This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/world/south_asia/6155842.stm
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 1 | Version 2 |
---|---|
Senate agrees India nuclear deal | Senate agrees India nuclear deal |
(40 minutes later) | |
The US Senate has overwhelmingly voted to pass a controversial deal to share civilian nuclear technology with India. | The US Senate has overwhelmingly voted to pass a controversial deal to share civilian nuclear technology with India. |
The deal was proposed over a year ago as a way to boost ties with a strategic ally. In exchange, India must allow the US to inspect its civilian reactors. | The deal was proposed over a year ago as a way to boost ties with a strategic ally. In exchange, India must allow the US to inspect its civilian reactors. |
Critics have argued the agreement will be detrimental to global anti-nuclear proliferation efforts. | Critics have argued the agreement will be detrimental to global anti-nuclear proliferation efforts. |
But President George W Bush hailed the move as bringing India into the "nuclear non-proliferation mainstream". | But President George W Bush hailed the move as bringing India into the "nuclear non-proliferation mainstream". |
"As India's economy continues to grow, this partnership will help India meet its energy needs without increasing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions," he said. | "As India's economy continues to grow, this partnership will help India meet its energy needs without increasing air pollution and greenhouse gas emissions," he said. |
The legislation was adopted by 85 votes to 12 in the Senate after a series of proposed amendments - which India had opposed - were defeated. | The legislation was adopted by 85 votes to 12 in the Senate after a series of proposed amendments - which India had opposed - were defeated. |
The Senate bill and a version passed by the House of Representatives, the lower house of the US Congress, must be reconciled and approved by Mr Bush before the legislation can take effect. | |
Important fillip | Important fillip |
The deal is a "lasting incentive" for India not to test nuclear weapons and "to co-operate closely with the United States in stopping proliferation", Senator Richard Lugar said as the upper house of the American parliament began debating the bill. | The deal is a "lasting incentive" for India not to test nuclear weapons and "to co-operate closely with the United States in stopping proliferation", Senator Richard Lugar said as the upper house of the American parliament began debating the bill. |
Mid-term fallout on deal | Mid-term fallout on deal |
Correspondents say that once the legislation is eventually approved, the initiative will overturn decades of US anti-proliferation policy. | Correspondents say that once the legislation is eventually approved, the initiative will overturn decades of US anti-proliferation policy. |
They say that while success for the bill in the Senate hands President George W Bush an important fillip, several obstacles loom before the two countries can begin trade in civilian nuclear materials. | They say that while success for the bill in the Senate hands President George W Bush an important fillip, several obstacles loom before the two countries can begin trade in civilian nuclear materials. |
India would need to get approval for the deal from the Nuclear Suppliers Group, an assembly of nations that export nuclear material. | India would need to get approval for the deal from the Nuclear Suppliers Group, an assembly of nations that export nuclear material. |
Delhi would also need to negotiate a safeguard agreement with the UN nuclear watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency. | Delhi would also need to negotiate a safeguard agreement with the UN nuclear watchdog, the International Atomic Energy Agency. |
There is also some concern about the transfer of missile technology to Iran by at least two Indian firms, recently black-listed by the US government. | There is also some concern about the transfer of missile technology to Iran by at least two Indian firms, recently black-listed by the US government. |
Overwhelming majority | Overwhelming majority |
Once those hurdles have been overcome, technical negotiations would need to be completed between the two countries before Congress holds another vote on the overall deal. | Once those hurdles have been overcome, technical negotiations would need to be completed between the two countries before Congress holds another vote on the overall deal. |
The BBC's Shahzeb Jillani in Washington says that the Bush administration sees the deal as one of its most important foreign policy initiatives. | The BBC's Shahzeb Jillani in Washington says that the Bush administration sees the deal as one of its most important foreign policy initiatives. |
Overall, the agreement has enjoyed strong bipartisan support among US lawmakers. | Overall, the agreement has enjoyed strong bipartisan support among US lawmakers. |
Earlier this year, the House of Representatives passed its version of the bill with an overwhelming majority. | Earlier this year, the House of Representatives passed its version of the bill with an overwhelming majority. |
The Indian Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, strongly defended the deal in the Indian parliament in August. | The Indian Prime Minister, Manmohan Singh, strongly defended the deal in the Indian parliament in August. |
He said India would not accept any move by Washington that would impede its atomic weapons programme, nor would it allow any international scrutiny of its military facilities. | He said India would not accept any move by Washington that would impede its atomic weapons programme, nor would it allow any international scrutiny of its military facilities. |
But Mr Singh also argued that the deal was in India's interests. | But Mr Singh also argued that the deal was in India's interests. |
He said mass poverty could only be removed by a fast expanding economy, which in turn needed energy. | He said mass poverty could only be removed by a fast expanding economy, which in turn needed energy. |