This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/hampshire/7477461.stm

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Caretaker wins ladder fall case Caretaker wins ladder fall case
(about 2 hours later)
A school caretaker has successfully sued Hampshire County Council after he was injured falling off a stepladder.A school caretaker has successfully sued Hampshire County Council after he was injured falling off a stepladder.
Anthony Gower-Smith, 73, fell off the 6ft stepladder at Awbridge Primary School in Romsey in 2004. Anthony Gower-Smith, 73, fell off the 6ft (180cm) stepladder at Awbridge Primary School in Romsey in 2004.
In court, he claimed his employer had not shown him how to use the ladder. The council denied negligence.In court, he claimed his employer had not shown him how to use the ladder. The council denied negligence.
But on Friday, Mr Gower-Smith, from North Baddesley, won his case on the basis the council was 75% to blame. His compensation will now be assessed.But on Friday, Mr Gower-Smith, from North Baddesley, won his case on the basis the council was 75% to blame. His compensation will now be assessed.
Mr Gower-Smith, who had made a claim for £50,000, suffered a fractured skull, fractured cheek bone and kidney injuries in the fall, leading to treatment in intensive care.Mr Gower-Smith, who had made a claim for £50,000, suffered a fractured skull, fractured cheek bone and kidney injuries in the fall, leading to treatment in intensive care.
He has not been able to work since the accident.He has not been able to work since the accident.
Hampshire County Council said the caretaker was given adequate training and equipment to do the job.Hampshire County Council said the caretaker was given adequate training and equipment to do the job.
Hampshire County Council takes health and safety very seriously Councillor David KirkHampshire County Council takes health and safety very seriously Councillor David Kirk
The authority said Mr Gower-Smith signed an induction training sheet in 2002 on starting the job to show he had received training to use stepladders.The authority said Mr Gower-Smith signed an induction training sheet in 2002 on starting the job to show he had received training to use stepladders.
At the time a health and safety report said the council was not at fault and the council claimed that Mr Gower-Smith had positioned the ladder improperly before overbalancing.At the time a health and safety report said the council was not at fault and the council claimed that Mr Gower-Smith had positioned the ladder improperly before overbalancing.
At London's High Court, Recorder Christopher Moger QC, who recently heard the case at Winchester County Court, said Mr Gower-Smith's training was deficient.At London's High Court, Recorder Christopher Moger QC, who recently heard the case at Winchester County Court, said Mr Gower-Smith's training was deficient.
He said Mr Gower-Smith knew he should not go on to the top platform of the ladder but did so and, by doing so, increased the likelihood of it overturning.He said Mr Gower-Smith knew he should not go on to the top platform of the ladder but did so and, by doing so, increased the likelihood of it overturning.
"Notwithstanding his self-confidence and readiness to trust in his own judgement, I find that his lack of training was responsible for... his lack of awareness of the extent of the danger posed and therefore the accident itself," he said."Notwithstanding his self-confidence and readiness to trust in his own judgement, I find that his lack of training was responsible for... his lack of awareness of the extent of the danger posed and therefore the accident itself," he said.
Damages reducedDamages reduced
The damages award will be reduced by 25% to reflect Mr Gower-Smith's contributory negligence.The damages award will be reduced by 25% to reflect Mr Gower-Smith's contributory negligence.
After the verdict Hampshire County Council said it was sorry but "surprised and disappointed" with the decision.After the verdict Hampshire County Council said it was sorry but "surprised and disappointed" with the decision.
Councillor David Kirk, Hampshire County Council's member for children's services, said: "While the judge acknowledged training had been given to Mr Gower-Smith he found that there was insufficient emphasis placed on the positioning of the step ladder even though this guidance is in our manual, which is routinely reviewed to reflect new HSE regulations.Councillor David Kirk, Hampshire County Council's member for children's services, said: "While the judge acknowledged training had been given to Mr Gower-Smith he found that there was insufficient emphasis placed on the positioning of the step ladder even though this guidance is in our manual, which is routinely reviewed to reflect new HSE regulations.
"Hampshire County Council takes health and safety very seriously and last year we were among a number of local authorities who signed up to the HSE's sensible risk campaign.""Hampshire County Council takes health and safety very seriously and last year we were among a number of local authorities who signed up to the HSE's sensible risk campaign."