This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/northern_ireland/6169648.stm
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Water charges 'may be in doubt' | Water charges 'may be in doubt' |
| (20 minutes later) | |
| The introduction of controversial water charges next April could be in doubt after a judgement in the High Court. | The introduction of controversial water charges next April could be in doubt after a judgement in the High Court. |
| The General Consumer Council has won a judicial review of the decision to bring in charges because it had not been adequately consulted. | The General Consumer Council has won a judicial review of the decision to bring in charges because it had not been adequately consulted. |
| The Consumer Council said the judgement was a landmark ruling. | The Consumer Council said the judgement was a landmark ruling. |
| But the government said it was confident charges would still be introduced in April. The legislation is due to go before parliament next week. | But the government said it was confident charges would still be introduced in April. The legislation is due to go before parliament next week. |
| During the hearing last month, the council's lawyer claimed that the Northern Ireland Office had rushed ahead with the legislation. | During the hearing last month, the council's lawyer claimed that the Northern Ireland Office had rushed ahead with the legislation. |
| He claimed the NIO feared a restored assembly would reject the rate. | He claimed the NIO feared a restored assembly would reject the rate. |
| This was rejected by Mr Justice Weatherup who said he was not suggesting any illegal impropriety on the part of ministers. | This was rejected by Mr Justice Weatherup who said he was not suggesting any illegal impropriety on the part of ministers. |
| However, he added that there should have been proper consultation with the council before the legislation was laid before parliament. | However, he added that there should have been proper consultation with the council before the legislation was laid before parliament. |
| 'Essential services' | 'Essential services' |
| Regional Development Minister David Cairns said the government was "fully justified in proceeding with the legislative process in view of the courts ruling". | |
| "We appreciate that the introduction of new charges is never popular but it is crucial to underpin the economy of Northern Ireland that we put these essential services on a sustainable financial basis," he added. | |
| Consumer Council chairman Steve Costello said the judgement firmly established that the government had a legal duty to properly consult on matters of such importance. | |
| "This is a victory for the consumers' voice as this issue will impact on every home and business in Northern Ireland for a long time to come," said Mr Costello. | |
| "We brought the government to court because consumers were not being heard and, in doing so, fulfilled our statutory remit to safeguard and protect consumers." | |
| BBC Northern Ireland correspondent Mike McKimm said: "The legislation bringing in the charges will still go through Westminster next week, but the judge is adding a declaration, or as he described it, a 'compact statement' of the courts' conclusions. | |
| "Then it's up to parliament, having read this declaration, to either pass the legislation or throw it out if they feel it's flawed. | "Then it's up to parliament, having read this declaration, to either pass the legislation or throw it out if they feel it's flawed. |
| "So we won't know if the new water charges are absolutely guaranteed for the 1 April next year until later next week." | "So we won't know if the new water charges are absolutely guaranteed for the 1 April next year until later next week." |