I pursued both science and humanities to A-level before landing a place at Cambridge to read history of art. Wooed by the hedonism of student media, I pursued a career in entertainment television, dismissing my long-standing passion for nursing as a romantic daydream, sparked by the literature of Vera Brittain and Florence Nightingale. |
| However, with each year my passion grew rather than waned and I realised it was more than a passing phase. So at Christmas I decided to turn my back on an industry I had fought so hard to get into, and applied for the two-year postgraduate diploma in adult nursing. | However, with each year my passion grew rather than waned and I realised it was more than a passing phase. So at Christmas I decided to turn my back on an industry I had fought so hard to get into, and applied for the two-year postgraduate diploma in adult nursing. |
| At first I wasn’t brave enough to shun societal expectation and for a while I considered applying to study graduate medicine. I recall one particular conversation with my mother where she described how she’d spent her life being “just” a nurse and aspired for her daughter to aim higher – evidence of how the longstanding prejudice surrounding the profession is passed between generations. | At first I wasn’t brave enough to shun societal expectation and for a while I considered applying to study graduate medicine. I recall one particular conversation with my mother where she described how she’d spent her life being “just” a nurse and aspired for her daughter to aim higher – evidence of how the longstanding prejudice surrounding the profession is passed between generations. |
| After working as a healthcare assistant in a busy London trust my suspicions were confirmed: it was the work of the nurses, rather than the doctors, that inspired me. Seeing nurses on the ward, I grew to appreciate the autonomy of their role; distinct, yet equally valuable as the physicians. | After working as a healthcare assistant in a busy London trust my suspicions were confirmed: it was the work of the nurses, rather than the doctors, that inspired me. Seeing nurses on the ward, I grew to appreciate the autonomy of their role; distinct, yet equally valuable as the physicians. |
| Unlike doctors, a nurse will spend extended periods of time with their patients, building a relationship founded on implicit trust. They are at the bedside from admission through to discharge, relieving pain, easing distress and raising the alarm at any red flags. | Unlike doctors, a nurse will spend extended periods of time with their patients, building a relationship founded on implicit trust. They are at the bedside from admission through to discharge, relieving pain, easing distress and raising the alarm at any red flags. |
| Consequently, they are in the best position to observe the subtleties of a patient’s condition and gain the most holistic understanding of their needs. This unique nurse-patient relationship, combined with intelligent communication with the physicians, is arguably at the forefront of successful treatment and recovery. Therefore, nurses are required not only to be empathetic and perceptive, but highly skilled, educated professionals who can operate independently. | Consequently, they are in the best position to observe the subtleties of a patient’s condition and gain the most holistic understanding of their needs. This unique nurse-patient relationship, combined with intelligent communication with the physicians, is arguably at the forefront of successful treatment and recovery. Therefore, nurses are required not only to be empathetic and perceptive, but highly skilled, educated professionals who can operate independently. |
| Yet despite this, nurses are still widely perceived as handmaidens to doctors. The stereotypes linger, reinforced by popular culture. Take any glossy hospital hit of the last decade – House, ER, Grey’s Anatomy. Nurses are portrayed as unskilled aides to the deity-like doctors, that’s if they’re given screen time at all. | Yet despite this, nurses are still widely perceived as handmaidens to doctors. The stereotypes linger, reinforced by popular culture. Take any glossy hospital hit of the last decade – House, ER, Grey’s Anatomy. Nurses are portrayed as unskilled aides to the deity-like doctors, that’s if they’re given screen time at all. |
| The prejudice also manifests itself in a continued gender imbalance. Just over 10% of UK registered nurses are male, a stubborn figure that barely shifts each year. It’s a fact I’m reminded of every time I hear the call of “sister” or “matron” echo down the ward. | The prejudice also manifests itself in a continued gender imbalance. Just over 10% of UK registered nurses are male, a stubborn figure that barely shifts each year. It’s a fact I’m reminded of every time I hear the call of “sister” or “matron” echo down the ward. |
| The view of nurses as subordinate seems to be particularly entrenched in the UK, ironic given the founder of modern nursing, Florence Nightingale, rallied against the view of nurses as “devoted and obedient” (a definition she scoffed “might do for a horse”). One nurse I work with is considering returning to Nigeria, so disheartened by the lack of trust and respect in the NHS, attitudes that do not exist in her country. Others are attracted by opportunities overseas, notably Canada and Australia, where salaries reflect the higher status of the profession. | The view of nurses as subordinate seems to be particularly entrenched in the UK, ironic given the founder of modern nursing, Florence Nightingale, rallied against the view of nurses as “devoted and obedient” (a definition she scoffed “might do for a horse”). One nurse I work with is considering returning to Nigeria, so disheartened by the lack of trust and respect in the NHS, attitudes that do not exist in her country. Others are attracted by opportunities overseas, notably Canada and Australia, where salaries reflect the higher status of the profession. |
| There is hope, as the profession has evolved dramatically over the last decade and there are increasing numbers of opportunities to specialise and even prescribe. New titles, including nursing consultant, advance nurse practitioner and clinical nurse specialist challenge the traditional hierarchy. | There is hope, as the profession has evolved dramatically over the last decade and there are increasing numbers of opportunities to specialise and even prescribe. New titles, including nursing consultant, advance nurse practitioner and clinical nurse specialist challenge the traditional hierarchy. |
| However, prejudice is so deep rooted that I fear change will take decades and in some cases be met with resistance. Just last week I overheard a consultant say to an impressionable junior doctor: “We don’t do care, we do medicine”. It wasn’t so much the statement that was upsetting; it was the delivery. Tinged with disdain, the implication was obvious: the provision of care is lowly, beneath the role of the physician. | However, prejudice is so deep rooted that I fear change will take decades and in some cases be met with resistance. Just last week I overheard a consultant say to an impressionable junior doctor: “We don’t do care, we do medicine”. It wasn’t so much the statement that was upsetting; it was the delivery. Tinged with disdain, the implication was obvious: the provision of care is lowly, beneath the role of the physician. |
| We must challenge these views and start to see nurses as partners to doctors, not inferiors. Their unique scope of practice is of equal importance and until we recognise this, we will struggle to retain and attract the brightest talent to the profession. | We must challenge these views and start to see nurses as partners to doctors, not inferiors. Their unique scope of practice is of equal importance and until we recognise this, we will struggle to retain and attract the brightest talent to the profession. |
| Join the Healthcare Professionals Network to read more pieces like this. And follow us on Twitter (@GdnHealthcare) to keep up with the latest healthcare news and views. | Join the Healthcare Professionals Network to read more pieces like this. And follow us on Twitter (@GdnHealthcare) to keep up with the latest healthcare news and views. |
| Healthcare Network | Healthcare Network |
| Nursing in focus | Nursing in focus |
| Health | Health |
| Nursing | Nursing |
| Nursing and midwifery | Nursing and midwifery |
| Work practices | Work practices |
| Workforce | Workforce |
| comment | comment |
| Share on Facebook | Share on Facebook |
| Share on Twitter | Share on Twitter |
| Share via Email | Share via Email |
| Share on LinkedIn | Share on LinkedIn |
| Share on Pinterest | Share on Pinterest |
| Share on Google+ | Share on Google+ |
| Share on WhatsApp | Share on WhatsApp |
| Share on Messenger | Share on Messenger |
| Reuse this content | Reuse this content |