This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2016/04/14/technology/europe-us-data-privacy.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Europe’s Privacy Watchdogs Call for Changes to U.S. Data-Transfer Deal | Europe’s Privacy Watchdogs Call for Changes to U.S. Data-Transfer Deal |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| Only two months after the European Union’s top policy makers agreed to a hard-won data-sharing pact with United States officials, the bloc’s national privacy regulators said on Wednesday that the deal did not go far enough to safeguard the personal information of Internet users in Europe. | |
| The agreement, the so-called E.U.-U.S. Privacy Shield, which would allow companies to continue sending personal data back and forth across the Atlantic, is still widely expected to be ratified by early summer. But by sounding the alarm over the current deal, national privacy watchdogs from France, Germany and other European Union member states have served notice that American companies like Google, Facebook and Amazon could face protracted country-by-country legal battles. | |
| The regulators say they worry that companies could misuse data, including information from search engine queries and social media posts. They also say they fear that American law enforcement and intelligence agencies might gain access to European citizens’ personal information without sufficient safeguards in place. | The regulators say they worry that companies could misuse data, including information from search engine queries and social media posts. They also say they fear that American law enforcement and intelligence agencies might gain access to European citizens’ personal information without sufficient safeguards in place. |
| “From the outside, it must look like Europe can’t speak with one voice on privacy,” said Patrick van Eecke, a data protection lawyer at DLA Piper in Brussels. “This is becoming kind of a circus.” | “From the outside, it must look like Europe can’t speak with one voice on privacy,” said Patrick van Eecke, a data protection lawyer at DLA Piper in Brussels. “This is becoming kind of a circus.” |
| The stance taken by the regulators — which have the power to investigate and, in some cases, to fine companies that have broken privacy rules in the region — represents a major setback for European and United States negotiators who had spent years hammering out the deal. | The stance taken by the regulators — which have the power to investigate and, in some cases, to fine companies that have broken privacy rules in the region — represents a major setback for European and United States negotiators who had spent years hammering out the deal. |
| And the protest from the regulators signals that they could open cases and levy fines on companies that rely on moving data such as employees’ financial information or social media posts across the Atlantic. | And the protest from the regulators signals that they could open cases and levy fines on companies that rely on moving data such as employees’ financial information or social media posts across the Atlantic. |
| As part of their announcement on Wednesday, European national privacy regulators said the data-transfer agreement was an improvement on previous rules. But they added that they remained concerned over American intelligence agencies’ seemingly indiscriminate access to citizens’ personal data when it is transferred to the United States. | As part of their announcement on Wednesday, European national privacy regulators said the data-transfer agreement was an improvement on previous rules. But they added that they remained concerned over American intelligence agencies’ seemingly indiscriminate access to citizens’ personal data when it is transferred to the United States. |
| That access, according to the privacy watchdogs, is not subject to protections that match those currently offered in Europe. The regulators also said that new legal mechanisms to allow Europeans to monitor how their data is used in the United States needed to be strengthened. | That access, according to the privacy watchdogs, is not subject to protections that match those currently offered in Europe. The regulators also said that new legal mechanisms to allow Europeans to monitor how their data is used in the United States needed to be strengthened. |
| “We believe there’s still work to do,” Isabelle Falque-Pierrotin, France’s data protection chief, who also heads a Pan-European privacy regulator, said on Wednesday. “We need to ensure that protections of the Privacy Shield are indeed essentially equivalent to what is available in Europe.” | “We believe there’s still work to do,” Isabelle Falque-Pierrotin, France’s data protection chief, who also heads a Pan-European privacy regulator, said on Wednesday. “We need to ensure that protections of the Privacy Shield are indeed essentially equivalent to what is available in Europe.” |
| Ms. Falque-Pierrotin called on the European Commission, the executive arm of the European Union that negotiated the data-transfer pact, to make further changes to the deal to meet the regulators’ concerns. | |
| Those included fears that the indiscriminate bulk collection of Europeans’ data by United States and European intelligence agencies failed to comply with the region’s data protection rules. The privacy agencies also said the independence of a United States ombudsman reviewing European data protection complaints had to be strengthened. | Those included fears that the indiscriminate bulk collection of Europeans’ data by United States and European intelligence agencies failed to comply with the region’s data protection rules. The privacy agencies also said the independence of a United States ombudsman reviewing European data protection complaints had to be strengthened. |
| Vera Jourova, the European justice commissioner, said in a statement on Wednesday that she would try to incorporate the regulators’ views into the final Privacy Shield pact, though she did not say which of the proposals would be included. | Vera Jourova, the European justice commissioner, said in a statement on Wednesday that she would try to incorporate the regulators’ views into the final Privacy Shield pact, though she did not say which of the proposals would be included. |
| But Ms. Jourova also emphasized that attention should now turn to getting European countries’ approval for the data-transfer agreement by next month. | But Ms. Jourova also emphasized that attention should now turn to getting European countries’ approval for the data-transfer agreement by next month. |
| “I count on data protection authorities to help ensure that the E.U.-U.S. Privacy Shield works well in practice,” she said. | “I count on data protection authorities to help ensure that the E.U.-U.S. Privacy Shield works well in practice,” she said. |
| European privacy campaigners, including Max Schrems, an Austrian law student whose case against Facebook led the region’s highest court to invalidate the previous trans-Atlantic data-sharing agreement, the so-called Safe Harbor pact, have called for greater restrictions on how companies and United States agencies gain access to users’ digital information. | |
| Some are also preparing legal challenges to the Privacy Shield deal, saying that it failed to uphold Europe’s tough privacy rules, which are viewed as being on a par with other fundamental rights, like freedom of expression. | Some are also preparing legal challenges to the Privacy Shield deal, saying that it failed to uphold Europe’s tough privacy rules, which are viewed as being on a par with other fundamental rights, like freedom of expression. |
| American officials contend that new oversight mechanisms — including an ombudsman in the State Department to handle European data queries — sufficiently protect privacy. They also say that American safeguards over how national intelligence agencies gain access to personal data go beyond what is available in many countries in the European Union. | American officials contend that new oversight mechanisms — including an ombudsman in the State Department to handle European data queries — sufficiently protect privacy. They also say that American safeguards over how national intelligence agencies gain access to personal data go beyond what is available in many countries in the European Union. |
| “The U.S. has a different structure than Europe, but both systems offer robust privacy protection,” Penny Pritzker, the United States commerce secretary who led the American team in negotiating to revamp the data-transfer agreement, said in a recent interview. | “The U.S. has a different structure than Europe, but both systems offer robust privacy protection,” Penny Pritzker, the United States commerce secretary who led the American team in negotiating to revamp the data-transfer agreement, said in a recent interview. |
| Despite Europe’s national regulators raising concerns over Privacy Shield, legal experts and policy makers still expect the agreement to be approved by European countries by early summer. | Despite Europe’s national regulators raising concerns over Privacy Shield, legal experts and policy makers still expect the agreement to be approved by European countries by early summer. |
| That is because the European Commission has the sole power to agree to the new rules, and because some countries, particularly the likes of Britain and Ireland, where many American technology companies have headquarters, have given their support to the trans-Atlantic deal. | That is because the European Commission has the sole power to agree to the new rules, and because some countries, particularly the likes of Britain and Ireland, where many American technology companies have headquarters, have given their support to the trans-Atlantic deal. |
| It remains unclear how the European Commission will alter Privacy Shield to answer national regulators’ concerns, though it is unlikely that European officials will reopen negotiations with their American counterparts. | It remains unclear how the European Commission will alter Privacy Shield to answer national regulators’ concerns, though it is unlikely that European officials will reopen negotiations with their American counterparts. |
| But Europe’s privacy regulators — which will soon gain the right to fine companies up to 4 percent of their global revenue if they are found to have broken local data protection laws — may still not be satisfied with any changes to the data-transfer agreement, increasing uncertainty over how some of the world’s largest companies will handle digital information. | But Europe’s privacy regulators — which will soon gain the right to fine companies up to 4 percent of their global revenue if they are found to have broken local data protection laws — may still not be satisfied with any changes to the data-transfer agreement, increasing uncertainty over how some of the world’s largest companies will handle digital information. |
| “No national regulator wants to put companies in a legal limbo,” said Alexander Whalen, a senior policy manager at Digital Europe, an industry body whose members include Google and Microsoft. “We’re now in a waiting game.” | “No national regulator wants to put companies in a legal limbo,” said Alexander Whalen, a senior policy manager at Digital Europe, an industry body whose members include Google and Microsoft. “We’re now in a waiting game.” |