This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/artanddesign/2017/feb/26/nazi-art-stolen-poland-returned-horst-waechter
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 5 | Version 6 |
|---|---|
| Son of Nazi governor returns art stolen from Poland during second world war | Son of Nazi governor returns art stolen from Poland during second world war |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| In December 1939 a Viennese woman with chestnut brown hair walked triumphantly into the National Museum in Kraków. | In December 1939 a Viennese woman with chestnut brown hair walked triumphantly into the National Museum in Kraków. |
| Charlotte Wächter’s husband was the recently appointed Nazi governor of Kraków: SS Gruppenführer Otto Wächter; she was decorating the new headquarters that he had established at the city’s Potocki Palace – and in the process, she looted every department of the museum. | Charlotte Wächter’s husband was the recently appointed Nazi governor of Kraków: SS Gruppenführer Otto Wächter; she was decorating the new headquarters that he had established at the city’s Potocki Palace – and in the process, she looted every department of the museum. |
| According to a Polish government assessment from 1946, Frau Wächter took “the most exquisite paintings and the most beautiful items of antique furniture, militaria, etc, despite the fact that the director of the museum had warned her against taking masterpieces for this purpose”. | According to a Polish government assessment from 1946, Frau Wächter took “the most exquisite paintings and the most beautiful items of antique furniture, militaria, etc, despite the fact that the director of the museum had warned her against taking masterpieces for this purpose”. |
| An estimated half a million art objects were plundered from Poland by the occupying Nazi and Soviet forces during the second world war. | An estimated half a million art objects were plundered from Poland by the occupying Nazi and Soviet forces during the second world war. |
| Poland’s ministry of culture still keeps a vigilant watch for any that may turn up on the international art circuit. Unable to force their current holders to return them, Poland often finds itself having to buy the works at auction – sometimes from the descendants of those who stole them. | Poland’s ministry of culture still keeps a vigilant watch for any that may turn up on the international art circuit. Unable to force their current holders to return them, Poland often finds itself having to buy the works at auction – sometimes from the descendants of those who stole them. |
| But Sunday marked a key moment in Poland’s decades-long effort to regain its looted treasure, one that hopefully will set an example for other descendants of Nazi art thieves. | But Sunday marked a key moment in Poland’s decades-long effort to regain its looted treasure, one that hopefully will set an example for other descendants of Nazi art thieves. |
| Horst Wächter, the fourth of the SS general’s six children, has spent years trying to return a painting taken by his parents from the Potocki Palace. On Sunday, he attended a ceremony in Kraków at which three stolen works were returned to the Polish government. | Horst Wächter, the fourth of the SS general’s six children, has spent years trying to return a painting taken by his parents from the Potocki Palace. On Sunday, he attended a ceremony in Kraków at which three stolen works were returned to the Polish government. |
| “This is probably the first time that the member of a family of one of the most important Nazi occupiers is giving back art that was stolen from Poland during the war,” said Ryszard Czarnecki, a vice-president of the European parliament and a member of the Polish Law and Justice party. | “This is probably the first time that the member of a family of one of the most important Nazi occupiers is giving back art that was stolen from Poland during the war,” said Ryszard Czarnecki, a vice-president of the European parliament and a member of the Polish Law and Justice party. |
| Wächter, 78, returned three works that his mother stole: a painting of the Potocki Palace, a map of 17th-century Poland, and an engraving of Kraków during the Renaissance. | Wächter, 78, returned three works that his mother stole: a painting of the Potocki Palace, a map of 17th-century Poland, and an engraving of Kraków during the Renaissance. |
| The small painting by countess Julia Potocka (1818-1895) depicts Artur Potocki bidding farewell from the balcony of the Potocki Palace to relatives who are departing in horse-drawn carriages burdened with heavy luggage. | The small painting by countess Julia Potocka (1818-1895) depicts Artur Potocki bidding farewell from the balcony of the Potocki Palace to relatives who are departing in horse-drawn carriages burdened with heavy luggage. |
| “My mother liked it very much,” said Wächter. “The painting always hung in the rooms she inhabited. She took the painting out of the Potocki Palace – which was my father’s office – to Austria where she furnished the house we were living in during the war.” | “My mother liked it very much,” said Wächter. “The painting always hung in the rooms she inhabited. She took the painting out of the Potocki Palace – which was my father’s office – to Austria where she furnished the house we were living in during the war.” |
| An attempt some years ago to return the painting to the Potocki family – the prominent Polish noble family whose Kraków residence Otto Wächter usurped during the war – did not go well. | An attempt some years ago to return the painting to the Potocki family – the prominent Polish noble family whose Kraków residence Otto Wächter usurped during the war – did not go well. |
| The Potockis “did not want to have anything to do with me as the son of a Nazi”, said Wächter in an email from Schloss Haggenberg, the 17th-century castle where he resides in Austria. | The Potockis “did not want to have anything to do with me as the son of a Nazi”, said Wächter in an email from Schloss Haggenberg, the 17th-century castle where he resides in Austria. |
| About 68,000 Jews were expelled from Kraków in 1940 on the orders of Wächter, who the next year created the Kraków ghetto for the 15,000 Jews who remained. Killings under his orders continued when Hitler transferred him to become governor of Galicia in the Ukraine in 1942. | About 68,000 Jews were expelled from Kraków in 1940 on the orders of Wächter, who the next year created the Kraków ghetto for the 15,000 Jews who remained. Killings under his orders continued when Hitler transferred him to become governor of Galicia in the Ukraine in 1942. |
| Seventy-five years later, the Wächter surname still rings alarm bells in Poland. | Seventy-five years later, the Wächter surname still rings alarm bells in Poland. |
| The delicate task of negotiating the return of the painting was finally taken on by Magdalena Ogórek, a Polish politician and historian who had conducted a series of interviews with Horst Wächter for a book she is writing about his father. | The delicate task of negotiating the return of the painting was finally taken on by Magdalena Ogórek, a Polish politician and historian who had conducted a series of interviews with Horst Wächter for a book she is writing about his father. |
| Ogórek had spotted the 17th-century map of Kraków in a photograph accompanying an article about Wächter in the Financial Times. When she asked Wächter about it, he admitted that his mother had stolen it, along with the other works. | |
| “I have to admit that I did not have to convince Horst to return it, he wanted to return it,” says Ogórek, who also attended the handover ceremony on Sunday. | “I have to admit that I did not have to convince Horst to return it, he wanted to return it,” says Ogórek, who also attended the handover ceremony on Sunday. |
| The hard part turned out to be convincing officials in Poland to negotiate with the son of such a notorious Nazi criminal. “Polish officials are reluctant to have contact with the children of Nazis, but I convinced them that our obligation was to do everything we could to return this painting to the city of Kraków.” | The hard part turned out to be convincing officials in Poland to negotiate with the son of such a notorious Nazi criminal. “Polish officials are reluctant to have contact with the children of Nazis, but I convinced them that our obligation was to do everything we could to return this painting to the city of Kraków.” |
| Wächter says he returned the art works to honour the memory of his mother, who died in 1985. “I am not especially proud of my deeds,” he said. “I do not return the objects for me, but for the sake of my mother.” | Wächter says he returned the art works to honour the memory of his mother, who died in 1985. “I am not especially proud of my deeds,” he said. “I do not return the objects for me, but for the sake of my mother.” |
| In a 2015 documentary My Nazi legacy, Wächter admitted to the British lawyer and author Philippe Sands that his mother was “proud” to be a Nazi. “She was convinced that my father was right and did the right things. She never spoke one word bad about him.” | In a 2015 documentary My Nazi legacy, Wächter admitted to the British lawyer and author Philippe Sands that his mother was “proud” to be a Nazi. “She was convinced that my father was right and did the right things. She never spoke one word bad about him.” |
| Despite his clear-eyed approach to the looted artworks, Wächter maintains that his father was an unwilling cog in the Nazi killing machine, a position that has won him many critics. “My father became doomed and murdered for something he never planned and executed himself,” Wächter said. | Despite his clear-eyed approach to the looted artworks, Wächter maintains that his father was an unwilling cog in the Nazi killing machine, a position that has won him many critics. “My father became doomed and murdered for something he never planned and executed himself,” Wächter said. |
| Otto Wächter died under mysterious circumstances in Rome in 1949 while waiting to escape to Argentina, where many other Nazis had already found safe refuge. He was administered the last rites by Austrian bishop Alois Hudal, one of the main churchmen involved in rescuing Nazis from Allied justice. | Otto Wächter died under mysterious circumstances in Rome in 1949 while waiting to escape to Argentina, where many other Nazis had already found safe refuge. He was administered the last rites by Austrian bishop Alois Hudal, one of the main churchmen involved in rescuing Nazis from Allied justice. |
| Ogórek believes Wächter may have been murdered in Rome. “I have discovered a Hudal document in the Vatican secret archives that shows he could have been poisoned,” says Ogórek. | Ogórek believes Wächter may have been murdered in Rome. “I have discovered a Hudal document in the Vatican secret archives that shows he could have been poisoned,” says Ogórek. |
| Another question is how many other works of looted art might still be in the hands of families of other Nazi officers. | Another question is how many other works of looted art might still be in the hands of families of other Nazi officers. |
| “I hope that the return of this painting will encourage other families in possession of looted art to return them instead of trying to sell them at auction,” said Czarnecki. | “I hope that the return of this painting will encourage other families in possession of looted art to return them instead of trying to sell them at auction,” said Czarnecki. |
| As the son of a Nazi war criminal, it is perhaps unsurprising that Horst Wächter has a dim view of humanity, one which he says is confirmed by the rise of populist and racist movements across the Europe and the US. | As the son of a Nazi war criminal, it is perhaps unsurprising that Horst Wächter has a dim view of humanity, one which he says is confirmed by the rise of populist and racist movements across the Europe and the US. |
| “In difficult times there have always been leaders who convince their followers that the others – all those different from them in culture, language or faith – were responsible for their troubles and that their community has to get rid of them. The Nazi period is definitely doomed to repeat itself.” | “In difficult times there have always been leaders who convince their followers that the others – all those different from them in culture, language or faith – were responsible for their troubles and that their community has to get rid of them. The Nazi period is definitely doomed to repeat itself.” |