This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/science-environment-39231896
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
B vitamins may have 'protective effect' against air pollution | B vitamins may have 'protective effect' against air pollution |
(35 minutes later) | |
B vitamins may offer some protection against the impacts of air pollution, a small scale human trial suggests. | B vitamins may offer some protection against the impacts of air pollution, a small scale human trial suggests. |
Researchers in the US found that high doses of these supplements may "completely offset" the damage caused by very fine particulate matter. | Researchers in the US found that high doses of these supplements may "completely offset" the damage caused by very fine particulate matter. |
The scientists involved say the effect is real but stress the limitations of their work. | The scientists involved say the effect is real but stress the limitations of their work. |
Follow up studies are urgently needed, they say, in heavily polluted cities like Beijing or Mexico. | Follow up studies are urgently needed, they say, in heavily polluted cities like Beijing or Mexico. |
While the impacts of air pollution on health have become a cause of growing concern to people all around the world, the actual mechanics of exactly how dirty air makes people sick are not clearly understood. | While the impacts of air pollution on health have become a cause of growing concern to people all around the world, the actual mechanics of exactly how dirty air makes people sick are not clearly understood. |
According to the World Health Organization (WHO), over 90% of the world's population live in areas where air pollution exceeds safety guidelines. | |
One of the pollutants that is considered the most dangerous is very fine particulate matter, referred to as PM2.5, where particles have a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometres. | One of the pollutants that is considered the most dangerous is very fine particulate matter, referred to as PM2.5, where particles have a diameter of less than 2.5 micrometres. |
These complex particulates come from diesel cars, wood burning stoves and as a by-product of chemical reactions between other polluting gases. | These complex particulates come from diesel cars, wood burning stoves and as a by-product of chemical reactions between other polluting gases. |
At around 1/30 the width of a human hair, PM2.5 fragments can lodge deep in the human lung and contribute to lung and heart health issues in the young and old. | At around 1/30 the width of a human hair, PM2.5 fragments can lodge deep in the human lung and contribute to lung and heart health issues in the young and old. |
Scientists have long suspected that PM2.5 causes what are termed epigenetic changes in our cells that can damage our health. | Scientists have long suspected that PM2.5 causes what are termed epigenetic changes in our cells that can damage our health. |
The genes in our DNA contain the instructions for life, but epigenetics controls how those instructions are used - it's like the relationship between an mp3 track and the volume control, you can only hear the musical notes (genes) when you dial up the volume (epigenetic changes). | The genes in our DNA contain the instructions for life, but epigenetics controls how those instructions are used - it's like the relationship between an mp3 track and the volume control, you can only hear the musical notes (genes) when you dial up the volume (epigenetic changes). |
The study shows the very presence of environmental factors like air pollution seems to alter genes in the immune system at the epigenetic level - switching them on or off, and inhibiting our defences. | The study shows the very presence of environmental factors like air pollution seems to alter genes in the immune system at the epigenetic level - switching them on or off, and inhibiting our defences. |
Researchers had already seen that nutrients could somehow stop this process in animal studies with the chemical Bisphenol A. | Researchers had already seen that nutrients could somehow stop this process in animal studies with the chemical Bisphenol A. |
Now in this new human trial, an international team of scientists wanted to see if exposure to concentrations of PM2.5 could be mitigated by a daily B vitamin supplement containing 2.5mg of folic acid, 50mg of vitamin B6, and 1mg of vitamin B12. | Now in this new human trial, an international team of scientists wanted to see if exposure to concentrations of PM2.5 could be mitigated by a daily B vitamin supplement containing 2.5mg of folic acid, 50mg of vitamin B6, and 1mg of vitamin B12. |
Ten volunteers were tested initially exposed to clean air while given a placebo to measure their basic responses. The same volunteers were later tested with large doses of B vitamins while exposed to air containing high levels of PM2.5. | Ten volunteers were tested initially exposed to clean air while given a placebo to measure their basic responses. The same volunteers were later tested with large doses of B vitamins while exposed to air containing high levels of PM2.5. |
The researchers found that a four week B vitamin supplementation limited the PM2.5 effect by between 28-76% at ten gene locations. They found a similar reduction in impact on the mitochondrial DNA, the parts of cells that generate energy. | The researchers found that a four week B vitamin supplementation limited the PM2.5 effect by between 28-76% at ten gene locations. They found a similar reduction in impact on the mitochondrial DNA, the parts of cells that generate energy. |
"Where we quantify the effect, it is almost close to a complete offset on the epigenome of the air pollution," said Jia Zhong from Harvard School of Public Health, who led the study. | "Where we quantify the effect, it is almost close to a complete offset on the epigenome of the air pollution," said Jia Zhong from Harvard School of Public Health, who led the study. |
"On the mitochondrial DNA side, it also offset a big proportion of it." | "On the mitochondrial DNA side, it also offset a big proportion of it." |
However, the authors caution that their study, while observing a real effect, has many limitations. As well as the small number of participants, there was little information on the size of the B vitamin dose that elicited the response. | However, the authors caution that their study, while observing a real effect, has many limitations. As well as the small number of participants, there was little information on the size of the B vitamin dose that elicited the response. |
"We didn't have different doses and the doses we used were quite high, higher than a normal pregnancy suggested intake. So it is quite high but at the same we did observe this protective effect," said Jia Zhong. | "We didn't have different doses and the doses we used were quite high, higher than a normal pregnancy suggested intake. So it is quite high but at the same we did observe this protective effect," said Jia Zhong. |
Other scientists in the field, while welcoming the study, agree that caution is needed. | Other scientists in the field, while welcoming the study, agree that caution is needed. |
"The fact that they find a coherent story in only 10 subjects is promising, but clearly warrants further follow-up in larger populations especially considering the ethnic variability in this study," said Prof Carrie Breton from the University of Southern California, who wasn't involved in the report. | "The fact that they find a coherent story in only 10 subjects is promising, but clearly warrants further follow-up in larger populations especially considering the ethnic variability in this study," said Prof Carrie Breton from the University of Southern California, who wasn't involved in the report. |
"While I think it is great that doing something as easy as taking a vitamin would help protect against air pollution harm, the public health goal still needs to be one of reducing air pollution to a level that is not harmful," she said in a statement. | "While I think it is great that doing something as easy as taking a vitamin would help protect against air pollution harm, the public health goal still needs to be one of reducing air pollution to a level that is not harmful," she said in a statement. |
The authors acknowledge that this was a pilot study to test a hypothesis and they are not in a position to make any deductions about whether B vitamins could be used in clinical practice as a means of protecting against air pollution. | The authors acknowledge that this was a pilot study to test a hypothesis and they are not in a position to make any deductions about whether B vitamins could be used in clinical practice as a means of protecting against air pollution. |
More and bigger studies are needed - and they need to be done in environments where people have a major exposure to PM2.5. | More and bigger studies are needed - and they need to be done in environments where people have a major exposure to PM2.5. |
"I think that B vitamins are a likely hope that we can potentially utilise as an individualised treatment to complement the policy regulations to minimise the impacts of air pollution," said Jia Zhong. | "I think that B vitamins are a likely hope that we can potentially utilise as an individualised treatment to complement the policy regulations to minimise the impacts of air pollution," said Jia Zhong. |
"A more sophisticated study is urgently needed in Beijing or India or Mexico just to see whether those who are chronically exposed, if the protective effect can still be effective." | "A more sophisticated study is urgently needed in Beijing or India or Mexico just to see whether those who are chronically exposed, if the protective effect can still be effective." |
The study has been published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS). | The study has been published in the journal Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences (PNAS). |
Follow Matt on Twitter and on Facebook. | Follow Matt on Twitter and on Facebook. |
Previous version
1
Next version