This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2016/02/18/world/europe/infighting-could-dilute-british-lawmakers-push-to-leave-the-eu.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Infighting Dilutes Push in Britain to Leave E.U. | |
| (about 7 hours later) | |
| LONDON — Old-fashioned, upper class and with a habit of spouting Latin quotations, the British lawmaker and European Union critic Jacob Rees-Mogg is affectionately known in Parliament as the “honorable member for the early 20th century.” | LONDON — Old-fashioned, upper class and with a habit of spouting Latin quotations, the British lawmaker and European Union critic Jacob Rees-Mogg is affectionately known in Parliament as the “honorable member for the early 20th century.” |
| But with a referendum looming on Britain’s place in the union, Mr. Rees-Mogg and other Tory euroskeptics think that they are on the right side of history in pressing Britons to quit. | But with a referendum looming on Britain’s place in the union, Mr. Rees-Mogg and other Tory euroskeptics think that they are on the right side of history in pressing Britons to quit. |
| “The British people feel closer to the Americans than they do to the French,” said Mr. Rees-Mogg, 46, sitting in an ornate tearoom in Parliament, overlooking the Thames River. | “The British people feel closer to the Americans than they do to the French,” said Mr. Rees-Mogg, 46, sitting in an ornate tearoom in Parliament, overlooking the Thames River. |
| Yet, the euroskeptics are plagued by internal disputes, underscored by the presence of the Conservative prime minister, David Cameron, in Brussels this week trying to complete a deal on restrictions on welfare payments to migrants from other European Union nations and other sovereignty issues. Mr. Cameron hopes an agreement will enable him to campaign for his country to remain in the bloc. | Yet, the euroskeptics are plagued by internal disputes, underscored by the presence of the Conservative prime minister, David Cameron, in Brussels this week trying to complete a deal on restrictions on welfare payments to migrants from other European Union nations and other sovereignty issues. Mr. Cameron hopes an agreement will enable him to campaign for his country to remain in the bloc. |
| With the referendum likely to be held in June, the euroskeptics’ inability to coalesce around a single, clear message or leader is complicating their cause, even as their long-sought goal of ending Britain’s membership in the European Union is within reach. | With the referendum likely to be held in June, the euroskeptics’ inability to coalesce around a single, clear message or leader is complicating their cause, even as their long-sought goal of ending Britain’s membership in the European Union is within reach. |
| The internal spats extend beyond the Conservative Party to competing private groups representing rival ideological camps — free-market conservatives, like Mr. Rees-Mogg, and a more populist, anti-immigrant component embodied most visibly by Nigel Farage, leader of the nativist U.K. Independence Party. | The internal spats extend beyond the Conservative Party to competing private groups representing rival ideological camps — free-market conservatives, like Mr. Rees-Mogg, and a more populist, anti-immigrant component embodied most visibly by Nigel Farage, leader of the nativist U.K. Independence Party. |
| Because cabinet ministers who oppose Mr. Cameron on the issue are not yet free to argue to leave the union (they will be once the renegotiation is complete), so far the less senior euroskeptic lawmakers have been making the case. | Because cabinet ministers who oppose Mr. Cameron on the issue are not yet free to argue to leave the union (they will be once the renegotiation is complete), so far the less senior euroskeptic lawmakers have been making the case. |
| Advocates of a British withdrawal from the union constitute a lively and outspoken — if ill-disciplined — force. Naturally, they are not impressed with Mr. Cameron’s renegotiation: Liam Fox, a former defense secretary, has accused him of handing out the “political begging bowl.” Philip Davies, another Conservative lawmaker who favors leaving the bloc, calls the effort an “absolute shambles.” | Advocates of a British withdrawal from the union constitute a lively and outspoken — if ill-disciplined — force. Naturally, they are not impressed with Mr. Cameron’s renegotiation: Liam Fox, a former defense secretary, has accused him of handing out the “political begging bowl.” Philip Davies, another Conservative lawmaker who favors leaving the bloc, calls the effort an “absolute shambles.” |
| Mr. Farage’s U.K. Independence Party has come to prominence in the last decade, successfully capitalizing on concerns over immigration in European elections but not in those for the British Parliament. | Mr. Farage’s U.K. Independence Party has come to prominence in the last decade, successfully capitalizing on concerns over immigration in European elections but not in those for the British Parliament. |
| But the Conservatives have been split on Europe since before 1990 when Margaret Thatcher was pushed out as prime minister. She supported membership of the European Economic Community, as it then was, in Britain’s previous referendum in 1975, but became steadily more hostile to European integration. | But the Conservatives have been split on Europe since before 1990 when Margaret Thatcher was pushed out as prime minister. She supported membership of the European Economic Community, as it then was, in Britain’s previous referendum in 1975, but became steadily more hostile to European integration. |
| Her ouster in a 1990 putsch was partly caused by European policy, and her successor, John Major, was tormented by her supporters. | Her ouster in a 1990 putsch was partly caused by European policy, and her successor, John Major, was tormented by her supporters. |
| Even now, several years after her death, there is debate about how Mrs. Thatcher would have voted on exiting the bloc, a “spectacularly silly” discussion, according to Mr. Rees-Mogg, who ridiculed it by suggesting “a quick séance.” | Even now, several years after her death, there is debate about how Mrs. Thatcher would have voted on exiting the bloc, a “spectacularly silly” discussion, according to Mr. Rees-Mogg, who ridiculed it by suggesting “a quick séance.” |
| “Knock once for ‘yes,’ knock twice for ‘no,’ ” he said, before rapping twice on the table and announcing, with a grin, that Mrs. Thatcher had spoken from beyond the grave. “It’s ‘no!’ ” | “Knock once for ‘yes,’ knock twice for ‘no,’ ” he said, before rapping twice on the table and announcing, with a grin, that Mrs. Thatcher had spoken from beyond the grave. “It’s ‘no!’ ” |
| Mr. Rees-Mogg makes an economic case for Britain to go it alone, saying that Europe is narrowing Britain’s trading focus, “when we need to broaden it.” But he also highlights historical factors that, he says, set Britain apart, including that “it’s also a long time since we have, off our own bat, wanted to fight anyone in Europe.” | Mr. Rees-Mogg makes an economic case for Britain to go it alone, saying that Europe is narrowing Britain’s trading focus, “when we need to broaden it.” But he also highlights historical factors that, he says, set Britain apart, including that “it’s also a long time since we have, off our own bat, wanted to fight anyone in Europe.” |
| As for his personal style Mr. Rees-Mogg, who does not own a pair of jeans, believes that arguments, not “personal quirks” will decide the referendum. Anyway, he says, “I can’t suddenly pretend to be Mr. Trendy.” | As for his personal style Mr. Rees-Mogg, who does not own a pair of jeans, believes that arguments, not “personal quirks” will decide the referendum. Anyway, he says, “I can’t suddenly pretend to be Mr. Trendy.” |
| Not all euroskeptics are as entertaining as Mr. Rees-Mogg, perhaps because some have spent decades studying the subclauses of European Union treaties, regulations and other, mind-numbing texts. The best known and most knowledgeable of these is Bill Cash, a veteran lawmaker once derided by Mr. Major as “obsessive, driven and, on Europe, frankly a bore.” | Not all euroskeptics are as entertaining as Mr. Rees-Mogg, perhaps because some have spent decades studying the subclauses of European Union treaties, regulations and other, mind-numbing texts. The best known and most knowledgeable of these is Bill Cash, a veteran lawmaker once derided by Mr. Major as “obsessive, driven and, on Europe, frankly a bore.” |
| Mr. Cash has long worried about the erosion of national sovereignty. Younger euroskeptics also contend that European institutions lack democratic legitimacy, and that Britain’s history and common law legal system sets it apart. | Mr. Cash has long worried about the erosion of national sovereignty. Younger euroskeptics also contend that European institutions lack democratic legitimacy, and that Britain’s history and common law legal system sets it apart. |
| “We have different histories,” said Mr. Davies, the Conservative lawmaker. “The motivation for the European Union was, in a sense, to stop France and Germany from going to war with each other.” | “We have different histories,” said Mr. Davies, the Conservative lawmaker. “The motivation for the European Union was, in a sense, to stop France and Germany from going to war with each other.” |
| He added: “If France and Germany want to do that, good luck to them. But that wasn’t our history.” | He added: “If France and Germany want to do that, good luck to them. But that wasn’t our history.” |
| While Mr. Rees-Mogg, was educated at Eton College and Oxford University and is the son of the onetime editor of The London Times, William Rees-Mogg, Mr. Davies grew up in Doncaster, northern England, and was a supermarket manager before being elected to Parliament. | While Mr. Rees-Mogg, was educated at Eton College and Oxford University and is the son of the onetime editor of The London Times, William Rees-Mogg, Mr. Davies grew up in Doncaster, northern England, and was a supermarket manager before being elected to Parliament. |
| Mr. Davies’s main argument reflects a switch of emphasis made by euroskeptics in the last decade, when they began to argue that membership in the bloc was shackling Britain to an economic corpse. | Mr. Davies’s main argument reflects a switch of emphasis made by euroskeptics in the last decade, when they began to argue that membership in the bloc was shackling Britain to an economic corpse. |
| “Europe is an economic disaster zone, and unless we can start looking outwards, we are going to get nowhere,” Mr. Davies said. That argument has resonance because it relates to the central reason that Britain joined the bloc in the first place. | “Europe is an economic disaster zone, and unless we can start looking outwards, we are going to get nowhere,” Mr. Davies said. That argument has resonance because it relates to the central reason that Britain joined the bloc in the first place. |
| Back then Britain’s economy was stagnant and arguably needed the impetus of membership in a club that had helped France and Germany to thrive. | Back then Britain’s economy was stagnant and arguably needed the impetus of membership in a club that had helped France and Germany to thrive. |
| Now the roles are reversed, with Britain’s economy outperforming most of the Continent. | Now the roles are reversed, with Britain’s economy outperforming most of the Continent. |
| Euroskeptics are trying to reverse the common assumption that an exit is a leap into the unknown. Mr. Davies says the bloc is fated ultimately to “fall apart,” and Mr. Rees-Mogg suggests that it would be safer to stay “governed by our own democratic forms, rather than to be in a country called Europe, governed by a bureaucracy in Brussels.” | Euroskeptics are trying to reverse the common assumption that an exit is a leap into the unknown. Mr. Davies says the bloc is fated ultimately to “fall apart,” and Mr. Rees-Mogg suggests that it would be safer to stay “governed by our own democratic forms, rather than to be in a country called Europe, governed by a bureaucracy in Brussels.” |
| Meanwhile, Mr. Farage and others have campaigned against immigration into Britain from Eastern Europe, which surged after the expansion of the European Union. | Meanwhile, Mr. Farage and others have campaigned against immigration into Britain from Eastern Europe, which surged after the expansion of the European Union. |
| That happened after Britain decided to open its labor market immediately to new European Union citizens in 2004, unlike countries such as Germany and France, which exercised a right to delay their employment rights. | That happened after Britain decided to open its labor market immediately to new European Union citizens in 2004, unlike countries such as Germany and France, which exercised a right to delay their employment rights. |
| While Britain is outside the union’s passport-free travel zone, known as Schengen, euroskeptics argue that since Europeans have a right to live and work in one another’s countries, only by quitting the bloc can Britain control its borders. | While Britain is outside the union’s passport-free travel zone, known as Schengen, euroskeptics argue that since Europeans have a right to live and work in one another’s countries, only by quitting the bloc can Britain control its borders. |
| Indeed, the big dilemma for those who want to quit the union is how hard to push this argument. The two main groups campaigning for a “no” vote are rivals: Vote Leave, supported by most Conservatives, which emphasizes economic and sovereignty issues; and Leave.eu, which has the support of Mr. Farage and focuses on immigration and identity. | Indeed, the big dilemma for those who want to quit the union is how hard to push this argument. The two main groups campaigning for a “no” vote are rivals: Vote Leave, supported by most Conservatives, which emphasizes economic and sovereignty issues; and Leave.eu, which has the support of Mr. Farage and focuses on immigration and identity. |
| Other politicians know that while Mr. Farage might galvanize some voters, he is a divisive figure. That has led to feuding over which organization should be the approved “no” campaign. | Other politicians know that while Mr. Farage might galvanize some voters, he is a divisive figure. That has led to feuding over which organization should be the approved “no” campaign. |
| Whether these divisions matter to voters is unclear, and having several different messages might actually help the departure movement by allowing its campaign to reach different groups. | Whether these divisions matter to voters is unclear, and having several different messages might actually help the departure movement by allowing its campaign to reach different groups. |
| One seasoned European diplomat, speaking on the condition of anonymity following protocol, believes that in the end the divisions in the exit camp may not matter. Those who want Britain to remain in the bloc have a big battle on their hands, he said, because euroskeptics have tapped into a rich vein of British life. | One seasoned European diplomat, speaking on the condition of anonymity following protocol, believes that in the end the divisions in the exit camp may not matter. Those who want Britain to remain in the bloc have a big battle on their hands, he said, because euroskeptics have tapped into a rich vein of British life. |
| “It’s not just that Britons see themselves as different from the Continent,” he said. “It’s more that they really want to be.” | “It’s not just that Britons see themselves as different from the Continent,” he said. “It’s more that they really want to be.” |