This article is from the source 'nytimes' and was first published or seen on . It last changed over 40 days ago and won't be checked again for changes.
You can find the current article at its original source at http://www.nytimes.com/2015/09/09/world/europe/britain-tries-to-deter-migrants-even-as-it-lets-more-in.html
The article has changed 4 times. There is an RSS feed of changes available.
| Version 2 | Version 3 |
|---|---|
| Britain Tries to Deter Migrants, Even as It Lets More In | Britain Tries to Deter Migrants, Even as It Lets More In |
| (about 4 hours later) | |
| SHEFFIELD, England — It may be the dreamed-of destination for many migrants in the wave now traveling through Europe, but Britain remains among the stingiest of European countries toward asylum seekers, and is even planning new measures to deter the flow of people determined to come here. | SHEFFIELD, England — It may be the dreamed-of destination for many migrants in the wave now traveling through Europe, but Britain remains among the stingiest of European countries toward asylum seekers, and is even planning new measures to deter the flow of people determined to come here. |
| British policy has been altered in recent days to make room for more refugees, reflecting the intense crosscurrents of the European debate over how to balance humanitarian response against an array of opposing forces, from domestic politics and budget concerns to nationalism and race. | British policy has been altered in recent days to make room for more refugees, reflecting the intense crosscurrents of the European debate over how to balance humanitarian response against an array of opposing forces, from domestic politics and budget concerns to nationalism and race. |
| Pressured by public outrage over the photographs of a drowned Syrian boy on a Turkish beach, Prime Minister David Cameron pledged Monday to take in 20,000 more refugees from Syria over five years — a commitment that was described as a “very slim response” by the archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, especially as France promised to accept 24,000 over the next two years and Germany talked of taking 500,000 a year. | Pressured by public outrage over the photographs of a drowned Syrian boy on a Turkish beach, Prime Minister David Cameron pledged Monday to take in 20,000 more refugees from Syria over five years — a commitment that was described as a “very slim response” by the archbishop of Canterbury, Justin Welby, especially as France promised to accept 24,000 over the next two years and Germany talked of taking 500,000 a year. |
| But Mr. Cameron’s Conservative government remains under intense pressure to restrict immigration, against the backdrop of a fight over whether Britain should remain in the European Union, whose stated commitment to the free flow of people has long been at odds with Britain’s desire to tightly control its own borders. | But Mr. Cameron’s Conservative government remains under intense pressure to restrict immigration, against the backdrop of a fight over whether Britain should remain in the European Union, whose stated commitment to the free flow of people has long been at odds with Britain’s desire to tightly control its own borders. |
| The rise of right-wing parties opposed to immigration and globalization, and growing public sentiment against bringing in more newcomers, has resulted in policies that make it difficult to enter Britain and even harder to secure asylum status once in the door. | The rise of right-wing parties opposed to immigration and globalization, and growing public sentiment against bringing in more newcomers, has resulted in policies that make it difficult to enter Britain and even harder to secure asylum status once in the door. |
| Many newcomers encounter meager benefits, tightly controlled living conditions, long waits for processing and a hard-line stance on what justifies asylum. | Many newcomers encounter meager benefits, tightly controlled living conditions, long waits for processing and a hard-line stance on what justifies asylum. |
| “Britain has probably become one of the harshest countries for asylum seekers in Europe if we think in terms of criteria like access to territory, refugee recognition rates, the administrative process, available benefits, and conditions of detention and removal,” said Alexander Betts, director of the Refugee Studies Center at Oxford University. | “Britain has probably become one of the harshest countries for asylum seekers in Europe if we think in terms of criteria like access to territory, refugee recognition rates, the administrative process, available benefits, and conditions of detention and removal,” said Alexander Betts, director of the Refugee Studies Center at Oxford University. |
| Still, the government plans more restrictive measures this autumn in a bill aimed at further deterring future migrants. Proposals include cutting benefits for asylum seekers, who now live on the equivalent of about $8 a day. Immigrants found to be working illegally would face six months in prison, and asylum seekers could be immediately deported. Companies hiring them would also be punished. | Still, the government plans more restrictive measures this autumn in a bill aimed at further deterring future migrants. Proposals include cutting benefits for asylum seekers, who now live on the equivalent of about $8 a day. Immigrants found to be working illegally would face six months in prison, and asylum seekers could be immediately deported. Companies hiring them would also be punished. |
| Britain has also decided not to adopt new European Union directives on the reception and protection of asylum seekers, which impose time limits on detention and grant them access to jobs. | Britain has also decided not to adopt new European Union directives on the reception and protection of asylum seekers, which impose time limits on detention and grant them access to jobs. |
| The high bar for securing asylum has come as a shock to some, like Huruy, 29, a former soldier from Eritrea who is appealing his denial. “I was angry,” he said at a center to aid asylum seekers in Sheffield. | The high bar for securing asylum has come as a shock to some, like Huruy, 29, a former soldier from Eritrea who is appealing his denial. “I was angry,” he said at a center to aid asylum seekers in Sheffield. |
| Like others interviewed, Huruy uses an alias because he fears deportation, though asylum seekers are allowed to stay while their cases are under appeal. | |
| A thin man with a deep crescent-shaped scar between his eyebrows, Huruy said he had been repeatedly warned of the dangers he would face fleeing to Britain: Eritrean border guards would kill him; smugglers would steal his money and leave him to die in the Sahara. If he made it that far, Islamic State militants in Libya would “chop his head off like a chicken,” or he would drown in the Mediterranean. | |
| He managed to survive those hazards across five countries, one desert and two seas, and was rescued after the Europe-bound cargo ship that carried him in December capsized. | He managed to survive those hazards across five countries, one desert and two seas, and was rescued after the Europe-bound cargo ship that carried him in December capsized. |
| But he was not prepared to be refused asylum by the country where he sought refuge, he said. | But he was not prepared to be refused asylum by the country where he sought refuge, he said. |
| He said he pleaded with the officers who found him hidden in a truck entering Britain through the Channel Tunnel that he was not an economic migrant, and that Eritrea, one of the world’s most secretive and repressive countries, was far from safe. | He said he pleaded with the officers who found him hidden in a truck entering Britain through the Channel Tunnel that he was not an economic migrant, and that Eritrea, one of the world’s most secretive and repressive countries, was far from safe. |
| “I’ve just escaped from a very, very difficult situation,” Huruy said. | “I’ve just escaped from a very, very difficult situation,” Huruy said. |
| His circumstances here as he pursues his case are hardly comfortable. He walked an hour to the asylum aid center because he could not afford the bus fare, and lives in asylum housing outside Sheffield. He wants to work, but cannot under British rules that discourage newcomers arriving merely for jobs. “I don’t know what to do,” he said of his free time. | His circumstances here as he pursues his case are hardly comfortable. He walked an hour to the asylum aid center because he could not afford the bus fare, and lives in asylum housing outside Sheffield. He wants to work, but cannot under British rules that discourage newcomers arriving merely for jobs. “I don’t know what to do,” he said of his free time. |
| The idea that asylum seekers “are sitting in refugee camps with a calculator in their hands, working out the benefits they’ll get if they choose to go to one destination rather than another, is far-fetched,” Mr. Betts said. | The idea that asylum seekers “are sitting in refugee camps with a calculator in their hands, working out the benefits they’ll get if they choose to go to one destination rather than another, is far-fetched,” Mr. Betts said. |
| Yet according to a recent poll published by the BBC, a majority of the public were in favor of Britain’s taking in fewer refugees, or at least maintaining current acceptance rates. | Yet according to a recent poll published by the BBC, a majority of the public were in favor of Britain’s taking in fewer refugees, or at least maintaining current acceptance rates. |
| Last year, Britain granted refugee status to 14,605 applicants, fewer than a third of the number granted by Germany and half of that granted by Sweden, according to Eurostat, the European Union statistics agency. France and Italy each granted refugee status to around 20,630 asylum seekers. | Last year, Britain granted refugee status to 14,605 applicants, fewer than a third of the number granted by Germany and half of that granted by Sweden, according to Eurostat, the European Union statistics agency. France and Italy each granted refugee status to around 20,630 asylum seekers. |
| Taking size into account, Sweden accepted 3,424 asylum seekers per one million of its population, compared with 218 for Britain, which puts Britain in 14th place among European Union countries when measured this way. | Taking size into account, Sweden accepted 3,424 asylum seekers per one million of its population, compared with 218 for Britain, which puts Britain in 14th place among European Union countries when measured this way. |
| Asked for comment, a Home Office spokesman said, “The United Kingdom has a long and proud history of offering sanctuary to those who genuinely need our protection.” | Asked for comment, a Home Office spokesman said, “The United Kingdom has a long and proud history of offering sanctuary to those who genuinely need our protection.” |
| Benefits and processing of asylum seekers vary widely among the 28 European Union countries, said Minos Mouzourakis of the Brussels-based European Council on Refugees and Exiles. | Benefits and processing of asylum seekers vary widely among the 28 European Union countries, said Minos Mouzourakis of the Brussels-based European Council on Refugees and Exiles. |
| According to data compiled by the group, single adult asylum seekers in Britain receive about 158 pounds, or about $240, a month, while Germany provides 354 euros, or about $395, although that number is to be reduced as part of changes pushed by conservatives. France provides €343.50 and Belgium €276. In Sweden, an adult asylum seeker receives 2,130 krona, or about $252, a month, but can also seek work. | According to data compiled by the group, single adult asylum seekers in Britain receive about 158 pounds, or about $240, a month, while Germany provides 354 euros, or about $395, although that number is to be reduced as part of changes pushed by conservatives. France provides €343.50 and Belgium €276. In Sweden, an adult asylum seeker receives 2,130 krona, or about $252, a month, but can also seek work. |
| In Britain, asylum seekers face immediate deportation if they seek work, to ensure migrants do not arrive for economic reasons, the Home Office said. In Germany and Austria, asylum seekers must wait three months before seeking employment, while in France, they can get temporary work permits. | In Britain, asylum seekers face immediate deportation if they seek work, to ensure migrants do not arrive for economic reasons, the Home Office said. In Germany and Austria, asylum seekers must wait three months before seeking employment, while in France, they can get temporary work permits. |
| Britain is the only European Union country where asylum seekers can be detained for an unlimited period while their applications are processed, Mr. Mouzourakis said. According to Home Office statistics, 40 percent of asylum seekers spend more than a month in detention. | Britain is the only European Union country where asylum seekers can be detained for an unlimited period while their applications are processed, Mr. Mouzourakis said. According to Home Office statistics, 40 percent of asylum seekers spend more than a month in detention. |
| Private contractors run seven of Britain’s 11 immigration detention centers, where migrants are under lock and key. In Germany, there are no special detention centers for asylum seekers, while France does not detain anyone for the purpose of examining a claim and limits detention to 45 days. Detention is not widespread in Sweden, but it has been used more in recent months. | Private contractors run seven of Britain’s 11 immigration detention centers, where migrants are under lock and key. In Germany, there are no special detention centers for asylum seekers, while France does not detain anyone for the purpose of examining a claim and limits detention to 45 days. Detention is not widespread in Sweden, but it has been used more in recent months. |
| Advocates for asylum seekers in Britain said the system was a challenge. Migrants file asylum claims in Croydon, near central London, and are typically detained in immigration removal centers while their right to entry is assessed. Some migrants are given housing, generally in the north, in towns like Sheffield. | Advocates for asylum seekers in Britain said the system was a challenge. Migrants file asylum claims in Croydon, near central London, and are typically detained in immigration removal centers while their right to entry is assessed. Some migrants are given housing, generally in the north, in towns like Sheffield. |
| Huruy and another Eritrean, Daniel, 23, live with others from Afghanistan and Iraq, each on his £5.28 a day. | Huruy and another Eritrean, Daniel, 23, live with others from Afghanistan and Iraq, each on his £5.28 a day. |
| Isaac, 52, from Nigeria, said he had saved for seven weeks to buy a shirt. “The whole asylum system is set up to make you so frustrated and so angry that you give up and you want to leave,” he said. | Isaac, 52, from Nigeria, said he had saved for seven weeks to buy a shirt. “The whole asylum system is set up to make you so frustrated and so angry that you give up and you want to leave,” he said. |
| Since 2012, housing has been provided through the security companies G4S, Serco and Clearel on government contracts, though last year the government auditors concluded that they lacked the required experience and arranged for “unacceptably poor” housing. | Since 2012, housing has been provided through the security companies G4S, Serco and Clearel on government contracts, though last year the government auditors concluded that they lacked the required experience and arranged for “unacceptably poor” housing. |
| Before privatization, in 2011, a parliamentary inquiry reported on families living in “poorly maintained, overcrowded accommodation infested with mice, cockroaches and other pests, rotting floorboards and locked windows.” | Before privatization, in 2011, a parliamentary inquiry reported on families living in “poorly maintained, overcrowded accommodation infested with mice, cockroaches and other pests, rotting floorboards and locked windows.” |
| John Grayson, an activist based in Sheffield, said of migrants, “They’ve gone through a horrendous journey, and these conditions exacerbate their trauma.” | John Grayson, an activist based in Sheffield, said of migrants, “They’ve gone through a horrendous journey, and these conditions exacerbate their trauma.” |
| A G4S spokesman, Nigel Fairbrass, said the parliamentary reports were outdated. He said any evidence that British standards “are not being met would be taken very seriously by both G4S and the Home Office.” | A G4S spokesman, Nigel Fairbrass, said the parliamentary reports were outdated. He said any evidence that British standards “are not being met would be taken very seriously by both G4S and the Home Office.” |