This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.

You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/health/7424169.stm

The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.

Version 0 Version 1
Charity props up NHS cancer care Charity props up NHS cancer care
(about 2 hours later)
The NHS relies heavily on charitable donations for the treatment and support of children and teenagers with cancer, research suggests.The NHS relies heavily on charitable donations for the treatment and support of children and teenagers with cancer, research suggests.
Up to half of funding in NHS specialist cancer centres in England and Wales comes from charities, a team of health economists calculate.Up to half of funding in NHS specialist cancer centres in England and Wales comes from charities, a team of health economists calculate.
Some oncologists said without charity support many services would not exist.Some oncologists said without charity support many services would not exist.
The funding level raises questions about the government's responsibility for cancer care, the researchers say.The funding level raises questions about the government's responsibility for cancer care, the researchers say.
The take-home message is that it is a significant contribution towards work which arguably should be paid for by the NHS Dr Dyfrig Hughes, study authorThe take-home message is that it is a significant contribution towards work which arguably should be paid for by the NHS Dr Dyfrig Hughes, study author
A total of 51 charities have been set up specifically to assist children with cancer and 340 charities had made some kind of financial contribution, the University of Bristol team report in the Journal of Child Health Care. A total of 51 charities have been set up specifically to assist children with cancer and 340 charities had made some kind of financial contribution, the University of Bangor team report in the Journal of Child Health Care.
A further 28 organisations had been set up to provide funds for hospices.A further 28 organisations had been set up to provide funds for hospices.
Figures from 2003 show that between £25m and £38m (depending on the method of calculation used) of funding for cancer care came from national charities, compared with between £38m and £55m coming from the NHS.Figures from 2003 show that between £25m and £38m (depending on the method of calculation used) of funding for cancer care came from national charities, compared with between £38m and £55m coming from the NHS.
'Over-reliance''Over-reliance'
Study author, Dr Dyfrig Hughes, said the charity figures could be an underestimate, as they did not include the many hospital and local charities which also provide funding.Study author, Dr Dyfrig Hughes, said the charity figures could be an underestimate, as they did not include the many hospital and local charities which also provide funding.
"The take-home message is that it is a significant contribution towards work which arguably should be paid for by the NHS."The take-home message is that it is a significant contribution towards work which arguably should be paid for by the NHS.
"People tend to give money to things which play on the heart strings and cancer is an area which attracts a huge amount of charity but there are other diseases that do not get the same donations.""People tend to give money to things which play on the heart strings and cancer is an area which attracts a huge amount of charity but there are other diseases that do not get the same donations."
He said the reliance on charitable funding may skew NHS priorities and means services are available in some areas but not others.He said the reliance on charitable funding may skew NHS priorities and means services are available in some areas but not others.
"For things which might be labelled as luxury that's fine, but essential things should come from central resources to ensure equal access.""For things which might be labelled as luxury that's fine, but essential things should come from central resources to ensure equal access."
One example given in the study was funding for children's cancer nurse specialists by charity CLIC Sargent.One example given in the study was funding for children's cancer nurse specialists by charity CLIC Sargent.
Dr James Nicholson, consultant paediatric oncologist at Addenbrookes Hospital in Cambridge, said he was not surprised by the figures as some consultant and many hospital and nurse positions around the country were charity posts.Dr James Nicholson, consultant paediatric oncologist at Addenbrookes Hospital in Cambridge, said he was not surprised by the figures as some consultant and many hospital and nurse positions around the country were charity posts.
There is no doubt that charities were instrumental in establishing paediatric oncology units in their early days Professor Sir Alan Craft, University of NewcastleThere is no doubt that charities were instrumental in establishing paediatric oncology units in their early days Professor Sir Alan Craft, University of Newcastle
"If all this was provided by core funding it wouldn't be an issue - charity funds should be the icing on the cake.""If all this was provided by core funding it wouldn't be an issue - charity funds should be the icing on the cake."
He added the funding situation resulted in large inequalities and often depended on local donations.He added the funding situation resulted in large inequalities and often depended on local donations.
"The absolute basic care around the country probably doesn't vary but the experience for the child and their family varies widely and I worry about how long it will be before that encroaches on treatment of children.""The absolute basic care around the country probably doesn't vary but the experience for the child and their family varies widely and I worry about how long it will be before that encroaches on treatment of children."
Social workSocial work
But Professor Sir Alan Craft, head of child health at the University of Newcastle questioned the accuracy of the figures.But Professor Sir Alan Craft, head of child health at the University of Newcastle questioned the accuracy of the figures.
"There is no doubt that charities were instrumental in establishing paediatric oncology units in their early days."There is no doubt that charities were instrumental in establishing paediatric oncology units in their early days.
"Now there is little charity funding apart from social work."Now there is little charity funding apart from social work.
"In Newcastle, we have charity funding for social work, partly, and a nursery nurse but the rest of the unit is NHS funded - so here it is certainly less than 5%.""In Newcastle, we have charity funding for social work, partly, and a nursery nurse but the rest of the unit is NHS funded - so here it is certainly less than 5%."
Susan George, CLIC Sargent's lead on community services for children and young people with cancer said they fund over 60 medical and clinical posts within the NHS.Susan George, CLIC Sargent's lead on community services for children and young people with cancer said they fund over 60 medical and clinical posts within the NHS.
The charity, who also provide 150 social workers for children with cancer is currently carrying out a review with the Department of Health over provision of community support for young cancer patients.The charity, who also provide 150 social workers for children with cancer is currently carrying out a review with the Department of Health over provision of community support for young cancer patients.
A spokesperson for the Department of Health said cancer care for children has improved significantly in the last 10 years due to investment and reform with 75% of children successfully treated compared with 25% in the 1960s.A spokesperson for the Department of Health said cancer care for children has improved significantly in the last 10 years due to investment and reform with 75% of children successfully treated compared with 25% in the 1960s.
"In February, Care Services Minister, Ivan Lewis launched a £20m investment to improve palliative care services for the thousands of children with life-limiting or life-threatening conditions such as childhood cancers.""In February, Care Services Minister, Ivan Lewis launched a £20m investment to improve palliative care services for the thousands of children with life-limiting or life-threatening conditions such as childhood cancers."