This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/uk_politics/7264740.stm
The article has changed 3 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 1 | Version 2 |
|---|---|
| Cameron steps into Sharia law row | Cameron steps into Sharia law row |
| (about 3 hours later) | |
| Conservative leader David Cameron has rejected any expansion of Sharia law in the UK, saying it would undermine society and alienate other communities. | Conservative leader David Cameron has rejected any expansion of Sharia law in the UK, saying it would undermine society and alienate other communities. |
| In a speech in London he said allowing two laws to work side by side would be dangerous adding: "All citizens are equal before the law." | In a speech in London he said allowing two laws to work side by side would be dangerous adding: "All citizens are equal before the law." |
| He also said "state multiculturalism" had produced "disastrous results". | He also said "state multiculturalism" had produced "disastrous results". |
| It follows comments by the Archbishop of Canterbury that adopting parts of Sharia law in the UK was unavoidable. | It follows comments by the Archbishop of Canterbury that adopting parts of Sharia law in the UK was unavoidable. |
| Dr Rowan Williams came under heavy pressure from traditionalists to apologise for the suggestion and has since insisted he was not advocating a parallel set of laws. | Dr Rowan Williams came under heavy pressure from traditionalists to apologise for the suggestion and has since insisted he was not advocating a parallel set of laws. |
| 'Different laws' | 'Different laws' |
| The archbishop said some remarks had been taken out of context and that what he meant was similar to Catholic agencies having special opt-outs on gay adoption. | The archbishop said some remarks had been taken out of context and that what he meant was similar to Catholic agencies having special opt-outs on gay adoption. |
| In his speech on "extremism, individual rights and the rule of law", Mr Cameron said British law already allowed individuals to settle private disputes in different ways - but under the ultimate jurisdiction of English law. | In his speech on "extremism, individual rights and the rule of law", Mr Cameron said British law already allowed individuals to settle private disputes in different ways - but under the ultimate jurisdiction of English law. |
| I believe that state multiculturalism is a wrong-headed doctrine that has had disastrous results David CameronConservative leader class="" href="/1/hi/uk_politics/7265386.stm">Analysis: Cameron speech | |
| He added: "If the archbishop was not talking about the status quo - about what already exists - the danger is that he was actually suggesting else - something more akin to different laws for different communities. | He added: "If the archbishop was not talking about the status quo - about what already exists - the danger is that he was actually suggesting else - something more akin to different laws for different communities. |
| "This would be dangerous and illiberal. It would be dangerous because in Britain, all citizens are equal before the law. That concept is absolutely fundamental to our democracy - itself developed and nurtured over centuries. " | "This would be dangerous and illiberal. It would be dangerous because in Britain, all citizens are equal before the law. That concept is absolutely fundamental to our democracy - itself developed and nurtured over centuries. " |
| 'Separate lives' | 'Separate lives' |
| In his first formal public comments on the row earlier this month he said an introduction of Sharia law for Muslims "wouldn't strengthen our society - it would undermine it". | In his first formal public comments on the row earlier this month he said an introduction of Sharia law for Muslims "wouldn't strengthen our society - it would undermine it". |
| He said it would alienate others not subject to "preferential treatment", demoralise Muslims who embrace liberal values and would provide "succour" to separatists. | He said it would alienate others not subject to "preferential treatment", demoralise Muslims who embrace liberal values and would provide "succour" to separatists. |
| Mr Cameron also criticised what he called "state multiculturalism" saying it allowed and encouraged people to "live separate lives, apart from each other and apart from the mainstream". | Mr Cameron also criticised what he called "state multiculturalism" saying it allowed and encouraged people to "live separate lives, apart from each other and apart from the mainstream". |
| "I believe that state multiculturalism is a wrong-headed doctrine that has had disastrous results. | "I believe that state multiculturalism is a wrong-headed doctrine that has had disastrous results. |
| "It has fostered difference between communities and it has stopped us from strengthening our collective identity. Indeed it has deliberately weakened it." | "It has fostered difference between communities and it has stopped us from strengthening our collective identity. Indeed it has deliberately weakened it." |
| He said any expansion of Sharia law was the "logical endpoint of the now discredited doctrine of state multiculturalism, seeing people merely as followers of certain religions, rather than individuals in their own right within a common community". | He said any expansion of Sharia law was the "logical endpoint of the now discredited doctrine of state multiculturalism, seeing people merely as followers of certain religions, rather than individuals in their own right within a common community". |
| It was not just the Conservative Party that wanted to move away from state multiculturalism - it was becoming the consensus view, he suggested - as seen in citizenship ceremonies introduced by the former Labour home secretary David Blunkett. | It was not just the Conservative Party that wanted to move away from state multiculturalism - it was becoming the consensus view, he suggested - as seen in citizenship ceremonies introduced by the former Labour home secretary David Blunkett. |