This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.nytimes.com/2017/06/12/arts/television/bill-cosby-trial-day-6.html
The article has changed 11 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 3 | Version 4 |
|---|---|
| Bill Cosby Trial Day 6: The Defense Rests After One Witness | Bill Cosby Trial Day 6: The Defense Rests After One Witness |
| (about 1 hour later) | |
| • The defense rested its case Monday after calling one witness, a police detective, who testified for six minutes. Closing arguments in the sexual assault trial started immediately, with the defense going first. | • The defense rested its case Monday after calling one witness, a police detective, who testified for six minutes. Closing arguments in the sexual assault trial started immediately, with the defense going first. |
| • There had been some speculation that Mr. Cosby might testify, but he did not. His wife, Camille, who had not been in court last week, walked in with him on Monday. | • There had been some speculation that Mr. Cosby might testify, but he did not. His wife, Camille, who had not been in court last week, walked in with him on Monday. |
| • Judge Steven T. O’Neill, who said the case would likely go to the jurors early in the week, was right in his prediction. | • Judge Steven T. O’Neill, who said the case would likely go to the jurors early in the week, was right in his prediction. |
| His lawyers rested their case after calling just one witness, a local detective who in 2005 had interviewed both Mr. Cosby and Andrea Constand, the Temple University staff member who has accused Mr. Cosby of drugging and sexually assaulting her at his home outside Philadelphia in 2004. | His lawyers rested their case after calling just one witness, a local detective who in 2005 had interviewed both Mr. Cosby and Andrea Constand, the Temple University staff member who has accused Mr. Cosby of drugging and sexually assaulting her at his home outside Philadelphia in 2004. |
| The detective, Sgt. Richard Schaffer, had testified last week as a prosecution witness. On Monday, Brian J. McMonagle, a lawyer for Mr. Cosby, brought him back to the stand for roughly six minutes, specifically to have him talk about a document he had created in 2005. The document, which the detective labeled “Questions for Andrea,” included some matters about her account that he had sought clarification on, including the question as to why she had gone to meet Mr. Cosby at a casino in Connecticut. | |
| The defense has argued that that meeting and other evidence suggests that Ms. Constand had a romantic relationship with Mr. Cosby and that their sexual encounter in 2004 was consensual. Ms. Constand and her mother were in the courtroom Monday. | The defense has argued that that meeting and other evidence suggests that Ms. Constand had a romantic relationship with Mr. Cosby and that their sexual encounter in 2004 was consensual. Ms. Constand and her mother were in the courtroom Monday. |
| The detective testified for only a few minutes and then the defense rested. | The detective testified for only a few minutes and then the defense rested. |
| Defense lawyers had asked to bring forward a second witness, Marguerite Jackson, an adviser at Temple, for reasons that were not clear. But Judge Steven T. O’Neill, who is presiding, denied the request to introduce her. | Defense lawyers had asked to bring forward a second witness, Marguerite Jackson, an adviser at Temple, for reasons that were not clear. But Judge Steven T. O’Neill, who is presiding, denied the request to introduce her. |
| The judge interacted a bit with Mr. Cosby as Monday’s court session began, speaking directly to him across the court and presenting several questions to Mr. Cosby to confirm that he agreed with his lawyers’ decision to bring one witness and with the decision that he wasn’t going to testify. As his wife, Camille, watched from the front row, Mr. Cosby replied simply, “Yes” or “Correct.” | The judge interacted a bit with Mr. Cosby as Monday’s court session began, speaking directly to him across the court and presenting several questions to Mr. Cosby to confirm that he agreed with his lawyers’ decision to bring one witness and with the decision that he wasn’t going to testify. As his wife, Camille, watched from the front row, Mr. Cosby replied simply, “Yes” or “Correct.” |
| Prosecutors asked Ms. Constand to tell her story, while defense lawyers attacked Ms. Constand’s credibility. Her testimony was emotional and she stayed composed, even as Mr. Cosby’s defense team produced phone records showing she called Mr. Cosby at least 53 times after the night she said she was assaulted at his home. She said that she had to speak to him for Temple University business. | Prosecutors asked Ms. Constand to tell her story, while defense lawyers attacked Ms. Constand’s credibility. Her testimony was emotional and she stayed composed, even as Mr. Cosby’s defense team produced phone records showing she called Mr. Cosby at least 53 times after the night she said she was assaulted at his home. She said that she had to speak to him for Temple University business. |
| Another question for the defense had been whether to call Bruce L. Castor Jr., the former district attorney who carried out the initial investigation in 2005. His name has been referenced several times in court by the defense team. But even though he had concluded there was “insufficient credible and admissible evidence” to bring charges, he had also said that he believed Ms. Constand’s account and thought Mr. Cosby was guilty of some improper behavior. | Another question for the defense had been whether to call Bruce L. Castor Jr., the former district attorney who carried out the initial investigation in 2005. His name has been referenced several times in court by the defense team. But even though he had concluded there was “insufficient credible and admissible evidence” to bring charges, he had also said that he believed Ms. Constand’s account and thought Mr. Cosby was guilty of some improper behavior. |
| “My gut told me that,” he told The New York Times in 2014. | “My gut told me that,” he told The New York Times in 2014. |
| Perhaps the defense worries that this sentiment would come out on cross-examination. | Perhaps the defense worries that this sentiment would come out on cross-examination. |
| District Attorney Kevin R. Steele was expected to lead the prosecution in its closing arguments on Monday. | District Attorney Kevin R. Steele was expected to lead the prosecution in its closing arguments on Monday. |
| Judge O’Neill will charge the jury, which means provide them with guidance and instruction on their deliberations, after the defense makes it closing arguments, most likely Monday afternoon. | Judge O’Neill will charge the jury, which means provide them with guidance and instruction on their deliberations, after the defense makes it closing arguments, most likely Monday afternoon. |
| The jurors may be relieved by the speed of the proceedings. They were drawn from the Pittsburgh area, 300 miles west of Norristown, Pa., because of concerns over pretrial publicity. They are being sequestered for the duration of the trial. | The jurors may be relieved by the speed of the proceedings. They were drawn from the Pittsburgh area, 300 miles west of Norristown, Pa., because of concerns over pretrial publicity. They are being sequestered for the duration of the trial. |
| “You have been amazing in how you have taken that hardship, being away from your family, away from your normal routine,” Judge O’Neill said on Friday as he wished them a restful weekend. | “You have been amazing in how you have taken that hardship, being away from your family, away from your normal routine,” Judge O’Neill said on Friday as he wished them a restful weekend. |
| But he warned them not to talk about the case with anyone and to keep an open mind, as they now come into the spotlight. | But he warned them not to talk about the case with anyone and to keep an open mind, as they now come into the spotlight. |