This article is from the source 'bbc' and was first published or seen on . It will not be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://news.bbc.co.uk/go/rss/-/1/hi/england/7263796.stm
The article has changed 2 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
Previous version
1
Next version
Version 0 | Version 1 |
---|---|
Autographs 'are fake' expert says | Autographs 'are fake' expert says |
(1 day later) | |
The signatures of sporting heroes on a range of memorabilia were faked, a handwriting expert has said. | The signatures of sporting heroes on a range of memorabilia were faked, a handwriting expert has said. |
Kim Hughes told Chester Crown Court there were significant differences between the forged signatures and autographs supplied by players. | Kim Hughes told Chester Crown Court there were significant differences between the forged signatures and autographs supplied by players. |
Graeme Walker, 45, of Connah's Quay, Flintshire, denies more than 50 counts of cheating the customers of his shop Sporting Icons in Chester. | |
Faisal Madani, 43, of Stockport, denies 20 counts of supplying the forgeries. | |
'Significant differences' | 'Significant differences' |
The pair stand accused of faking signatures of sporting figures Michael Owen, Steven Gerrard, Johnny Wilkinson and Ian Rush, among others on a range of memorabilia including shirts and photographs. | The pair stand accused of faking signatures of sporting figures Michael Owen, Steven Gerrard, Johnny Wilkinson and Ian Rush, among others on a range of memorabilia including shirts and photographs. |
Mr Hughes told the court that a framed number eight Liverpool shirt had the forged signature of Steven Gerrard written on it. | Mr Hughes told the court that a framed number eight Liverpool shirt had the forged signature of Steven Gerrard written on it. |
He said he had compared how the "s" and the "d" were written on the shirt with the signatures provided by the star. | He said he had compared how the "s" and the "d" were written on the shirt with the signatures provided by the star. |
"There are significant differences between this and the signed specimen from Steven Gerrard. This is not a genuine signature," he said. | "There are significant differences between this and the signed specimen from Steven Gerrard. This is not a genuine signature," he said. |
A handwriting expert admitted signatures could change | A handwriting expert admitted signatures could change |
When asked what his findings were when he examined the signature of Ian Rush on a 1977 European Cup Winners Liverpool football shirt, Mr Hughes told the court: "There is conclusive findings that that is not a genuine signature of Ian Rush." | When asked what his findings were when he examined the signature of Ian Rush on a 1977 European Cup Winners Liverpool football shirt, Mr Hughes told the court: "There is conclusive findings that that is not a genuine signature of Ian Rush." |
The court was also shown two England armbands apparently signed by Michael Owen but, after comparing the signature with those provided by the player, Mr Hughes said: "Those are not genuine signatures of Michael Owen." | The court was also shown two England armbands apparently signed by Michael Owen but, after comparing the signature with those provided by the player, Mr Hughes said: "Those are not genuine signatures of Michael Owen." |
But during cross examination Mr Hughes admitted that a person's signature could change. | But during cross examination Mr Hughes admitted that a person's signature could change. |
Paul Lawton, who is defending Mr Walker, asked if Mr Hughes's work with trading standards had compromised his independence with regards the investigation. | Paul Lawton, who is defending Mr Walker, asked if Mr Hughes's work with trading standards had compromised his independence with regards the investigation. |
Mr Hughes denied the claim. | Mr Hughes denied the claim. |
The trial continues. | The trial continues. |
Previous version
1
Next version