This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at https://www.theguardian.com/politics/live/2016/jul/22/corbyn-eagle-abuse-labour-mps-cameron-honours-politics-live
The article has changed 16 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 9 | Version 10 |
---|---|
Jeremy Corbyn denies bullying over threat to ring MP's Sinn Féin father - live | Jeremy Corbyn denies bullying over threat to ring MP's Sinn Féin father - live |
(35 minutes later) | |
1.18pm BST | |
13:18 | |
Corbyn’s camp has again insisted that the Labour leader did not threaten to call the father of Labour MP Conor McGinn. “Jeremy did not at any point threaten to call Conor’s dad, nor did he call him,” a spokesman told Politics Home. | |
New Corbyn line on Conor McGinn: "Jeremy did not at any point threaten to call Conor's dad. nor did he call him." | |
McGinn, who technically still serves as an opposition whip, has not withdrawn the accusation. | |
I've known Jeremy for over a decade. Respected him & worked for him. But I can't tolerate his hypocrisy any longer https://t.co/G8PDcIUSV3 | |
12.57pm BST | |
12:57 | |
Here’s a roundup of what’s happened so far today: | |
12.33pm BST | 12.33pm BST |
12:33 | 12:33 |
Peter Walker | Peter Walker |
More on the bullying row from Peter Walker: | More on the bullying row from Peter Walker: |
Jeremy Corbyn has been forced to deny bullying his political opponents after one of his MPs alleged that the Labour leader had threatened to telephone his father amid a row over the party’s direction. | Jeremy Corbyn has been forced to deny bullying his political opponents after one of his MPs alleged that the Labour leader had threatened to telephone his father amid a row over the party’s direction. |
Corbyn has denied such a conversation ever took place, but Conor McGinn, the opposition whip, has insisted the leader of party said he would call his Sinn Féin supporting father over complaints about Labour’s direction. | Corbyn has denied such a conversation ever took place, but Conor McGinn, the opposition whip, has insisted the leader of party said he would call his Sinn Féin supporting father over complaints about Labour’s direction. |
The disagreement began with a statement from McGinn, the St Helens North MP since last year and a member of the Labour whips office, posted on Friday morning on the Politics Home website. | The disagreement began with a statement from McGinn, the St Helens North MP since last year and a member of the Labour whips office, posted on Friday morning on the Politics Home website. |
McGinn said he had been told by fellow whips that after Corbyn had been angered by an interview McGinn gave, he had proposed telephoning the MP’s father, who is a Sinn Féin councillor, to seek his intervention. While the call was never made, McGinn said the suggestion was “shocking and embarrassing, and almost unbelievable”. | McGinn said he had been told by fellow whips that after Corbyn had been angered by an interview McGinn gave, he had proposed telephoning the MP’s father, who is a Sinn Féin councillor, to seek his intervention. While the call was never made, McGinn said the suggestion was “shocking and embarrassing, and almost unbelievable”. |
Speaking to Sky News later, Corbyn denied he had made any threats. “I don’t do any abuse, I don’t do any bullying,” he said. A spokesman for the Labour leader’s office said Corbyn was denying any conversation took place about phoning McGinn’s father. | Speaking to Sky News later, Corbyn denied he had made any threats. “I don’t do any abuse, I don’t do any bullying,” he said. A spokesman for the Labour leader’s office said Corbyn was denying any conversation took place about phoning McGinn’s father. |
Related: Corbyn denies threatening to phone MP's father over row | Related: Corbyn denies threatening to phone MP's father over row |
11.56am BST | 11.56am BST |
11:56 | 11:56 |
Jessica Elgot | Jessica Elgot |
Former pensions minister Ros Altmann has said her time in David Cameron’s government was like being in detention, and said the stress of not being free to speak her mind had affected her health. | Former pensions minister Ros Altmann has said her time in David Cameron’s government was like being in detention, and said the stress of not being free to speak her mind had affected her health. |
“It has been the most terrible experience for me,” she told the Jewish Chronicle, saying she felt “micro-controlled” during her 14 months in government. “It affected my health without question. It’s a very uncomfortable experience,” she said. | “It has been the most terrible experience for me,” she told the Jewish Chronicle, saying she felt “micro-controlled” during her 14 months in government. “It affected my health without question. It’s a very uncomfortable experience,” she said. |
Altmann was a regular media personality as the former director-general of Saga Group, before she was given a peerage. But she said she had been told not to speak to journalists and direct all queries to the press office, who did not understand pensions in the same detail. | Altmann was a regular media personality as the former director-general of Saga Group, before she was given a peerage. But she said she had been told not to speak to journalists and direct all queries to the press office, who did not understand pensions in the same detail. |
“The instructions I had were: ‘If any journalist phones you; then they are always out to trick you and trap you’. What I found difficult was not being able to explain policy to the media; and thereby to the public in an open and honest way; which is what I have always done.” | “The instructions I had were: ‘If any journalist phones you; then they are always out to trick you and trap you’. What I found difficult was not being able to explain policy to the media; and thereby to the public in an open and honest way; which is what I have always done.” |
“Now and again I was very naughty, and I would actually speak to a journalist and take the consequences because I thought: ‘Stuff it, I have had enough of this’. But then you get called in to see the Secretary of State. It’s like being in school, like being in the naughty corner or detention.” | “Now and again I was very naughty, and I would actually speak to a journalist and take the consequences because I thought: ‘Stuff it, I have had enough of this’. But then you get called in to see the Secretary of State. It’s like being in school, like being in the naughty corner or detention.” |
Altmann, who earlier this week told the FT she had been “frozen out” of talks over the purchase of Tata Steel despite grave concerns she had over proposed legal changes for the company to shed its pension liability, and the precedent that would set, said she felt she could have more impact outside of government. | Altmann, who earlier this week told the FT she had been “frozen out” of talks over the purchase of Tata Steel despite grave concerns she had over proposed legal changes for the company to shed its pension liability, and the precedent that would set, said she felt she could have more impact outside of government. |
“As I said to the prime minister, I am not going anywhere. I am still in the Lords and I am still offering to help. I can help as long as legislation goes through, to try and move it in a better direction, lead debates and ask the right questions.” | “As I said to the prime minister, I am not going anywhere. I am still in the Lords and I am still offering to help. I can help as long as legislation goes through, to try and move it in a better direction, lead debates and ask the right questions.” |
11.52am BST | 11.52am BST |
11:52 | 11:52 |
Smith echoed Theresa May’s attack on Corbyn as an unscrupulous boss. | Smith echoed Theresa May’s attack on Corbyn as an unscrupulous boss. |
Asked by Sky News about Corbyn’s threats of deselecting rebel MPs, the Labour leadership contender said: “It is not kinder and gentler if you are the boss of an organisation and the workers are unhappy to threaten to give them the sack. It is the sort of thing that you might see at Sports Direct. It is not what you should be expecting in the Labour party.” | Asked by Sky News about Corbyn’s threats of deselecting rebel MPs, the Labour leadership contender said: “It is not kinder and gentler if you are the boss of an organisation and the workers are unhappy to threaten to give them the sack. It is the sort of thing that you might see at Sports Direct. It is not what you should be expecting in the Labour party.” |
The criticism follows a similar line of attack against Corbyn by May in her first prime minister’s questions. Asked by Corbyn about job insecurity, she said: “I suspect that many members on the opposition benches might be familiar with an unscrupulous boss – a boss who does not listen to his workers, a boss who requires some of his workers to double their workload and maybe even a boss who exploits the rules to further his own career. Remind you of anyone?” | The criticism follows a similar line of attack against Corbyn by May in her first prime minister’s questions. Asked by Corbyn about job insecurity, she said: “I suspect that many members on the opposition benches might be familiar with an unscrupulous boss – a boss who does not listen to his workers, a boss who requires some of his workers to double their workload and maybe even a boss who exploits the rules to further his own career. Remind you of anyone?” |
Smith added: “Some of the infighting in Labour is because I suspect people are frustrated that they don’t see a prospect of Labour returning to power and therefore we are turning in on ourselves.” | Smith added: “Some of the infighting in Labour is because I suspect people are frustrated that they don’t see a prospect of Labour returning to power and therefore we are turning in on ourselves.” |
Asked if any of the 180,000 new Labour supporters would vote for him, Smith revealed that one of the new supporters was his mother. “My mam is one of them, so I’m hoping she’s definitely going to vote for me. I’m really pleased that we have got so many people wanting to take part in this contest.” | Asked if any of the 180,000 new Labour supporters would vote for him, Smith revealed that one of the new supporters was his mother. “My mam is one of them, so I’m hoping she’s definitely going to vote for me. I’m really pleased that we have got so many people wanting to take part in this contest.” |
On bullying he said: | On bullying he said: |
I’ve never been bullied by Jeremy. Jeremy is very softly spoken and very calm in his manner. But the problem is under his leadership there has been a culture of bullying. There has been intolerance and abuse in the Labour party, that we have never seen before. Women in Labour have found themselves subject to awful awful misogynistic abuse, some of our Jewish MPs have been subjected to antisemitic abuse, some of our Asian MPs have been subjected to abuse. None of that can be acceptable in the Labour party. | I’ve never been bullied by Jeremy. Jeremy is very softly spoken and very calm in his manner. But the problem is under his leadership there has been a culture of bullying. There has been intolerance and abuse in the Labour party, that we have never seen before. Women in Labour have found themselves subject to awful awful misogynistic abuse, some of our Jewish MPs have been subjected to antisemitic abuse, some of our Asian MPs have been subjected to abuse. None of that can be acceptable in the Labour party. |
Jeremy, of course, always says that he does no condone it, but somehow under his leadership we can’t deny the facts that this wasn’t something we saw in the Labour party before Jeremy Corbyn became leader and it’s now become common place in the Labour party. So something has gone badly wrong under his watch. | Jeremy, of course, always says that he does no condone it, but somehow under his leadership we can’t deny the facts that this wasn’t something we saw in the Labour party before Jeremy Corbyn became leader and it’s now become common place in the Labour party. So something has gone badly wrong under his watch. |
I fundamentally believe both Conor McGinn and Angela Eagle. Neither of them would tell lies about this. Conor has simply said that he understands that Jeremy was proposing to ring his father, who is a Sinn Féin councillor, and felt that was inappropriate as I think anybody would. I would be mortified if Jeremy was proposing to ring up my Dad to complain about me challenging him for the leadership. | I fundamentally believe both Conor McGinn and Angela Eagle. Neither of them would tell lies about this. Conor has simply said that he understands that Jeremy was proposing to ring his father, who is a Sinn Féin councillor, and felt that was inappropriate as I think anybody would. I would be mortified if Jeremy was proposing to ring up my Dad to complain about me challenging him for the leadership. |
This all speaks of a Labour party that is in crisis. We risk splitting the party. If that were to happen we would be destroyed. | This all speaks of a Labour party that is in crisis. We risk splitting the party. If that were to happen we would be destroyed. |
11.22am BST | 11.22am BST |
11:22 | 11:22 |
Owen Smith complains of 'culture of bullying' under Corbyn | Owen Smith complains of 'culture of bullying' under Corbyn |
Labour leadership challenger Owen Smith has complained of a “culture of bullying” under Jeremy Corbyn’s watch. In an interview with Sky News he said he had no reason to doubt claims made against Corbyn by Labour MPs Conor McGinn and Angela Eagle. | Labour leadership challenger Owen Smith has complained of a “culture of bullying” under Jeremy Corbyn’s watch. In an interview with Sky News he said he had no reason to doubt claims made against Corbyn by Labour MPs Conor McGinn and Angela Eagle. |
11.10am BST | 11.10am BST |
11:10 | 11:10 |
The popularity of Corbyn threatens a paradigm shift in thinking from both the Labour party and, ahem, the Guardian, according author and journalist Jonathan Cook. | The popularity of Corbyn threatens a paradigm shift in thinking from both the Labour party and, ahem, the Guardian, according author and journalist Jonathan Cook. |
Writing on his blog, he argues: | Writing on his blog, he argues: |
The old elites, whether in the Labour parliamentary party or the Guardian editorial offices, sense the danger, even if they lack the necessary awareness to appreciate Corbyn’s significance. They will fight tooth and nail to protect what they have. They will do so even if their efforts create so much anger and resentment they risk unleashing darker political forces. | The old elites, whether in the Labour parliamentary party or the Guardian editorial offices, sense the danger, even if they lack the necessary awareness to appreciate Corbyn’s significance. They will fight tooth and nail to protect what they have. They will do so even if their efforts create so much anger and resentment they risk unleashing darker political forces. |
Corbyn’s style of socialism draws on enduring traditions and values – of compassion, community and solidarity – that the young have never really known except in history books. Those values seem very appealing to a generation trapped in the dying days of a deeply atomised, materialist, hyper-competitive world. They want change and Corbyn offers them a path to it. | Corbyn’s style of socialism draws on enduring traditions and values – of compassion, community and solidarity – that the young have never really known except in history books. Those values seem very appealing to a generation trapped in the dying days of a deeply atomised, materialist, hyper-competitive world. They want change and Corbyn offers them a path to it. |
But whatever his critics claim, Corbyn isn’t just a relic of past politics. Despite his age, he is also a very modern figure. He exudes a Zen-like calm, a self-awareness and a self-effacement that inspires those who have been raised in a world of 24-hour narcissism. | But whatever his critics claim, Corbyn isn’t just a relic of past politics. Despite his age, he is also a very modern figure. He exudes a Zen-like calm, a self-awareness and a self-effacement that inspires those who have been raised in a world of 24-hour narcissism. |
In these increasingly desperate times, Cobyn’s message is reaching well beyond the young, of course. A paradigm shift doesn’t occur just because the young replace the old. It involves the old coming to accept – however reluctantly – that the young may have found an answer to a question they had forgotten needed answering. Many in the older generation know about solidarity and community. They may have been dazzled by promises of an aspirational lifestyle and the baubles of rampant consumption, but it is slowly dawning on them too that this model has a rapidly approaching sell-by date. | In these increasingly desperate times, Cobyn’s message is reaching well beyond the young, of course. A paradigm shift doesn’t occur just because the young replace the old. It involves the old coming to accept – however reluctantly – that the young may have found an answer to a question they had forgotten needed answering. Many in the older generation know about solidarity and community. They may have been dazzled by promises of an aspirational lifestyle and the baubles of rampant consumption, but it is slowly dawning on them too that this model has a rapidly approaching sell-by date. |
Those most wedded to the neoliberal model – the political, economic and media elites – will be the last to be weaned off a system that has so richly rewarded them. They would rather bring the whole house crashing down than give Corbyn and his supporters the chance to repair it. | Those most wedded to the neoliberal model – the political, economic and media elites – will be the last to be weaned off a system that has so richly rewarded them. They would rather bring the whole house crashing down than give Corbyn and his supporters the chance to repair it. |
10.57am BST | 10.57am BST |
10:57 | 10:57 |
Patrick Wintour | Patrick Wintour |
Boris Johnson, the British foreign secretary, has taken issue with the Republican US presidential nominee, Donald Trump, by emphasising the importance of Nato’s doctrine of mutual defence. | Boris Johnson, the British foreign secretary, has taken issue with the Republican US presidential nominee, Donald Trump, by emphasising the importance of Nato’s doctrine of mutual defence. |
Trump questioned the doctrine this week when he said he would weigh up whether other Nato members “fulfill their obligations” before deciding whether the US would protect them in the face of external aggression. | Trump questioned the doctrine this week when he said he would weigh up whether other Nato members “fulfill their obligations” before deciding whether the US would protect them in the face of external aggression. |
Johnson, speaking in Washington DC, insisted he was not getting involved in US politics but stressed the UK’s commitment to the policy of mutual defence. | Johnson, speaking in Washington DC, insisted he was not getting involved in US politics but stressed the UK’s commitment to the policy of mutual defence. |
He said: “I think that article five in the Nato treaty of 1948, the doctrine of mutual defence, is incredibly important. It’s something that I’ve repeated several times already just in the last week to various other countries, and my counterparts in various other countries around Europe, in the Baltic countries and elsewhere. | He said: “I think that article five in the Nato treaty of 1948, the doctrine of mutual defence, is incredibly important. It’s something that I’ve repeated several times already just in the last week to various other countries, and my counterparts in various other countries around Europe, in the Baltic countries and elsewhere. |
10.49am BST | 10.49am BST |
10:49 | 10:49 |
PMI slump | PMI slump |
Nick Fletcher | Nick Fletcher |
The UK economy shrank at its fastest rate since the financial crisis of seven years ago, following the vote to leave the European Union, according to a survey of business activity. | The UK economy shrank at its fastest rate since the financial crisis of seven years ago, following the vote to leave the European Union, according to a survey of business activity. |
In the first survey of business confidence since the Brexit referendum, the services sector was particularly hard hit, showing its biggest drop on record. | In the first survey of business confidence since the Brexit referendum, the services sector was particularly hard hit, showing its biggest drop on record. |
With manufacturing dropping to its lowest level since February 2013, the survey suggests UK GDP could shrink by 0.4% in the third quarter, according to Markit, which compiles the data. | With manufacturing dropping to its lowest level since February 2013, the survey suggests UK GDP could shrink by 0.4% in the third quarter, according to Markit, which compiles the data. |
Related: Britain's economy shrinking at fastest rate since 2009, says survey | Related: Britain's economy shrinking at fastest rate since 2009, says survey |
Don’t say we didn’t warn you says remain campaigner Angela Eagle. | Don’t say we didn’t warn you says remain campaigner Angela Eagle. |
As we warned : BBC News - Brexit plunges UK economy to worst level since 2009, data suggests https://t.co/R6K4bnrzXy | As we warned : BBC News - Brexit plunges UK economy to worst level since 2009, data suggests https://t.co/R6K4bnrzXy |
10.36am BST | 10.36am BST |
10:36 | 10:36 |
Anushka Asthana | Anushka Asthana |
Politicians have allowed xenophobia, Islamophobia and antisemitism to enter the mainstream as a result of their toxic and divisive campaigning, according to Lady Warsi. | Politicians have allowed xenophobia, Islamophobia and antisemitism to enter the mainstream as a result of their toxic and divisive campaigning, according to Lady Warsi. |
The Conservative peer and former party co-chair told the Guardian she was deeply worried about the current political climate, claiming a surge in “respectable racism” was feeding the far right. | The Conservative peer and former party co-chair told the Guardian she was deeply worried about the current political climate, claiming a surge in “respectable racism” was feeding the far right. |
“I was still disgusted but more comfortable with the racism of the 70s and 80s that was overt and thuggish, than this new form of respectable xenophobia where it is done in political circles, journalism and academia,” she said. | “I was still disgusted but more comfortable with the racism of the 70s and 80s that was overt and thuggish, than this new form of respectable xenophobia where it is done in political circles, journalism and academia,” she said. |
Warsi argued that the EU referendum and London mayoralty campaigns had helped create a climate in which people feel it is acceptable to tell long-established British communities “it’s time for you to leave”. | Warsi argued that the EU referendum and London mayoralty campaigns had helped create a climate in which people feel it is acceptable to tell long-established British communities “it’s time for you to leave”. |
Referring to a spike in hate crime since the 23 June EU vote, she said: “I do not hold anybody who voted for Brexit responsible for the rise in racism; I don’t hold people who believed in Brexit responsible; but I definitely hold politicians, who put out divisive xenophobic messages and posters, responsible because this created the atmosphere in which this thrived.” | Referring to a spike in hate crime since the 23 June EU vote, she said: “I do not hold anybody who voted for Brexit responsible for the rise in racism; I don’t hold people who believed in Brexit responsible; but I definitely hold politicians, who put out divisive xenophobic messages and posters, responsible because this created the atmosphere in which this thrived.” |
Related: Politicians to blame for rise of 'respectable racism', says Lady Warsi | Related: Politicians to blame for rise of 'respectable racism', says Lady Warsi |
10.28am BST | 10.28am BST |
10:28 | 10:28 |
An anti Corbyn campaigner has turned to the stop-motion children’s television series Trumpton to mock the Labour leader and his supporters in the Momentum movement. Here’s a sample of Momentum Trumpton tweets: | An anti Corbyn campaigner has turned to the stop-motion children’s television series Trumpton to mock the Labour leader and his supporters in the Momentum movement. Here’s a sample of Momentum Trumpton tweets: |
Threats of deselection escalated to include every man, animal, plant & microorganism. Daisy branded as blairite scum pic.twitter.com/2bh3qeTelm | Threats of deselection escalated to include every man, animal, plant & microorganism. Daisy branded as blairite scum pic.twitter.com/2bh3qeTelm |
Dr Mopp has heard 'big pharma is bad' from the Dear Leader so asks Farmer Bell if he'll grow some drugs for him pic.twitter.com/urUP2Oc997 | Dr Mopp has heard 'big pharma is bad' from the Dear Leader so asks Farmer Bell if he'll grow some drugs for him pic.twitter.com/urUP2Oc997 |
James Schneider was pleased with the work Momentum had done in aiding his next party destination pic.twitter.com/Rt22vHO0hW | James Schneider was pleased with the work Momentum had done in aiding his next party destination pic.twitter.com/Rt22vHO0hW |