This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/scotland/5336842.stm
The article has changed 6 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Version 4 | Version 5 |
---|---|
McKie experts 'offered job deal' | McKie experts 'offered job deal' |
(about 8 hours later) | |
Fingerprint officials at the centre of the Shirley McKie case have been offered a deal to leave their jobs. | Fingerprint officials at the centre of the Shirley McKie case have been offered a deal to leave their jobs. |
Public sector union Unison described the efforts to remove the staff from their posts as "harassment". | |
One of the experts told BBC Scotland that she believed she faced the sack if she did not accept the deal. | |
It comes as the parliamentary inquiry investigating the misidentification of Ms McKie's fingerprint heard from Scotland's Lord Advocate Colin Boyd. | It comes as the parliamentary inquiry investigating the misidentification of Ms McKie's fingerprint heard from Scotland's Lord Advocate Colin Boyd. |
The inquiry also took evidence from the justice minister, who said the £750,000 awarded to Ms McKie was less than the £1.2m the former detective had sought. | The inquiry also took evidence from the justice minister, who said the £750,000 awarded to Ms McKie was less than the £1.2m the former detective had sought. |
The former Strathclyde Police officer, from Troon in Ayrshire, was cleared of leaving a print at a murder scene in 1997. | The former Strathclyde Police officer, from Troon in Ayrshire, was cleared of leaving a print at a murder scene in 1997. |
She received an out-of-court settlement after being found not guilty of committing perjury, when she contested the opinion of experts from the Scottish Fingerprint Service. | She received an out-of-court settlement after being found not guilty of committing perjury, when she contested the opinion of experts from the Scottish Fingerprint Service. |
Unison will be talking to our lawyers, to the staff affected and to the staff as a whole Anne RussellUnison's regional officer | Unison will be talking to our lawyers, to the staff affected and to the staff as a whole Anne RussellUnison's regional officer |
Justice Minister Cathy Jamieson told the committee the settlement was made on the basis that there had been a misidentification of Ms McKie's print, but that no malice was involved. | Justice Minister Cathy Jamieson told the committee the settlement was made on the basis that there had been a misidentification of Ms McKie's print, but that no malice was involved. |
Unison said the officers involved in the case had now been offered early retirement, redundancy or redeployment within the police. | Unison said the officers involved in the case had now been offered early retirement, redundancy or redeployment within the police. |
It said the approach was made as part of an action plan to modernise the Scottish Criminal Records Office (SCRO). | It said the approach was made as part of an action plan to modernise the Scottish Criminal Records Office (SCRO). |
Experts Hugh Macpherson, Charles Stewart, Fiona McBride and Anthony McKenna and two colleagues are at the centre of the move. | Experts Hugh Macpherson, Charles Stewart, Fiona McBride and Anthony McKenna and two colleagues are at the centre of the move. |
Ms McBride told Newsnight Scotland said she had received an offer to terminate her employment. | |
"If it is not accepted, then I believe the chances are to be sacked," she said. | |
MSPs are examining how Ms McKie's print was misidentified | MSPs are examining how Ms McKie's print was misidentified |
Anne Russell, Unison's regional officer, said it was "outrageous" the offer should be made in the middle of a parliamentary inquiry into the matter. | |
She said: "Unless these threats are withdrawn, Unison will be talking to our lawyers, to the staff affected and to the staff as a whole to decide our next steps in backing our members' rights." | She said: "Unless these threats are withdrawn, Unison will be talking to our lawyers, to the staff affected and to the staff as a whole to decide our next steps in backing our members' rights." |
Lord Boyd told the inquiry that it was unlikely that any of the four officers who identified Ms McKie's print would be called as experts in court again. | Lord Boyd told the inquiry that it was unlikely that any of the four officers who identified Ms McKie's print would be called as experts in court again. |
He said any future case they were involved in would be overshadowed by their links to the McKie case. | He said any future case they were involved in would be overshadowed by their links to the McKie case. |
However, Ms McBride insisted she would not be taking any deal. | However, Ms McBride insisted she would not be taking any deal. |
She said: "I'm hoping that despite what he (Lord Boyd) said, the decision will be taken to put this off. | She said: "I'm hoping that despite what he (Lord Boyd) said, the decision will be taken to put this off. |
"I'm hoping that we will give evidence in court again." | "I'm hoping that we will give evidence in court again." |
'People's lives' | 'People's lives' |
Ms Jamieson was the 38th witness to come before Holyrood's Justice 1 Committee. | Ms Jamieson was the 38th witness to come before Holyrood's Justice 1 Committee. |
She told MSPs the settlement recognised the damage caused to Ms McKie and allowed her to move on. | She told MSPs the settlement recognised the damage caused to Ms McKie and allowed her to move on. |
But she said she also had tried to recognise the "very difficult position" of the four SCRO officers who had identified the print as Ms McKie's. | But she said she also had tried to recognise the "very difficult position" of the four SCRO officers who had identified the print as Ms McKie's. |
"I was acutely conscious of the fact these were people's lives we were talking about, not only Shirley McKie and her family but the SCRO officers," she said. | "I was acutely conscious of the fact these were people's lives we were talking about, not only Shirley McKie and her family but the SCRO officers," she said. |
She finished her evidence session by pledging to consider any recommendations the committee makes in its report. | She finished her evidence session by pledging to consider any recommendations the committee makes in its report. |