This article is from the source 'guardian' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.theguardian.com/world/2016/feb/22/ukraines-eurovision-entry-takes-aim-at-russian-oppression
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Ukraine's Eurovision entry takes aim at Russian oppression | Ukraine's Eurovision entry takes aim at Russian oppression |
| (2 days later) | |
| The last Ukraine entry to the Eurovision song contest was a jolly, forgettable pop song called Tick Tock in which Mariya Yaremchuk urged her lover to “kiss and kiss me till I drop”. This year’s is, it’s fair to say, something of a gear change. | |
| On Sunday Ukraine chose a song about Joseph Stalin’s mass deportation in 1944 of about 240,000 Crimean Tatars, a horrific chapter that the nation’s parliament has described as tantamount to genocide. | On Sunday Ukraine chose a song about Joseph Stalin’s mass deportation in 1944 of about 240,000 Crimean Tatars, a horrific chapter that the nation’s parliament has described as tantamount to genocide. |
| Susana Jamaladinova, who performs under the stage name Jamala, was chosen on Sunday night by the combined votes of a three-person jury and 380,000 votes from viewers watching the televised final round. | Susana Jamaladinova, who performs under the stage name Jamala, was chosen on Sunday night by the combined votes of a three-person jury and 380,000 votes from viewers watching the televised final round. |
| Related: Putin's next strike could be anywhere in the world, warns Polish official | Related: Putin's next strike could be anywhere in the world, warns Polish official |
| The 32-year-old singer is herself a Crimean Tatar and has spoken of the importance of people knowing about the deportations. “The main message is to remember and to know this story,” she said. “When we know, we prevent.” | The 32-year-old singer is herself a Crimean Tatar and has spoken of the importance of people knowing about the deportations. “The main message is to remember and to know this story,” she said. “When we know, we prevent.” |
| Her song opens with the uncompromising lyrics: “When strangers are coming. They come to your house, they kill you all and say: ‘We’re not guilty … not guilty’.” | Her song opens with the uncompromising lyrics: “When strangers are coming. They come to your house, they kill you all and say: ‘We’re not guilty … not guilty’.” |
| Jamala’s great-grandmother was deported along with her four sons and one daughter. “This song really is about my family,” Jamala said. “I had to write it. It is a memorial song and it is difficult for me to sing it.” | Jamala’s great-grandmother was deported along with her four sons and one daughter. “This song really is about my family,” Jamala said. “I had to write it. It is a memorial song and it is difficult for me to sing it.” |
| Stalin’s government had accused Tatars of collaborating with Nazi forces who occupied the Crimean peninsula and in 1944 forcibly moved them from their homes to central Asia and other more remote parts of the USSR. Between 20% and 50% of the deportees died within the first two years of exile. | Stalin’s government had accused Tatars of collaborating with Nazi forces who occupied the Crimean peninsula and in 1944 forcibly moved them from their homes to central Asia and other more remote parts of the USSR. Between 20% and 50% of the deportees died within the first two years of exile. |
| But the song also feeds into contemporary geopolitical tensions, with Russia’s seizure of Crimea in 2014 still fresh in people’s memories. | But the song also feeds into contemporary geopolitical tensions, with Russia’s seizure of Crimea in 2014 still fresh in people’s memories. |
| One of the judges who chose Jamala’s song, the singer Rouslana, said the song “is precisely what we are all suffering in Ukraine today”. | One of the judges who chose Jamala’s song, the singer Rouslana, said the song “is precisely what we are all suffering in Ukraine today”. |
| Overtly political songs are not allowed in a contest best known for its kitsch, dodgy power ballads and bizarre gimmicks, not least Russia’s “Buranovo grannies”, who competed in 2012. | Overtly political songs are not allowed in a contest best known for its kitsch, dodgy power ballads and bizarre gimmicks, not least Russia’s “Buranovo grannies”, who competed in 2012. |
| A spokesman for the contest said a decision on whether to allow the Ukraine song would be made by the European Broadcasting Union’s reference group after 14 March, the deadline for all the songs to be submitted. | A spokesman for the contest said a decision on whether to allow the Ukraine song would be made by the European Broadcasting Union’s reference group after 14 March, the deadline for all the songs to be submitted. |
| “It is decided on a case-by-case basis,” he said. “Explicit political messages are not allowed in the songs, nor should they bring the contest into disrepute or have any commercial messages.” | “It is decided on a case-by-case basis,” he said. “Explicit political messages are not allowed in the songs, nor should they bring the contest into disrepute or have any commercial messages.” |
| If a song is judged to break the rules, the competing country might be asked to change the lyrics or the song itself. | If a song is judged to break the rules, the competing country might be asked to change the lyrics or the song itself. |
| In 2009 Georgia was asked to change the lyrics of its obviously anti-Putin song, We Don’t Wanna Put In. They refused and were disqualified from the competition. | In 2009 Georgia was asked to change the lyrics of its obviously anti-Putin song, We Don’t Wanna Put In. They refused and were disqualified from the competition. |
| In 2005, the Ukraine entry was deemed too political with its references to the then president Viktor Yuschenko. They were asked to change the lyrics, which they did. | In 2005, the Ukraine entry was deemed too political with its references to the then president Viktor Yuschenko. They were asked to change the lyrics, which they did. |
| This year’s contest will be held in Stockholm on 14 May. Organisers have promised the biggest voting changes since 1975, with the votes of a professional jury presented separately to the public vote. | This year’s contest will be held in Stockholm on 14 May. Organisers have promised the biggest voting changes since 1975, with the votes of a professional jury presented separately to the public vote. |
| That effectively means viewers will not know who has won until the very end, rather than having 20 minutes where it is obvious who has won while the nation-by-nation vote-gathering trundles on. | That effectively means viewers will not know who has won until the very end, rather than having 20 minutes where it is obvious who has won while the nation-by-nation vote-gathering trundles on. |
| Britain will be hoping to better its 24th position last year when Electro Velvet performed the jazz swing tune Still In Love With You. That at least was one better than Englebert Humperdinck’s 25th in 2012, and a runaway triumph compared to Jemini’s out of tune nul-points effort Cry Baby in 2003. | Britain will be hoping to better its 24th position last year when Electro Velvet performed the jazz swing tune Still In Love With You. That at least was one better than Englebert Humperdinck’s 25th in 2012, and a runaway triumph compared to Jemini’s out of tune nul-points effort Cry Baby in 2003. |
| The public will choose the British entry in an X Factor-style live competition on BBC4 on 26 February. | The public will choose the British entry in an X Factor-style live competition on BBC4 on 26 February. |
| • This article was amended on 24 February 2016. An editing error resulted in an earlier version saying that last year’s Ukraine entry was Tick Tock. That song was the last entry from Ukraine, in 2014, not 2015. |