This article is from the source 'independent' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/politics/philip-hammond-sexism-hysteria-hysterical-mary-creagh-a7605921.html
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Philip Hammond accused of sexism after telling Labour MP not to be 'hysterical' | Philip Hammond accused of sexism after telling Labour MP not to be 'hysterical' |
(35 minutes later) | |
The Chancellor of the Exchequer has been accused of sexism after telling a woman Labour MP not to be “hysterical”. | |
Mary Creagh asked Philip Hammond about the effect of Brexit on British businesses with bases in Ireland. | Mary Creagh asked Philip Hammond about the effect of Brexit on British businesses with bases in Ireland. |
Labour MPs heckled Mr Hammond after he urged Ms Creagh “not to be hysterical about these things”. | Labour MPs heckled Mr Hammond after he urged Ms Creagh “not to be hysterical about these things”. |
Ms Creagh, who represents Wakefield, raised a point of order with the Speaker John Bercow following the episode. | Ms Creagh, who represents Wakefield, raised a point of order with the Speaker John Bercow following the episode. |
“In response to my recent Treasury question, the Chancellor of the Exchequer accused me of being hysterical. | “In response to my recent Treasury question, the Chancellor of the Exchequer accused me of being hysterical. |
“Can we have a ruling from you as to whether this sort of sexist language used to diminish women who make a perfectly reasonable point - that is the sort of language that would not be used had I been man. | “Can we have a ruling from you as to whether this sort of sexist language used to diminish women who make a perfectly reasonable point - that is the sort of language that would not be used had I been man. |
“My question on the registration of companies in Ireland had nothing to do with the condition of my womb travelling to my head, as is the traditional hysterics rhetoric. | “My question on the registration of companies in Ireland had nothing to do with the condition of my womb travelling to my head, as is the traditional hysterics rhetoric. |
“I expect that sort of language from the sketch writers of the Daily Mail, not from the Chancellor of the Exchequer.” | “I expect that sort of language from the sketch writers of the Daily Mail, not from the Chancellor of the Exchequer.” |
Mr Hammond replied: “I did not, of course, accuse (Ms Creagh) of being hysterical - I urged her not to be hysterical. | Mr Hammond replied: “I did not, of course, accuse (Ms Creagh) of being hysterical - I urged her not to be hysterical. |
“If my comments have caused (Ms Creagh) any offence, I of course withdraw them unreservedly.” | “If my comments have caused (Ms Creagh) any offence, I of course withdraw them unreservedly.” |
Mr Bercow said that there was “difference between order and taste” and said that “people will have their own view about taste”. | Mr Bercow said that there was “difference between order and taste” and said that “people will have their own view about taste”. |
The word hysteria derived from the Greek word for uterus, hystera. In previous centuries hysteria was a common medical diagnosis applied to women. | The word hysteria derived from the Greek word for uterus, hystera. In previous centuries hysteria was a common medical diagnosis applied to women. |
Now widely discredited, its symptoms supposedly included irritability or a tendency to cause trouble | Now widely discredited, its symptoms supposedly included irritability or a tendency to cause trouble |
Previous version
1
Next version