This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/health-39103389
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Hepatitis C charity took drug industry funding | Hepatitis C charity took drug industry funding |
(about 11 hours later) | |
A charity that tried to force the NHS to buy more of an expensive hepatitis C treatment received large amounts of money from the drug's manufacturer, the Victoria Derbyshire show has found. | A charity that tried to force the NHS to buy more of an expensive hepatitis C treatment received large amounts of money from the drug's manufacturer, the Victoria Derbyshire show has found. |
The Hepatitis C Trust has taken £200,000 in grant funding from US drugs giant Gilead since 2014. | The Hepatitis C Trust has taken £200,000 in grant funding from US drugs giant Gilead since 2014. |
Last year, it unsuccessfully took NHS England to court for restricting access to the medicine on cost grounds. | Last year, it unsuccessfully took NHS England to court for restricting access to the medicine on cost grounds. |
The charity denied being influenced by the drugs industry. | The charity denied being influenced by the drugs industry. |
It said it had always acted in the interests of patients. | It said it had always acted in the interests of patients. |
'Revolutionary' treatment | 'Revolutionary' treatment |
In 2016, the Hepatitis C Trust brought a High Court action against NHS England to try to force it to reconsider a controversial decision to limit, or "ration", a new cure for hepatitis C. | In 2016, the Hepatitis C Trust brought a High Court action against NHS England to try to force it to reconsider a controversial decision to limit, or "ration", a new cure for hepatitis C. |
The new range of pills, which has completely changed the way hepatitis C is treated, is thought to be 95% effective at curing the disease within eight weeks. | The new range of pills, which has completely changed the way hepatitis C is treated, is thought to be 95% effective at curing the disease within eight weeks. |
Before this, it could only be cured with a year of injections, often with damaging side-effects likened to those of chemotherapy. | Before this, it could only be cured with a year of injections, often with damaging side-effects likened to those of chemotherapy. |
The first of these new drugs, Sovaldi - manufactured by Gilead - has a list price of £34,983 for a 12-week course, although a confidential deal with NHS England will have reduced the final cost to the health service. | The first of these new drugs, Sovaldi - manufactured by Gilead - has a list price of £34,983 for a 12-week course, although a confidential deal with NHS England will have reduced the final cost to the health service. |
In 2015, the health watchdog NICE ruled it was cost-effective compared with older medicines. | In 2015, the health watchdog NICE ruled it was cost-effective compared with older medicines. |
NHS England set aside an extra £200m a year to pay for Sovaldi and other new hepatitis C treatments. | NHS England set aside an extra £200m a year to pay for Sovaldi and other new hepatitis C treatments. |
But in 2016, faced with the high price of the new pills, it decided to limit the drug to 10,000 people a year, rising to 15,000 by 2021. | But in 2016, faced with the high price of the new pills, it decided to limit the drug to 10,000 people a year, rising to 15,000 by 2021. |
An estimated 215,000 people in the UK are infected with hepatitis C, a virus that can cause liver damage and cancer. | An estimated 215,000 people in the UK are infected with hepatitis C, a virus that can cause liver damage and cancer. |
Access is not restricted in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland. | Access is not restricted in Scotland, Wales or Northern Ireland. |
In the charity's case against the NHS, Gilead - along with rival drugs-makers Bristol-Myers Squibb and AbbVie - were listed as "interested parties" to the court case, according to documents seen by the BBC. | In the charity's case against the NHS, Gilead - along with rival drugs-makers Bristol-Myers Squibb and AbbVie - were listed as "interested parties" to the court case, according to documents seen by the BBC. |
An analysis of the charity's accounts shows it has longstanding financial links with drugs manufacturer Gilead, and other pharmaceutical companies developing new cures for hepatitis C. | An analysis of the charity's accounts shows it has longstanding financial links with drugs manufacturer Gilead, and other pharmaceutical companies developing new cures for hepatitis C. |
In 2016, the Trust accepted a total of £334,700 from five large pharmaceutical companies - 35% of its total income. | In 2016, the Trust accepted a total of £334,700 from five large pharmaceutical companies - 35% of its total income. |
For the financial year ending March 2016, it listed a £108,825 grant from Gilead. | For the financial year ending March 2016, it listed a £108,825 grant from Gilead. |
This level of drug industry funding appears to be significantly higher than most other charities and patient groups working in areas of the health service. | This level of drug industry funding appears to be significantly higher than most other charities and patient groups working in areas of the health service. |
Some refuse to accept any funding whatsoever from pharmaceutical companies. | Some refuse to accept any funding whatsoever from pharmaceutical companies. |
Find out more | |
Watch video journalist Jim Reed's full report into hepatitis C drugs on the Victoria Derbyshire website. | |
In September 2016, the charity lost its case. Mr Justice Blake ruled that the limit was "not an arbitrary cap", but a way of treating the most serious cases first. | In September 2016, the charity lost its case. Mr Justice Blake ruled that the limit was "not an arbitrary cap", but a way of treating the most serious cases first. |
In his ruling, the judge suggested the drugs companies themselves might have been funding the legal action. | In his ruling, the judge suggested the drugs companies themselves might have been funding the legal action. |
Charles Gore, the chief executive of the Hepatitis C Trust, strongly denied this, and said the court case was publicly crowdfunded. | Charles Gore, the chief executive of the Hepatitis C Trust, strongly denied this, and said the court case was publicly crowdfunded. |
"We were doing this for patients. The fact that drug companies stood to benefit from it was neither here nor there," he said. | "We were doing this for patients. The fact that drug companies stood to benefit from it was neither here nor there," he said. |
"We mustn't be in the pockets of big pharma [pharmaceutical companies], or seen to be in the pockets of big pharma. | "We mustn't be in the pockets of big pharma [pharmaceutical companies], or seen to be in the pockets of big pharma. |
"The NHS tries to influence us, the drugs industry tries to influence us, lots of people try to influence us. But it comes back to the same thing - what's right for patients?" | "The NHS tries to influence us, the drugs industry tries to influence us, lots of people try to influence us. But it comes back to the same thing - what's right for patients?" |
Other charities have been critical of patient groups that take large donations from drug companies working in the same area. | Other charities have been critical of patient groups that take large donations from drug companies working in the same area. |
Nick Harvey from Doctors of the World UK, which campaigns for greater access to hepatitis C drugs, describes this trend as "very worrying". | Nick Harvey from Doctors of the World UK, which campaigns for greater access to hepatitis C drugs, describes this trend as "very worrying". |
"Invariably the charities focus on the NHS for not allowing medicines to be given to them, and the blame goes towards the NHS. | "Invariably the charities focus on the NHS for not allowing medicines to be given to them, and the blame goes towards the NHS. |
"Hardly any of the debate is about the pharmaceutical industry and how much the medicine costs in the first place." | "Hardly any of the debate is about the pharmaceutical industry and how much the medicine costs in the first place." |
One expert, Dr Andrew Hill - from the University of Liverpool - claims the drugs firm is making "vast profits here, tens of billions of dollars". | One expert, Dr Andrew Hill - from the University of Liverpool - claims the drugs firm is making "vast profits here, tens of billions of dollars". |
'Reduced mortality rates' | 'Reduced mortality rates' |
Gilead said any support it provides to patient organisations is given "transparently, in accordance with industry standards and all applicable regulations". | Gilead said any support it provides to patient organisations is given "transparently, in accordance with industry standards and all applicable regulations". |
In a statement the company added: "Our hepatitis C treatments offer value for money, as independently assessed by NICE." | In a statement the company added: "Our hepatitis C treatments offer value for money, as independently assessed by NICE." |
"Curing patients both prevents onward transmission of this infectious disease [and] greatly reduces the financial burden to the NHS." | "Curing patients both prevents onward transmission of this infectious disease [and] greatly reduces the financial burden to the NHS." |
An NHS England spokesman said "by focusing on the sickest patients [with the new oral treatments] we've reduced mortality from hepatitis C by over 10% in the space of just one year". | An NHS England spokesman said "by focusing on the sickest patients [with the new oral treatments] we've reduced mortality from hepatitis C by over 10% in the space of just one year". |
Watch the Victoria Derbyshire programme on weekdays between 09:00 and 11:00 on BBC Two and the BBC News channel. | Watch the Victoria Derbyshire programme on weekdays between 09:00 and 11:00 on BBC Two and the BBC News channel. |
Previous version
1
Next version