This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2016/06/15/world/europe/london-bans-ads-with-unrealistic-body-images.html
The article has changed 7 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| London Mayor Cracks Down on Ads Promoting Unhealthy Body Image | London Mayor Cracks Down on Ads Promoting Unhealthy Body Image |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| LONDON — The young, thin model wore a bright yellow bikini and stared seductively at passers-by. | LONDON — The young, thin model wore a bright yellow bikini and stared seductively at passers-by. |
| “Are you beach body ready?” asked the ad for Protein World, a maker of dietary supplements. The ad was defaced in subway stations across London when it appeared in April 2015, and it drew strong protests. | “Are you beach body ready?” asked the ad for Protein World, a maker of dietary supplements. The ad was defaced in subway stations across London when it appeared in April 2015, and it drew strong protests. |
| On Monday, London’s new mayor, Sadiq Khan, announced a ban on such ads — which critics call “fat-shaming” — from London’s public transportation system starting in July, saying the messages encourage unhealthy body images for young women. | |
| “As the father of two teenage girls, I am extremely concerned about this kind of advertising, which can demean people, particularly women, and make them ashamed of their bodies,” Mr. Khan said. “Nobody should feel pressurized, while they travel on the Tube or bus, into unrealistic expectations surrounding their bodies.” | “As the father of two teenage girls, I am extremely concerned about this kind of advertising, which can demean people, particularly women, and make them ashamed of their bodies,” Mr. Khan said. “Nobody should feel pressurized, while they travel on the Tube or bus, into unrealistic expectations surrounding their bodies.” |
| The move is the latest effort by the authorities in Europe and elsewhere to address concerns about unrealistic or unhealthy body images in advertising, and the effect that impossibly thin models can have on the self-esteem and health of consumers. France, Israel, Italy and Spain have enacted policies aimed at preventing models with stick-thin bodies from working in the industry. | The move is the latest effort by the authorities in Europe and elsewhere to address concerns about unrealistic or unhealthy body images in advertising, and the effect that impossibly thin models can have on the self-esteem and health of consumers. France, Israel, Italy and Spain have enacted policies aimed at preventing models with stick-thin bodies from working in the industry. |
| The mayor, who said he wanted to send a “clear message” to the advertising industry, said the new guidelines would apply to any form of transit run by Transport for London that could create body-confidence issues. | The mayor, who said he wanted to send a “clear message” to the advertising industry, said the new guidelines would apply to any form of transit run by Transport for London that could create body-confidence issues. |
| An estimated 12,000 ads appear annually in London’s transport network, and Mr. Khan was following through on a campaign pledge in imposing restrictions on them. | An estimated 12,000 ads appear annually in London’s transport network, and Mr. Khan was following through on a campaign pledge in imposing restrictions on them. |
| Transport for London said in a statement that it would not allow ads that “could reasonably be seen as likely to cause pressure to conform to an unrealistic or unhealthy body shape, or as likely to create body-confidence issues, particularly among young people.” | Transport for London said in a statement that it would not allow ads that “could reasonably be seen as likely to cause pressure to conform to an unrealistic or unhealthy body shape, or as likely to create body-confidence issues, particularly among young people.” |
| Graeme Craig, the agency’s commercial development director, said the new rules were necessary because passengers were a captive audience. | Graeme Craig, the agency’s commercial development director, said the new rules were necessary because passengers were a captive audience. |
| Unlike ads that appear in other forums, like television, online and print, he said, passengers on public transportation “cannot simply switch off or turn a page if an advertisement offends or upsets them — and we have a duty to ensure the copy we carry reflects that unique environment.” | Unlike ads that appear in other forums, like television, online and print, he said, passengers on public transportation “cannot simply switch off or turn a page if an advertisement offends or upsets them — and we have a duty to ensure the copy we carry reflects that unique environment.” |
| The announcement of the ban inspired mixed reactions, with some saying that Mr. Khan, a member of the Labour Party, had performed a public service by fighting the regular portrayal of unrealistic body types. | The announcement of the ban inspired mixed reactions, with some saying that Mr. Khan, a member of the Labour Party, had performed a public service by fighting the regular portrayal of unrealistic body types. |
| “A great start for London’s ‘feminist Mayor’ ” Women’s Equality Party wrote on Twitter. | “A great start for London’s ‘feminist Mayor’ ” Women’s Equality Party wrote on Twitter. |
| But some critics suggested that Mr. Khan, a Muslim, was using the ad ban to clamp down on racy images of women because they were counter to the norms of conservative Islam. Mr. Khan’s office declined to comment when asked about that line of criticism. | But some critics suggested that Mr. Khan, a Muslim, was using the ad ban to clamp down on racy images of women because they were counter to the norms of conservative Islam. Mr. Khan’s office declined to comment when asked about that line of criticism. |
| Mr. Khan is the son of a bus driver who grew up in public housing, and his religion drew attention in the mayoral race, with a rival candidate, Zac Goldsmith, accusing him of giving “oxygen and cover” to extremists. | Mr. Khan is the son of a bus driver who grew up in public housing, and his religion drew attention in the mayoral race, with a rival candidate, Zac Goldsmith, accusing him of giving “oxygen and cover” to extremists. |
| Ian Twinn, a spokesman for the Incorporated Society of British Advertisers, which represents about 450 British companies, said he had no problem with the regulation as long as it focused solely on not promoting unhealthy body images. | Ian Twinn, a spokesman for the Incorporated Society of British Advertisers, which represents about 450 British companies, said he had no problem with the regulation as long as it focused solely on not promoting unhealthy body images. |
| “Parents don’t want their children to see ads of models who are unhealthily thin children, and send out a message that this is what you should look like,” he said. “Equally, we don’t want people who are comfortably chubby threatening to ban perfectly reasonable ads. We are not meant to go around with excessive fat on our waists. If fat is the new normal, we don’t want that to be the reason to sensor people who are not fat. That seems barmy.” | “Parents don’t want their children to see ads of models who are unhealthily thin children, and send out a message that this is what you should look like,” he said. “Equally, we don’t want people who are comfortably chubby threatening to ban perfectly reasonable ads. We are not meant to go around with excessive fat on our waists. If fat is the new normal, we don’t want that to be the reason to sensor people who are not fat. That seems barmy.” |
| Mr. Twinn said the model in the Protein World ad had a toned and athletic body, a perspective that was echoed by the Advertising Standards Authority. | Mr. Twinn said the model in the Protein World ad had a toned and athletic body, a perspective that was echoed by the Advertising Standards Authority. |
| After receiving 378 complaints last year about the ad, the advertising board ruled that it was not offensive or irresponsible. It did, however, ban the ad because of concerns about its health and weight loss claims. | After receiving 378 complaints last year about the ad, the advertising board ruled that it was not offensive or irresponsible. It did, however, ban the ad because of concerns about its health and weight loss claims. |
| Protein World, for its part, told the board that the phrase “beach body” was commonly used and understood to mean looking one’s best. | Protein World, for its part, told the board that the phrase “beach body” was commonly used and understood to mean looking one’s best. |
| It said that the model in the ad had a “healthy figure” and that the company “did not believe that the ad implied everyone should look like the model or that the text and image were irresponsible.” | It said that the model in the ad had a “healthy figure” and that the company “did not believe that the ad implied everyone should look like the model or that the text and image were irresponsible.” |
| Last year, the French Parliament approved measures aimed at preventing modeling agencies from hiring models deemed dangerously thin. | Last year, the French Parliament approved measures aimed at preventing modeling agencies from hiring models deemed dangerously thin. |
| Under the law, models need a doctor’s certificate to certify they are fit to work, and employers are at risk of jail or fines of 75,000 euros, or about $85,000, if they break the rules. | Under the law, models need a doctor’s certificate to certify they are fit to work, and employers are at risk of jail or fines of 75,000 euros, or about $85,000, if they break the rules. |