This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-eu-referendum-36397732
The article has changed 8 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
EU referendum campaigns 'misleading voters' | EU referendum campaigns 'misleading voters' |
(35 minutes later) | |
The two sides in the EU referendum campaign have been accused of peddling "misleading" figures and "implausible assumptions" by a committee of MPs. | The two sides in the EU referendum campaign have been accused of peddling "misleading" figures and "implausible assumptions" by a committee of MPs. |
The Treasury Select Committee calls Vote Leave's claim that leaving the EU would save £350m a week "deeply problematic". | The Treasury Select Committee calls Vote Leave's claim that leaving the EU would save £350m a week "deeply problematic". |
And it criticises the Remain campaign's claim the cost of imports could rise by "at least" £11bn if the UK leaves. | And it criticises the Remain campaign's claim the cost of imports could rise by "at least" £11bn if the UK leaves. |
The rival groups are failing to inform the public, the MPs say. | The rival groups are failing to inform the public, the MPs say. |
Vote Leave's £350m a week claim - repeated again today - does not take into account Britain's rebate and payments that flow back to the UK, the committee, chaired by Conservative MP Andrew Tyrie, says. | Vote Leave's £350m a week claim - repeated again today - does not take into account Britain's rebate and payments that flow back to the UK, the committee, chaired by Conservative MP Andrew Tyrie, says. |
"Vote Leave's persistence with it is deeply problematic," the report says. | "Vote Leave's persistence with it is deeply problematic," the report says. |
"It sits very awkwardly with its promises to the Electoral Commission to work in a spirit that reflects its "very significant responsibility" and the "gravity of the choice facing the British people". | "It sits very awkwardly with its promises to the Electoral Commission to work in a spirit that reflects its "very significant responsibility" and the "gravity of the choice facing the British people". |
Are we giving £350m a week to Brussels? | |
Do we get £1,200 back for every £120 we put into the EU? | |
Would Brexit cost your family £4,300? | |
The report says Britain Stronger In Europe's claim that the cost of imports could rise by "at least" £11bn and have a knock-on effect on household bills is based on an "implausible assumption". | The report says Britain Stronger In Europe's claim that the cost of imports could rise by "at least" £11bn and have a knock-on effect on household bills is based on an "implausible assumption". |
"Presenting the figures on the impact of Brexit on a per-household basis, as the Stronger In campaign has done, is likely to be misconstrued by readers, especially in the heat of a campaign, and probably has confused them," it said. | "Presenting the figures on the impact of Brexit on a per-household basis, as the Stronger In campaign has done, is likely to be misconstrued by readers, especially in the heat of a campaign, and probably has confused them," it said. |
"It may have left many readers thinking that the figures refer to the effect of leaving the EU on household disposable income, which they do not." | "It may have left many readers thinking that the figures refer to the effect of leaving the EU on household disposable income, which they do not." |
The committee also finds that it is misleading to claim that three million jobs are dependent on Britain's membership of the EU. | The committee also finds that it is misleading to claim that three million jobs are dependent on Britain's membership of the EU. |
"Without an estimate of how much trade would be lost as a result of Brexit, the impact on job losses cannot readily be estimated," it said. | "Without an estimate of how much trade would be lost as a result of Brexit, the impact on job losses cannot readily be estimated," it said. |
"The wider public might form the mistaken impression that all these jobs would be lost or at risk if the UK left the EU. | "The wider public might form the mistaken impression that all these jobs would be lost or at risk if the UK left the EU. |
"Campaigners should be clear that three million jobs may be associated with, but would not necessarily be dependent on, our membership of the EU." | "Campaigners should be clear that three million jobs may be associated with, but would not necessarily be dependent on, our membership of the EU." |
The report also singles out Vote Leave's Matthew Elliott and Dominic Cummings for their "appalling" treatment of the committee. | The report also singles out Vote Leave's Matthew Elliott and Dominic Cummings for their "appalling" treatment of the committee. |
The cross-party committee also says it is "highly unsatisfactory" that it was unable to scrutinise the government's analysis of the short-term impact of Brexit in time to include it in the report. | The cross-party committee also says it is "highly unsatisfactory" that it was unable to scrutinise the government's analysis of the short-term impact of Brexit in time to include it in the report. |
The report says: "It is to be hoped that scrutiny and transparency have not, in this case, been subordinated to the imperatives of the Number 10 'media grid'." | The report says: "It is to be hoped that scrutiny and transparency have not, in this case, been subordinated to the imperatives of the Number 10 'media grid'." |