This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/us-news/live/2016/mar/03/republican-presidential-debate-trump-rubio-cruz-fox-news-detroit-live
The article has changed 9 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 6 | Version 7 |
|---|---|
| Republican debate: candidates pledge to support Trump if needed – as it happened | |
| (35 minutes later) | |
| 4.56am GMT | |
| 04:56 | |
| The 11th Republican presidential debate has concluded. Here’s a breakdown of what happened: | |
| Trump: 'I'm softening' my policy on high-skilled foreign workers https://t.co/RIngjzLYs8 Genius strategy when your rise based on immigration | |
| Updated | |
| at 5.00am GMT | |
| 4.19am GMT | 4.19am GMT |
| 04:19 | 04:19 |
| Here are the top-tweeted #GOPDebate moments, via the metrics folks at Twitter: | Here are the top-tweeted #GOPDebate moments, via the metrics folks at Twitter: |
| 1. Trump defends his businesses, including Trump University. | 1. Trump defends his businesses, including Trump University. |
| 2. Cruz tells Trump to relax, Rubio follows up with a yoga joke. | 2. Cruz tells Trump to relax, Rubio follows up with a yoga joke. |
| 3. Trump calls Rubio “little Marco”; Chris Wallace live fact-checks Trump. | 3. Trump calls Rubio “little Marco”; Chris Wallace live fact-checks Trump. |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 4.29am GMT | at 4.29am GMT |
| 4.17am GMT | 4.17am GMT |
| 04:17 | 04:17 |
| From the comments / who won? | From the comments / who won? |
| We haven’t had much opportunity tonight to jump into the comments. Let’s see what’s going on down there. | We haven’t had much opportunity tonight to jump into the comments. Let’s see what’s going on down there. |
| Trump is the GOP nominee. Frankenstein didn't like his monster very much either - too bad. | Trump is the GOP nominee. Frankenstein didn't like his monster very much either - too bad. |
| well said - Clinton, weak as she is and she must know it, has got to be thrilled with how this is working out; Kasich could actually have beaten her in the general election had the party not eaten itself | well said - Clinton, weak as she is and she must know it, has got to be thrilled with how this is working out; Kasich could actually have beaten her in the general election had the party not eaten itself |
| As an observer to this theatrical nonsense from the Republican Party, the only things that seem to appeal to crowd is, who is the biggest celebrity, who will give you the biggest gun, and who prays to God more than the other. America you really are in deep trouble. | As an observer to this theatrical nonsense from the Republican Party, the only things that seem to appeal to crowd is, who is the biggest celebrity, who will give you the biggest gun, and who prays to God more than the other. America you really are in deep trouble. |
| The winner - Fox News gets high ratings | The winner - Fox News gets high ratings |
| The Loser - The American People | The Loser - The American People |
| Donald Trump is getting fu**ed up tonight | Donald Trump is getting fu**ed up tonight |
| 4.16am GMT | 4.16am GMT |
| 04:16 | 04:16 |
| It’s proper to fist bump after a debate, everybody knows that. | It’s proper to fist bump after a debate, everybody knows that. |
| Rubio fist bumps https://t.co/UHIG0a75Ot | Rubio fist bumps https://t.co/UHIG0a75Ot |
| Update: Rubio was hoarse. Looks like he was trying to keep his germs to himself. Stand-up guy. | Update: Rubio was hoarse. Looks like he was trying to keep his germs to himself. Stand-up guy. |
| Rubio, who has a cold, misses a golden opportunity to get his rivals sick too https://t.co/8SyhncVAOm | Rubio, who has a cold, misses a golden opportunity to get his rivals sick too https://t.co/8SyhncVAOm |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 4.23am GMT | at 4.23am GMT |
| 4.09am GMT | 4.09am GMT |
| 04:09 | 04:09 |
| Rubio is taking some heat from the #nevertrump’s on the right for saying he would support Trump if Trump is the nominee. | Rubio is taking some heat from the #nevertrump’s on the right for saying he would support Trump if Trump is the nominee. |
| Really disappointed in @MarcoRubio right here. #NeverTrump | Really disappointed in @MarcoRubio right here. #NeverTrump |
| This is after championing #NeverTrump, labeling him a con artist and a defender of white supremacists. https://t.co/uV2l4sdlJF | This is after championing #NeverTrump, labeling him a con artist and a defender of white supremacists. https://t.co/uV2l4sdlJF |
| Having said that, I'm not confident Rubio will actually support Trump if he's the nominee. | Having said that, I'm not confident Rubio will actually support Trump if he's the nominee. |
| Key point: these pledges mean nothing. | Key point: these pledges mean nothing. |
| 4.04am GMT | 4.04am GMT |
| 04:04 | 04:04 |
| That’s it. There is some generally milling on the stage and oh look there’s Bill O’Reilly again. | That’s it. There is some generally milling on the stage and oh look there’s Bill O’Reilly again. |
| He’s interviewing Trump. Trump says the debate was “tough but fair.” Eric Trump and Melania Trump appear silently and straight-faced behind Trump like... props? | He’s interviewing Trump. Trump says the debate was “tough but fair.” Eric Trump and Melania Trump appear silently and straight-faced behind Trump like... props? |
| Trump calls Romney jealous. He says he did not have the “guts to run” for president and he’s a joke artist. | Trump calls Romney jealous. He says he did not have the “guts to run” for president and he’s a joke artist. |
| More on Romney. Why do you fill them with loathing? | More on Romney. Why do you fill them with loathing? |
| “I’m loved,” Trump says. | “I’m loved,” Trump says. |
| 4.01am GMT | 4.01am GMT |
| 04:01 | 04:01 |
| Closing statements | Closing statements |
| Kasich: Progress in Ohio. Rehabilitated minority community. I’ll fix Washington. I’ll send you power to fix your communities. Restore America. | Kasich: Progress in Ohio. Rehabilitated minority community. I’ll fix Washington. I’ll send you power to fix your communities. Restore America. |
| Rubio: Unusual election cycle huh. This is about opportunities. 21st century wow. Our children. Freedom. Prosperity. MarcoRubio.com | Rubio: Unusual election cycle huh. This is about opportunities. 21st century wow. Our children. Freedom. Prosperity. MarcoRubio.com |
| Cruz: I want to talk to soldier, sailor, airmen, marine, and families. Obama does not believe in you. That will end. And to the cops and firemen: I got your back. | Cruz: I want to talk to soldier, sailor, airmen, marine, and families. Obama does not believe in you. That will end. And to the cops and firemen: I got your back. |
| Trump: I’ll bring jobs back. Fix military. Care for vets. “You’re going to be very very proud of this country in just a few years.” | Trump: I’ll bring jobs back. Fix military. Care for vets. “You’re going to be very very proud of this country in just a few years.” |
| 3.59am GMT | 3.59am GMT |
| 03:59 | 03:59 |
| Concluding question | Concluding question |
| Last question of the night: Will you support the GOP nominee even if it’s Trump? | Last question of the night: Will you support the GOP nominee even if it’s Trump? |
| Rubio: I’ll support the Republican nominee, even Trump, because the Democrats have two people left in the race. A socialist and a person who lies to the families of the victims of Benghazi. | Rubio: I’ll support the Republican nominee, even Trump, because the Democrats have two people left in the race. A socialist and a person who lies to the families of the victims of Benghazi. |
| Cruz: Yes, because I gave my word that I would. I keep my word. | Cruz: Yes, because I gave my word that I would. I keep my word. |
| Kasich: Yeah, I kinda think before it’s all said and done, I’ll be the nominee. Look, when you’re in the arena, you enter a special circle. If he ends up as the nominee. Sometimes he makes it a little bit hard but you know I’m going to support whoever is the nominee. | Kasich: Yeah, I kinda think before it’s all said and done, I’ll be the nominee. Look, when you’re in the arena, you enter a special circle. If he ends up as the nominee. Sometimes he makes it a little bit hard but you know I’m going to support whoever is the nominee. |
| Trump is asked would he support the nominee even if it’s not him. | Trump is asked would he support the nominee even if it’s not him. |
| Trump: Even if it’s not me? Millions of millions of people have come to the Republican party... and Democrats are losing people. I’m very proud. The answer is yes I will. | Trump: Even if it’s not me? Millions of millions of people have come to the Republican party... and Democrats are losing people. I’m very proud. The answer is yes I will. |
| 3.56am GMT | 3.56am GMT |
| 03:56 | 03:56 |
| John Stoehr | John Stoehr |
| Maybe there has been a gentlemen’s agreement in place during this GOP debate. Tonight, Cruz and Rubio have attacked Trump, sometime very successfully. Trump has been on the defensive most of the night. | Maybe there has been a gentlemen’s agreement in place during this GOP debate. Tonight, Cruz and Rubio have attacked Trump, sometime very successfully. Trump has been on the defensive most of the night. |
| Meanwhile, Kasich has presented himself very well. His foreign policy answer was superlative. Could it be that Cruz and Rubio are trying to put Kasich out front? I can’t imagine a selfless Cruz, but maybe. | Meanwhile, Kasich has presented himself very well. His foreign policy answer was superlative. Could it be that Cruz and Rubio are trying to put Kasich out front? I can’t imagine a selfless Cruz, but maybe. |
| 3.54am GMT | 3.54am GMT |
| 03:54 | 03:54 |
| Last commercial break! Let’s hear it – who’s winning and who’s losing? | Last commercial break! Let’s hear it – who’s winning and who’s losing? |
| Donald Trump (paraphrasing): "I don't get sued often."From PACER ... pic.twitter.com/mGNPOydOMF | Donald Trump (paraphrasing): "I don't get sued often."From PACER ... pic.twitter.com/mGNPOydOMF |
| 3.53am GMT | 3.53am GMT |
| 03:53 | 03:53 |
| Kasich takes a question about a commercial his campaign ran tying Trump to Putin. Do you think Trump is naive about Putin? | Kasich takes a question about a commercial his campaign ran tying Trump to Putin. Do you think Trump is naive about Putin? |
| “I’m not biting,” Kasich says. “Let me just take you around the world,” he says. He’s cheered and applauded. | “I’m not biting,” Kasich says. “Let me just take you around the world,” he says. He’s cheered and applauded. |
| Biggest applause line of the night may have just been John Kasich saying "I'm not biting" | Biggest applause line of the night may have just been John Kasich saying "I'm not biting" |
| He goes around the world: | He goes around the world: |
| Russia: attack on Eastern European Nato member states is attack on us. | Russia: attack on Eastern European Nato member states is attack on us. |
| China: stop hacking us and pipe down in south China sea. | China: stop hacking us and pipe down in south China sea. |
| Egypt: they are on last legs. | Egypt: they are on last legs. |
| Jordan, Saudi, Gulf states: our allies who need support. Annnd... | Jordan, Saudi, Gulf states: our allies who need support. Annnd... |
| “We need good human intelligence.” Ding ding ding. | “We need good human intelligence.” Ding ding ding. |
| “Let’s call it a semi-trip around the world,” Kasich says. He has run out of time. | “Let’s call it a semi-trip around the world,” Kasich says. He has run out of time. |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 3.55am GMT | at 3.55am GMT |
| 3.52am GMT | 3.52am GMT |
| 03:52 | 03:52 |
| Jeb Lund | Jeb Lund |
| Someone like Ted Cruz, who is constitutionally incapable of exhibiting any emotions other than affected unctuousness or smug paternalism, should probably avoid coming across like a father on stage. | Someone like Ted Cruz, who is constitutionally incapable of exhibiting any emotions other than affected unctuousness or smug paternalism, should probably avoid coming across like a father on stage. |
| I mean, leave aside all the creeping discomfort of Ted Cruz reminding you of someone’s daddy; it’s just unbearably smug. Telling Donald Trump to breathe and count to 10 and behave like an adult is just such a weasel reaction. | I mean, leave aside all the creeping discomfort of Ted Cruz reminding you of someone’s daddy; it’s just unbearably smug. Telling Donald Trump to breathe and count to 10 and behave like an adult is just such a weasel reaction. |
| For one, Cruz has been just as much of a petulant child as anyone else not named Bush, Carson or Kasich over the course of the debates. For another, it’s like trying to sneak a burn in through the backdoor of the discourse. Ted Cruz loses when he tries to attack Trump head on, so he’s going to passively attack him by portraying him as a child and showing how much wiser he is for refusing to engage. But Cruz is engaging, while trying to seem above the same inane slapfight he regularly engages. | For one, Cruz has been just as much of a petulant child as anyone else not named Bush, Carson or Kasich over the course of the debates. For another, it’s like trying to sneak a burn in through the backdoor of the discourse. Ted Cruz loses when he tries to attack Trump head on, so he’s going to passively attack him by portraying him as a child and showing how much wiser he is for refusing to engage. But Cruz is engaging, while trying to seem above the same inane slapfight he regularly engages. |
| Once you get past the superficial shaming, he’s either a hypocrite or a wuss or, more realistically, both. | Once you get past the superficial shaming, he’s either a hypocrite or a wuss or, more realistically, both. |
| Is this patronising "breathe, breathe" from Cruz really going to win over any Trump supporters to his side? #gopdebate | Is this patronising "breathe, breathe" from Cruz really going to win over any Trump supporters to his side? #gopdebate |
| Updated | Updated |
| at 3.52am GMT | at 3.52am GMT |
| 3.48am GMT | 3.48am GMT |
| 03:48 | 03:48 |
| Trump on military, again: 'they'll do as I tell them' | Trump on military, again: 'they'll do as I tell them' |
| Rubio’s invited to say why he thinks Trump’s not qualified to be president. | Rubio’s invited to say why he thinks Trump’s not qualified to be president. |
| Rubio says Trump hasn’t shown seriousness about foreign policy. Rubio cites Trump’s earlier answer about the military doing whatever he says even if it’s extra-legal. “That’s just not true,” Rubio says. | Rubio says Trump hasn’t shown seriousness about foreign policy. Rubio cites Trump’s earlier answer about the military doing whatever he says even if it’s extra-legal. “That’s just not true,” Rubio says. |
| Trump has not shown “the intellectual curiosity or the interest in learning about these complicated issues,” Rubio says. | Trump has not shown “the intellectual curiosity or the interest in learning about these complicated issues,” Rubio says. |
| Trump’s reply: “I’ve gotten to know Marco. Believe me, he is not a leader.” | Trump’s reply: “I’ve gotten to know Marco. Believe me, he is not a leader.” |
| “Frankly, when I say they’ll do as I tell them, they’ll do as I tell them.” | “Frankly, when I say they’ll do as I tell them, they’ll do as I tell them.” |
| Rubio says Trump once again was pressed on a policy issue and could only attack someone by name. Then he lists pressure from North Korea, China, Russia, Iran and radical jihadists. | Rubio says Trump once again was pressed on a policy issue and could only attack someone by name. Then he lists pressure from North Korea, China, Russia, Iran and radical jihadists. |
| “You have yet to answer a serious question about any of this,” Rubio says. | “You have yet to answer a serious question about any of this,” Rubio says. |
| “Putin said very nice things about me,” Trump says. Then he says he had said, “Wouldn’t it be nice if we got along with the world and maybe Russia could help us?” | “Putin said very nice things about me,” Trump says. Then he says he had said, “Wouldn’t it be nice if we got along with the world and maybe Russia could help us?” |
| 3.46am GMT | 3.46am GMT |
| 03:46 | 03:46 |
| Here is Trump on targetting terrorists’ families: | Here is Trump on targetting terrorists’ families: |
| And here’s the second 15 minutes of the debate: | And here’s the second 15 minutes of the debate: |
| 3.44am GMT | 3.44am GMT |
| 03:44 | 03:44 |
| Mona Chalabi | Mona Chalabi |
| As the candidates discussed gun control, they began to get more detail focused. Donald Trump has said that he does not support the ban on assault weapons. | As the candidates discussed gun control, they began to get more detail focused. Donald Trump has said that he does not support the ban on assault weapons. |
| In December, we investigated the 20 shootings with the most fatalities in 2015 and found that most gunmen obtain their weapons legally. More specifically, we found that in three of those shootings, assault weapons had been used. | In December, we investigated the 20 shootings with the most fatalities in 2015 and found that most gunmen obtain their weapons legally. More specifically, we found that in three of those shootings, assault weapons had been used. |