This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/health/6132856.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Google 'aids doctors' diagnoses' | Google 'aids doctors' diagnoses' |
(about 4 hours later) | |
Using internet search engine Google can help doctors diagnose tricky cases, researchers have said. | Using internet search engine Google can help doctors diagnose tricky cases, researchers have said. |
A team of Australian doctors Googled the symptoms of 26 cases for a study in the New England Journal of Medicine. | A team of Australian doctors Googled the symptoms of 26 cases for a study in the New England Journal of Medicine. |
In 15 cases, the web search came up with the right diagnosis, the paper published on the British Medical Journal website reports. | In 15 cases, the web search came up with the right diagnosis, the paper published on the British Medical Journal website reports. |
The authors say Google can be a "useful aid", but UK experts said the internet was "no replacement" for doctors. | The authors say Google can be a "useful aid", but UK experts said the internet was "no replacement" for doctors. |
The internet is in no way a replacement for doctors Professor Mayur Lakhani, Royal College of General Practitioners | The internet is in no way a replacement for doctors Professor Mayur Lakhani, Royal College of General Practitioners |
Google is the most popular search engine on the web, with access to more than three billion medical articles - and searching for health information is one of the most common uses of the web. | Google is the most popular search engine on the web, with access to more than three billion medical articles - and searching for health information is one of the most common uses of the web. |
And while doctors carry a huge amount of medical information in their heads, they may need to seek further help if they come up against an unusual case. | |
'Unique symptoms' | 'Unique symptoms' |
In each of the 26 cases studied, researchers based at the Princess Alexandra Hospital in Brisbane selected three to five search terms from each case and did a Google search without knowing the correct diagnoses. | In each of the 26 cases studied, researchers based at the Princess Alexandra Hospital in Brisbane selected three to five search terms from each case and did a Google search without knowing the correct diagnoses. |
They then recorded the three diagnoses that were ranked most prominently and selected the one which seemed most relevant to the signs. | They then recorded the three diagnoses that were ranked most prominently and selected the one which seemed most relevant to the signs. |
The doctors then compared the results with the correct diagnoses as published in the journal. | The doctors then compared the results with the correct diagnoses as published in the journal. |
Google searches found the correct diagnosis in just over half of the cases. | Google searches found the correct diagnosis in just over half of the cases. |
These included (CJD) Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, the hormonal condition Cushing's syndrome and the auto-immune disorder Churg-Strauss syndrome. | These included (CJD) Creutzfeldt-Jakob disease, the hormonal condition Cushing's syndrome and the auto-immune disorder Churg-Strauss syndrome. |
The team led by Dr Hangwi Tang, a respiratory and sleep physician, said Google could be a "useful aid" diagnosing for conditions with unique symptoms and signs that can easily be used as search terms. | The team led by Dr Hangwi Tang, a respiratory and sleep physician, said Google could be a "useful aid" diagnosing for conditions with unique symptoms and signs that can easily be used as search terms. |
'Support' | 'Support' |
But they said a successful search needed a "human expert" user, and therefore patients would have less success trying to diagnose themselves on the internet. | But they said a successful search needed a "human expert" user, and therefore patients would have less success trying to diagnose themselves on the internet. |
They added: "Computers connected to the internet are now ubiquitous in outpatient clinics and hospital wards. | They added: "Computers connected to the internet are now ubiquitous in outpatient clinics and hospital wards. |
"Useful information on even the rarest medical syndromes can now be found and digested within a matter of minutes. | "Useful information on even the rarest medical syndromes can now be found and digested within a matter of minutes. |
"Our study suggests that in difficult diagnostic cases, it is often useful to google for a diagnosis. | "Our study suggests that in difficult diagnostic cases, it is often useful to google for a diagnosis. |
"Web-based search engines such as Google are becoming the latest tools in clinical medicine, and doctors in training need to become proficient in their use." | "Web-based search engines such as Google are becoming the latest tools in clinical medicine, and doctors in training need to become proficient in their use." |
But Professor Mayur Lakhani, chairman of the Royal College of General Practitioners, said: "The internet is in no way a replacement for doctors - their clinical judgement and expertise will always be necessary to make sense of the information. | But Professor Mayur Lakhani, chairman of the Royal College of General Practitioners, said: "The internet is in no way a replacement for doctors - their clinical judgement and expertise will always be necessary to make sense of the information. |
"Rather, it should be seen as a way of supporting doctors and their patients." | "Rather, it should be seen as a way of supporting doctors and their patients." |
A spokeswoman for the Patients Association said: "Doctors have a very wide knowledge when it comes to diagnosing conditions. | A spokeswoman for the Patients Association said: "Doctors have a very wide knowledge when it comes to diagnosing conditions. |
"But we would be concerned if they were using websites to diagnose people, what would happen if they gave the patient the wrong information? | "But we would be concerned if they were using websites to diagnose people, what would happen if they gave the patient the wrong information? |
"Also, a lot of sites are not credible. There are lots of good sites out there, but we also know that there are many that are not credible." | "Also, a lot of sites are not credible. There are lots of good sites out there, but we also know that there are many that are not credible." |
Previous version
1
Next version